Mini 1088: Cookie Thief Mafia (Game Over)

[Elleran]

P-Edit, actually I believe Elleran. so far with what we've seen, a JOAT would make sense.
Elleran please provide evidence

P-Edit again

Why is darox town?
is that your evidence?

Here's Post 497.

So just like yesterday, I think we should lynch based on who is scummiest not who the GCs are.
VOTE: DAROX
He was scummy yesterday, coasting all the way through.

I don't understand this. How was he scummy yesterday? I believe Shotty is more scummy at this point than

Darox

.

@Shotty: I support you fullclaiming... But you should think before you claim, depending on what your role

is

.

And Hungry Herold... Perhaps it means he can one-shot vig by eating someone's cookie? He doesn't NEED to be a scum. He could be a

Townie

.

I hid this message there in case I was NK'ed and I didn't have a chance to reveal my findings.

Here's Post 788.

here is your evidence. Self vote since you are caught.

1. you want to lynch the person who is more productive and sensible to helping town catch scum
2. you are using WIFOM to explain your defense of Darox
3. outright believing andrew's claim is yet another one I will throw in there, his claim is completely unbelievable to me yet you seemed to accept it without any serious reservations

No, I'm not scum. I'm not going to self-vote, so you can forget that.

1) I'm not voting you because you're productive. I'm voting you because I want to vote for a GC member.
2) Is that scummy? Ignore my comment than. That WIFOM I made is basically irrelevent you know. I told you my stance, and I also told you that my reason is lame. Do you want to lynch Darox? Go ahead.

If he doesn't flip town, I'll eat my once-use, interent-access laptop.

3) I believe him because I don't see a reason why I shouldn't. If the only reason you think his claim is incredible is the imbalance issue with it, then that's not a very good reason either. I've had games in which the roles were horribly unbalanced. Trying to say "that's impossible because that would be imbalanced" is an easy mistake. Is there another reason why his claim is incredible to you?

That was another hint that I had a once-use ability. Last night, I investigated Darox because he was acting so strangely. It was an Alignment Investigation that is once-useable that involved using my 'laptop'.

[drmyshottyizsik]

unvote
vote furc

He's the only person who it would make sense to be scum right now... or don_johnson

[RobCapone]

Can you post reasons? You don't ever post reasons shotty

[drmyshottyizsik]

Furc's been scummy all along, I dont have time to make my case right now... sorry.

[RobCapone]

I agree about furc, but you have been scummy too

[drmyshottyizsik]

I know, but that's how I always play, scummy as town, towny as scum. Sorry

[RobCapone]

I will agree with that, the game you carried my ass you were very town

[Darox]

Oh hey it's dr realizing the wagon might swing back onto him, so he's wildly flailing about trying to lure it somewhere else before his bluff is called.

HOW ABOUT THAT, HUH?

[drmyshottyizsik]

I will agree with that, the game you carried my ass you were very town

Oh ya I for got about that game ))

We

I kicked ass

[Elleran]

Oh hey it's dr realizing the wagon might swing back onto him, so he's wildly flailing about trying to lure it somewhere else before his bluff is called.

HOW ABOUT THAT, HUH?

Darox, I tried to protect you, but you haven't exactly been making yourself look town at all. I had to claim now to protect and it's ridiculous. Start being productive and more input please. Trying to make up stupid excuses like "Gut-feelings" to try to justify why I was trying to protect you made me look scummy and you won't even try to look town.

[Elleran]

Look, guys. IMO, these guys are town: Darox, Shotty, Lewarcher, Andrew, Zed, and myself. I think 3 of the following are scums: Llamarble, RobCopone, Don_Johnson, and Furcolow. We should get one of people on my scumlist to be lynched today.

[drmyshottyizsik]

so let's lynch furc

[RobCapone]

How are lewarcher, Andrew, and zed clear?

[drmyshottyizsik]

andrew and zed will never be, but some one needs to examine them if they can

[RobCapone]

Zed has done nothing to help town

[drmyshottyizsik]

Yes, but furc is scummy

[RobCapone]

I don't disagree

unvote, vote furc

[drmyshottyizsik]

scummy scum is scummy

[Darox]

Oh hey it's dr realizing the wagon might swing back onto him, so he's wildly flailing about trying to lure it somewhere else before his bluff is called.

HOW ABOUT THAT, HUH?

Darox, I tried to protect you, but you haven't exactly been making yourself look town at all. I had to claim now to protect and it's ridiculous. Start being productive and more input please. Trying to make up stupid excuses like "Gut-feelings" to try to justify why I was trying to protect you made me look scummy and you won't even try to look town.

Why are you trying to protect me?

You've either got a cop read on me or you don't think I'm scum. That's all the justification you need.

I think forcing shotty to prove his role is in the best interests of the town. I am vocalizing this, and pointing out scummy actions shotty is doing to try and avoid having his bluff called. This is called being productive and providing input. Notice how I do not need bulletpoints or a wall of text to do so.

Your town/scum list smells terrible and unless you're claiming you have a supercop power it's nowhere near as black and white as you're making it out to be.

[FakeGod]

Vote Count 2.14

"New Year very soon." -mod

drmyshottyizsik (1): Darox
Darox (1): andrew94,
Elleran (3): lewarcher82, don_johnson, Llamarble
RobCapone (2): Elleran, Furcolow
Furcolow (2): drmyshottyizsik, RobCapone

Not Voting: Zed,

With 10 players, it takes 6 votes to lynch someone.

The new deadline is Jan. 7th, 2011!

[don_johnson]

Why is noone considering the idea that elleran is full of shit? Those are horribad crumbs. JOAT? Come on...

[Darox]

Hey Don John, have you considered the idea that we could lynch shotty, who is also full of shit, and then we either have a guaranteed scumlynch, or we can then go on and lynch someone else at no loss to the town?

[don_johnson]

Treestump is a rather genius fake claim. 3 player scum team would make this lylo if shotty is town. I think ell is better lynch atm.

[Darox]

Treestump is a rather genius fake claim. 3 player scum team would make this lylo if shotty is town. I think ell is better lynch atm.

No, 9 players - 3 scum =/= LYLO.

Try again.

[don_johnson]

Math isn't my strong point. Counted wrong. In that case, now would be the time to pressure.

unvote, vote:shotty

You're actually our most likely cookie scout atm.