Oldy Mafia (Game Over, who won?)

[inHimshallibe]

Check your role pm you lazy bum.

If I give you my teammates, will you keep me alive until the end? [/small victories]

[Patrick]

Votecount

Porochaz (2) -- CrashTextDummie, inHimshallibe
Yosarian2 (2) -- Shanba, MrBuddyLee
inHimshallibe (1) -- ChannelDelibird
chamber (2) -- Yosarian2, Lord Gurgi
ChannelDelibird (6) -- Glork, chamber, Cogito Ergo Sum, Ythill, Ether, DrippingGoofball
Shanba (1) -- HackerHuck

Not voting: Porochaz
15 alive, 8 to lynch

Everyone in range has been prodded.

[DrippingGoofball]

If I give you my teammates, will you keep me alive until the end? [/small victories]

Totally, please list.

[Ythill]

UNVOTE: CDB
VOTE: Yosarian2

[inHimshallibe]

Did I miss a claim out of CES or something?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

You haven't missed any claims.

[inHimshallibe]

Scratch that, was thinking of CDB after all.

[Yosarian2]

Look, I am not going to win an argument with you.

But if you don't argue with me, then how am I supposed to figure out your alignment?

You've done a few things that feel town-ish to me. I like your analysis of Stark as pro-town based on some of his posts. For the most part, though, you just haven't done that much that I can use to read you. And when you finally do something that seemed odd and seemed like I might be able to use it to figure out your alignment one way or the other (that odd comment where, out of the blue, you said you thought me and Ythill were scum), you refuse to expand or explain when asked.

Right now, you're basically a big, fat null read, and have been for most of the game (as people commented on, I didn't mention you on my list of reads on day 1). I don't like that, I want to get a read on you; and if you're town, you want me to be able to get a read on you. But I can't do that if you won't open up and say whatever it is you're thinking.

Thanks for not answering some of my questions?

Huh? What question did you ask me that I didn't answer?

The only question that you asked that I noticed was "why didn't InHim get lynched"; and, I think I already answered that; at least from my point of view, it pretty much feels like inhim didn't get lynched because I decided not to lynch him at the end of day 1 yesterday.

[inHimshallibe]

If Glork then DGB is a pretty strong pair, I think.

[inHimshallibe]

Yos getting more Town by the post. Keep up the Gurgi suspicion. :thumbup:

[inHimshallibe]

@

Patrick

, requesting a week's extension, considering that due to holidays and people's exams, it seems we haven't gotten jack shit done in two weeks.

Or we could lynch CDB, who replaced in for god knows why.

Tell me, have you voiced a desire to lynch UT/CDB before? I'll go hunting.

[inHimshallibe]

@

Patrick

, requesting a week's extension, considering that due to holidays and people's exams, it seems we haven't gotten jack shit done in two weeks.

Or we could lynch CDB, who replaced in for god knows why.

Tell me, have you voiced a desire to lynch UT/CDB before? I'll go hunting.

Yeah, I'm not seeing this.

unvote
vote: MBL

Glork's more than likely right that one of {my, Yos', MBL's} wagons were on scum. Not me. Leaning not Yos now. Combined with the above, MBL seems like a fine vote.

[Yosarian2]

@

Patrick

, requesting a week's extension, considering that due to holidays and people's exams, it seems we haven't gotten jack shit done in two weeks.

Or we could lynch CDB, who replaced in for god knows why.

Tell me, have you voiced a desire to lynch UT/CDB before? I'll go hunting.

Yeah, I'm not seeing this.

unvote
vote: MBL

Glork's more than likely right that one of {my, Yos', MBL's} wagons were on scum. Not me. Leaning not Yos now. Combined with the above, MBL seems like a fine vote.

Mm. Yeah, I could see MBL as scum. His scumhunting so far this game has been kind of disappointing, and I still think it's odd he was voting nobody at all at the end of day 1.

[MrBuddyLee]

@

Patrick

, requesting a week's extension, considering that due to holidays and people's exams, it seems we haven't gotten jack shit done in two weeks.

Or we could lynch CDB, who replaced in for god knows why.

Tell me, have you voiced a desire to lynch UT/CDB before? I'll go hunting.

You missed the poor attempt at sarcasm. We don't particularly have any good reason to lynch CDB, because he chose to replace in for a lurker and then proceeded to disappear for two weeks.

Mm. Yeah, I could see MBL as scum. His scumhunting so far this game has been kind of disappointing

Why specifically has my scumhunting been disappointing this game?

and I still think it's odd he was voting nobody at all at the end of day 1.

Why specifically did you find that odd?

[MrBuddyLee]

Glork's more than likely right that one of {my, Yos', MBL's} wagons were on scum.

Why, specifically, is Glork likely right about this? Note, he retracted the Yos angle.

[inHimshallibe]

Glork's more than likely right that one of {my, Yos', MBL's} wagons were on scum.

Why, specifically, is Glork likely right about this? Note, he retracted the Yos angle.

Because if he's town, he has good instincts on things like this, and I tend to trust him.

Or if he's scum, he's feeding us just enough correct information to fly by the seat of his pants.

And you bring up a good point. I'd be down for lynching Glork posthaste if Yos turns up scum, and vice versa.

[inHimshallibe]

Also, just because Glork retracted something doesn't mean he didn't post in the first place.

[Lord Gurgi]

3) Are you suggesting that me and Ythill are scum together? Do you think that makes sense considering everything that's been going on this game?

This is a very strange conclusion to draw. Why would I be making scumpairs before we have any known scum? It's too easy to draw connections between any two players since everything is either distancing or buddying if you want it to be. So I don't really care too much what your relation is to each other till one of you is 6 feet under. Why do you ask this? Do you feel it's ridiculous to have you on the same team so one or the other only must be scum?

Fair enough. Just trying to get a feel for what, exactly, you are saying.

I see question marks, but okay.

[inHimshallibe]

3) Are you suggesting that me and Ythill are scum together? Do you think that makes sense considering everything that's been going on this game?

This is a very strange conclusion to draw. Why would I be making scumpairs before we have any known scum? It's too easy to draw connections between any two players since everything is either distancing or buddying if you want it to be. So I don't really care too much what your relation is to each other till one of you is 6 feet under. Why do you ask this? Do you feel it's ridiculous to have you on the same team so one or the other only must be scum?

Fair enough. Just trying to get a feel for what, exactly, you are saying.

I see question marks, but okay.

LOL, Gurgi doesn't want to really play the hardball with Yos.

unvote
vote: Lord Gurgi

You all can't hold me back any longer.

[Lord Gurgi]

I am aware that you think I'm scum, but what are you trying to point out? I've already said I don't want to argue with him, but that's not the point of that post. That's sarcasm, for what it's worth, or else I wouldn't have brought up his dodging my questions in the first place, would I?

Who's holding you back?

[inHimshallibe]

I GUESS it's sarcasm, but it's also extremely non-confrontational.

[CrashTextDummie]

I certainly agree with the pressure on CDB, he's a pretty bad lurker right now and we need to hear more from him.

If you agree with the pressure, why aren't you supporting it? Why have you ignored the player slot all game long? This looks like an unusual blind spot, to say the very least.

I'm having the opposite reaction to these last couple pages than inHim, at least when it comes to Yos.

---------

Please take note of how DGB completely and utterly ignored everything I said about her. She even ommitted me from her "scumputer doubter" list, even though I've made my stance on it very, very clear. If we're not lynching CDB for whatever reason today, it's gotta be her.

---------

CDB is stalling, IMO. He obviously had the 5 minutes to at least acknowledge the fact that he's in lynching range. Let's see if he finds the time for a claim at least.

unvote, vote: CDB

If this wagon falls appart because CDB is on indefinite V/LA, I swear I'm gonna rage.

[Lord Gurgi]

Uh, sorry? Sarcasm is passive-aggressive, so it won't be confrontational.

I guess no one is holding you back... When did you go completely crazy? DGB can you vig inHim?

[CrashTextDummie]

By the way, DGB, I'm afraid to pose the obvious question, but why did you claim vig completely unprovoked?

[inHimshallibe]

Uh, sorry? Sarcasm is passive-aggressive, so it won't be confrontational.

Yes, and it only reinforces my point.

I guess no one is holding you back...

Plenty of people I consider town have been putting you in their town columns. I've been quietly respecting that, but no longer.

When did you go completely crazy? DGB can you vig inHim?

Trying to make light of the situation in an attempt at deflection. Check.