Oldy Mafia (Game Over, who won?)

[Ythill]

It wasn't put up for debate. The vig killed Yos.

This is a fact.

[ChannelDelibird]

Keep in mind that I'm not

just

saying these things at you so I can read you.

But fine.

Is the current wagon the only reason you're deciding to look at Huck specifically? Do you have an opinion on him

now?

I know. And while I appreciate the sentiment, I am quite aware of my responsibilities in this game. My point is that reading one-by-one is what I think is the quickest way I'll get to having an opinion on everyone.

As I may have hinted at yesterday, I haven't really noticed HH's presence too much so far. Skimming the game, I've seen posts at consistent intervals but he doesn't seem to be having much influence and doesn't seem to mind that. I feel he's more of an enigma than most. The current wagon is further reason to look at him first, but I think I would have done anyway.

---------

CES: No.

[Glork]

Ythill, who is YOUR current top suspect?

[Ythill]

Probably you or CDB. But that doesn't matter.

I intend to do some work here over the next few days. As that unfolds, I'll have a current suspect list.

[Porochaz]

CES is somehow trying to overtake Ythill in the who is most scummy stakes.

[Ether]

Glork's also town. He sucks too hard this game to be scum.

CDB could be scum, but I don't think it's really decipherable from his lurking so far.

[Ythill]

Like I said, I'll have more to discuss after putting some work into this game.

Two of my top suspects are now dead and were town. I need to rethink.

[Glork]

Yeah, rethink.... or, y'know, hang.

[Ythill]

I'm not going to be lynched.

[Glork]

Sure thing, champ.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Are you being dense on purpose, Glrok?

[Ythill]

You don't get hints, do you?

On current topics... either the scum don't have a RB or CES is town. Probably the former, since DGB was far from confirmed and a RB is as good as a rolecop vs. a claimed vig.

Also, the scum aren't very perceptive if they thought DGB was

actually

the vig.

[Ythill]

That last was directed at Glork. Just in case anyone else is too dumb...

Roleclaim: vigilante

[Shanba]

Morning!

Shoulda done this yesterday after unvoting Yos, but

Vote: Ythill

better late than never.

Have we seriously not managed to hit scum yet. Surely we ought to have got there just by weight of dead by this point. And there are good scumhunters in this game, too. 18 players, what, 4 scum? Ether is deftown, MBL is deftown. Which still gives me a huge field to pick from. So too early for process of elimination then.

Top picks are Ythill/Prozac, below that persons of interest who I want to look at are CES, a little bit hackerhuck. Given I've probably not picked out all 4 scum there's gotta be someone I'm missing, so I guess eventually I'll have to look at people like Glrok who I have vague concerns about but about whom I have reservations about them being scum: Glork is now in this category, as is chamber, cdb. Lord Gurgi and CTD are pretty townie. And the guy who I've inevitably forgotten from this list is defscum.

Hum. Inevitably the townreads die. How

annoying.

OH HEY PRE-POST EDIT

unvote ythill vote prozac

[Shanba]

[muse]4/18 are scum, pick 6 without replacement, what is the prob that all 6 are town[/muse]

[Porochaz]

Reasons?

[Shanba]

Reasons?

I do indeed have reasons.

[CrashTextDummie]

CDB, Porochaz, Glork. That's he people I'm willing to go for today.

vote Porochaz

I'll have a look at HackerHuck, I might be interested. I also have a feeling that chamber should be re-evalued in light of recent deaths.

[Porochaz]

Reasons?

I do indeed have reasons.

Well Im glad your sharing them so we can have a productive conversation about them.

[Ether]

Change of plans; Crash is probably scum. Not for his last post; more that I thought

he

was the vig, and if he's not, his behavior around DGB's been seriously fucked up.

[CrashTextDummie]

I find it

very hard

to believe that you thought I was the vig.

[Ether]

By the way, DGB, I'm afraid to pose the obvious question, but why did you claim vig completely unprovoked?

I'm getting strong DGB-Yos scumpair vibes.

Dum dedee dum dum, I'm not counterclaimed (mind you, vig counterclaims are usually settled with night fire).

In light of new developments, I don't think a CDB lynch is paramount anymore.

unvote, vote: Yos

[This post also advises the vig not to kill Shanba. I am aware of this and it did not give me pause at all.]

Then there's just a ton more of harassing the claimed vig. Now why would that be, and why on Earth would my conclusion surprise you at all?

[Lord Gurgi]

Counterclaims for Ythill?

Why is CES town if the scum don't have an RB?

I don't understand the HH thing. Or the Prozac thing. That said, all my scumreads are dead or have since claimed Vig...

And.... I CHOOSE YOU GO VOTE: CHAMBER

Getting on a plane tomorrow so expect a period of silence from me.

[Ether]

Between my roleblocker mixup and the knowledge that the scum killed DGB and not Yosarian, my thing about CES was just totally wrong.

[Glork]

Are you being dense on purpose, Glrok?

I'm not a big fan of this beating around the bush stuff. I see no reason for Ythill to go "I WON'T BE LYNCHED" without just saying he's the Vig. Ythill, instead of sitting there calling me dumb, please feel free to explain why you'd drop megahints without flat-out stating that you're the Vig to begin with.

I also find the claim to be completely unnecessary, but it's out of my hands at this point.

Also, the scum aren't very perceptive if they thought DGB was

actually

the vig.

She wasn't the vig, but she was still very obviously protown. There was really no reason NOT to kill her last night. Claiming Vig is completely suicidal as scum, and only minorly suicidal if you're a Vanilla Townie. Heck, I'd have pushed for it were I scum.