Here's what has us bugged about AGar:
Early on, his policy vote on Singersigner didn't sit well with us, but we managed to chalk it up to RVS nonsense. In retrospect, though, he didn't pursue the SS vote any further after Thor provided a convenient reason to vote Powerrox, which AGar happily parroted while also laying down some weird FoS on Thor… immediately after agreeing with his position on Powerrox. You'll see in our first big catchup
post that we noted AGar's agreement with Thor's case on Powerrox caused us to raise our eyebrows. But he still leaves a door open to hop back on the SS wagon if need be, when given the opportunity later on
by Blood Queen.
His
original reason for voting Guderan was due to… well, we're not sure, exactly. He says it's because it's scummy to state how Gud expected a three-man scumteam to behave, but never explains why, exactly, that is scummy. We don't even think AGar believed it himself. That's why
Rhinox had to remind him to change his vote.
This is more speculation than anything concrete, but his
PBPA of SS/CC's back-and-forth has the potential to be "trying to appear helpful/town" instead of actual pro-towniness.
The way he quickly bails on this, as he puts it, "fruitful" wagon on Guderian
in the very same post where he votes for him
is complete and utter bullshit. He gives no reason in the post… he just narrows it down to four potential scum, then votes one of them. However, when he sees he can easily rejoin the Guderian wagon, first he
sits on the fence, then RANDOMLY shows up later on,
quotes one of Gud's posts, and just declares him as scum out of nowhere. He wanted to get his vote back on Gud, but didn't wanna catch any heat in wagon hopping so blatantly again, so he needed that "cushion" post to ease the blow.
By the end of D1, AGar had expressed a willingness to lynch Guderian, Singer, sims, and Blood Queen. He never took a hard stance on any one of them and instead remained mostly fluid, bouncing from wagon to wagon, until eventually feeling comfortable sitting on the Guderian wagon while still throwing suspicion towards everyone else should he need to make a quick escape. Then he has the gall to come in D2 and state… wait, just let me quote his
iso 24 for everyone:
AGar wrote:My top suspects are undecided at this point, for those wondering. I need to re-read this, as I feel I was potentially barking way up the wrong tree yesterday.
Translation: I'm scum who played like shit D1, so I need time to let the rest of you come up with another case for me to parrot and wagon.
Eventually, today, he laid down a vote on Carrotcake,
after
he had a wagon going on him and his hand was forced. Looking through his post, there is very little active scumhunting or case-making. It's mostly flippant declarations of who is scummy and who is townie with very little reasoning put behind it, or him being defensive, or some kind of meta/theory discussion. This is
not
how real townies play - this is how scumbags play when they're trying to appear town.
Dramatic confirmation vote, complete with waving of hands: AGar
._.
meeeeeeep?
