Mini 1088: Cookie Thief Mafia (Game Over)

[lewarcher82]

@shotty: you were a lazy poster during day 1, meaning you were not very active and most of your posts were very short. However, this is not a strong scumtell. Would you consider suiciding right now in order to prove your claim? If not, why?

@furc: by all means, give us your damn flavour justification for your weak-voter feature, and answer rob.

All in all I would like both living GC's to give us their flavour names, since getting to know them would be nearly-impossible.

@everyone: who would be in favour of an early mc, who is against, and why.

1 out of 4 points got an answer. Waiting.

[Furcolow]

No way am I giving my name out, I feel it is very anti-town
Reason being is namefishing is similar to losing potentially for the town
What if the mafia had a scenario in which they won by us losing a certain player?
That is why I should have stalemated Rob, but the position I'm in right now I couldn't.

There would be screams for my head on an old, rusty pike if I was to actually oppose him after pushing the Poison lynch.
Look at it from my eyes, though:

1. Rob is town. I am a jackass for having exposed us all, but I will always view neighbors as null if it's 2 people. 3 people, however, and I feel like it is higher the % one of them is scum. I know I'm not scum, so the % it is Rob has gone up to 50% to you guys, and was already 100% to me. Him being scum or town is now like 80% Yes and 20% No for me, whereas I was 50-50 on him and Poison before. I knew I kept leaning towards it being Poison before, but to me this was like a chainlynch of Rob Capone, Godfather.

Lynch me, lynch Rob, whatever
if you don't lynch me, by God, I hope there is a medic or doctor out there to protect me

unvote
vote: rob

[FakeGod]

Vote Count 2.5

"That's a lot of posts." -mod

Darox (1): drmyshottyizsik
drmyshottyizsik (3): Darox, Llamarble, Elleran
RobCapone (1): Furcolow

Not Voting: andrew94, Zed, don_johnson, RobCapone, lewarcher82

With 10 players, it takes 6 votes to lynch someone.

[lewarcher82]

No way am I giving my name out, I feel it is very anti-town
Reason being is namefishing is similar to losing potentially for the town
What if the mafia had a scenario in which they won by us losing a certain player?
That is why I should have stalemated Rob, but the position I'm in right now I couldn't.

There would be screams for my head on an old, rusty pike if I was to actually oppose him after pushing the Poison lynch.
Look at it from my eyes, though:

1. Rob is town. I am a jackass for having exposed us all, but I will always view neighbors as null if it's 2 people. 3 people, however, and I feel like it is higher the % one of them is scum. I know I'm not scum, so the % it is Rob has gone up to 50% to you guys, and was already 100% to me. Him being scum or town is now like 80% Yes and 20% No for me, whereas I was 50-50 on him and Poison before. I knew I kept leaning towards it being Poison before, but to me this was like a chainlynch of Rob Capone, Godfather.

Lynch me, lynch Rob, whatever
if you don't lynch me, by God, I hope there is a medic or doctor out there to protect me

unvote
vote: rob

oh my god

[Furcolow]

basically, when i was trying to make a case in my mind for him being town... 1.
him being scum was going to be 2. but i couldnt even GET there

[drmyshottyizsik]

unvote
vote furc

blatant ate

[don_johnson]

sorry guys. working today and tomorrow. won't have time to get fully caught up. last minute xmas shopping is going to be a bitch. i would prefer to be able to post before lynch consensus is reached.

[Zed]

and furc's next post was I sent in shotty and chose you to make the action

@Furc- Why would you choose him to make the action if you are town? You probably knew that you were going to be around at the time the thread reopens. But why give someone who's alignment you supposably don't know control?

Furc should not reveal what person makes him lose his vote. Scum already has too much information, they don't need more. Anyone who thinks otherwise is getting FoSed by me.

no if i eat my cookie then i die and day continues, but it simulates a mislynch without a nk after it.

This does make sense... Shotty eating his cookie shouldn't count for both kills. And if it counts for the NK, then it shouldn't count for the lynch too.

At everyone- what is scummy about me, besides the mod's terrible name for me.

You're town play is just scummy. You are very pro-town when you're scum. Therefore, I'm not looking to lynch you right now.

[Elleran]

@Elleran:

For now, I will vote Shotty, who I believe is the most scummy right now.

How is he scummy? Except the name, I mean.

Mostly the name, tbh. :\ The name seems to actually have a relationship to the role, seeing "Pretty Patricia" was in the Girls Club and that "Odd Olivia" has 3 lives. (If he's telling the truth, which I think is true) Hungry Herold seems like a role with a kill ability. Sounds dangerous to me.

But I also think his play has been mostly unproductive. Even since day 1, he hasn't done much nor has he posted much opinion about many things.

@Furcolow: Yes, I believe that Andrew's claim is true. Here is my reasoning:
1. He wasn't in any pressure to claim, which means that he didn't really need to be creative, but he was creative regardless.
2. He claimed really early. If he is a scum, he wouldn't risk even fake claiming so early. Too risky.
3. I think the claim was a mistake... But still a claim regardless. I personally think it was a n00b-too-early claim.

I didn't vote Shotty for a quick lynch. I have a reason, like I said. (see above)

[Elleran]

No way am I giving my name out, I feel it is very anti-town
Reason being is namefishing is similar to losing potentially for the town
What if the mafia had a scenario in which they won by us losing a certain player?
That is why I should have stalemated Rob, but the position I'm in right now I couldn't.

There would be screams for my head on an old, rusty pike if I was to actually oppose him after pushing the Poison lynch.
Look at it from my eyes, though:

1. Rob is town. I am a jackass for having exposed us all, but I will always view neighbors as null if it's 2 people. 3 people, however, and I feel like it is higher the % one of them is scum. I know I'm not scum, so the % it is Rob has gone up to 50% to you guys, and was already 100% to me. Him being scum or town is now like 80% Yes and 20% No for me, whereas I was 50-50 on him and Poison before. I knew I kept leaning towards it being Poison before, but to me this was like a chainlynch of Rob Capone, Godfather.

Lynch me, lynch Rob, whatever
if you don't lynch me, by God, I hope there is a medic or doctor out there to protect me

unvote
vote: rob

Okay... So let me get this straight. You

finally

realized that Rob is a confirmed scum in your eyes and

now

you are voting him? I've been asking why you didn't see this before and you avoided the question and called it 'forced'. I don't understand your logic before.

P.S. I am a guy. Stop calling me 'she' or 'her' and look at my gender please.

[andrew94]

point is - a 3 town neighbour is too powerful, hence one of them is scum?
if so, why not furc be the scum???

[Elleran]

point is - a 3 town neighbour is too powerful, hence one of them is scum?
if so, why not furc be the scum???

Do you have evidence? Otherwise, that's just a speculation.

Unfortunately.

[Darox]

I wish I had a multishot day vig.

How about this:
drshotty kills himself.
We then lynch furcolow.

Quality of town improves by 400%

[andrew94]

^so you know that shotty can kill himself



INTERESTING

[Darox]

New plan.

drshotty kills himself.
We lynch Furcolow.
Then we nightkill andrew.

Quality improvement: 600%

[andrew94]

^ yea... 'we' nightkill

kkkkk

[Darox]

Newest plan.

Daykill: andrew

[lewarcher82]

This is interesting, Darox. What if it ends up with him surviving and you having practically proved you are a dayvig/daykiller?

@Elleran: you called shotty scummy, and then you have nothing more than his name and his lurking? You called HIM scummy, not his name. You better have more scumreads on him to share, otherwise you are definitely getting serious scumpoints for this.

[Darox]

Oh right, Andrew has that extra lifes claim bullshit.

Whatever, totally worth it.

[RobCapone]

[andrew94]

faking day kills is modkillable

but then again, I

could

modkill anyone for anything... -mod

k thanks bye

[RobCapone]

No it's not

[lewarcher82]

faking day kills is modkillable

k thanks bye

it sure isn't. I can post anything I want in bold fontface.

Seriously now:

mod: if the daykill is actually darox's skill, and if andrew actually HAS multiple lives, I do expect you to post flavour about the failed killing (cookie-stealing?) attempt.

[RobCapone]

And if the daykill is fake, I suggest a darox lynch cause fake daykills suck

[Darox]

Deleted by mod.