Mafia 125: Khan's Game of Mafia (Game Over)

[RedCoyote]

Oh, wait, I think it's shape up or ship out.

Sorry, I'm a little buzzed.

[Xtoxm]

Xtoxm, I'm not sure if this is alignment related or not but you suck. I'm sorry but you really do. You don't abandon posting and set up a ghost game in a large for 5 days out of a simple claim situation while being on site.

Also frustrated at PF's non-response so far.

I'm not sure why people think they're waiting for me, I have claimed. It is Antihero's turn.

• I choose one person each night
• I die if they are dangerous
• I chose Yabbaguy last night
• I live to to tell the tale
• Yabbaguy is not dangerous

I have no real objection to be being lynched, but I think it would be kinda dumb seeing as how i'm confirmable and all.

[DrippingGoofball]

Indeed.

We're not lynching Xtomx, nothing to see here, move along.

[iamausername]

Xtoxm, I'm not sure if this is alignment related or not but you suck. I'm sorry but you really do. You don't abandon posting and set up a ghost game in a large for 5 days out of a simple claim situation while being on site.

Also frustrated at PF's non-response so far.

I'm not sure why people think they're waiting for me, I have claimed. It is Antihero's turn.

• I choose one person each night
• I die if they are dangerous
• I chose Yabbaguy last night
• I live to to tell the tale
• Yabbaguy is not dangerous

I have no real objection to be being lynched, but I think it would be kinda dumb seeing as how i'm confirmable and all.

• You have claimed the 'Weak' modifier.
  
• You have not claimed the ability that it is modifying.
  
• That is what we are waiting for.
  
• It is not fucking difficult to answer this simple question.

[Xtoxm]

The Hider ability.

[iamausername]

Unvote

Thank you.

Ball's in your court, Antihero. What makes you think he's lying?

[Kublai Khan]

Official Vote Count

Players needed to lynch: 9

"Let me embrace thee, sour adversity, for wise men say it is the wisest course."

- William Shakespeare

Xtoxm

- 4 - nocase, inHimshallibe, Antihero, SpyreX

Antihero

- 2 - RedCoyote, Cyberbob

Dutch one

- 2 - PokerFace, Chevre

PokerFace

- 2 - Dutch one, Weatherman

SpyreX

- 1 - Korlash

Cyberbob

- 1 - curiouskarmadog

inHimshallibe

- 1 - Kmd4390

Players not voting:

Xtoxm, DrippingGoofball, yabbaguy, iamausername

Notes/Prods

:
- Prodding: Chevre
- Current Deadline: Seeeeecret. {There will be a 3 day warning}

[Weatherman]

@MOD

: I am voting Pokerface.
In case the missing colon was a problem, here we go again:

vote: Pokerface

Fixed.

[Antihero]

I'm a roleblocker. I blocked Seraphim (Xtoxm) last night. When this whole thing started, he game me the impression he got

results

which I knew was impossible. I guess all I did was make Xtoxm bulletproof.

UNVOTE:

[DrippingGoofball]

That makes it easy.

VOTE: Antihero

[Antihero]

^Said the scum

VOTE: DGB

[iamausername]

No, Antihero's behaviour still doesn't make sense from a scum point of view. His claim was not well thought out, but as a scum roleblocker, he'd know that Xtoxm wasn't lying and figure out how he could still think yabba was innocent despite being blocked. As a town roleblocker, he'd have much more reason to believe that Xtoxm could be lying and newsboy jump in with the counter claim without thinking through all the possibilities.

They're both town. Let's lynch Chevre instead.

VOTE: Chevre

[nocase]

it appears i've been gravely mistaken.

unvote. vote: inhimshallibe.

[nocase]

oh, okay.

unvote. vote: chevre.

[iamausername]

Fuckin' lol.

newsboy = brashly

Thanks, iPod autocorrect.

[nocase]

wait, no.

unvote. vote: cyberbob.

sorry.

[yabbaguy]

So xtoxm doesn't actually get a pm, but he lived, hence he thought he had taken a risk with me and lived. And I really lose confirmed status.

Vote Chevre

[SpyreX]

Hold up one second:

@Mod:

Would non-investigative roles (Hider, Bodyguard, Delayer, etc) be aware of the success of their actions?

[PokerFace]

I can't make the post I want right now (need to sleep proper nights, 2nd day at new work tomorrow morning), but guys:
READ THE POKERFACE ISO.
I'm starting to get bothered by the fact that he has never posted anything that doesn't feel like busywork.

vote Pokerface

His scumreads D1 (late replacement): Gorrad, werewolf, inHim.
Vote D2: Dutch man
Can you go more with the flow? with the rise of the Antihero wagon he stated was "considering looking at it" (what that even means I don't know) and commended iaun's post - town looks and decides or doesn't, but "considering to look" sounds exactly like a preparation to perhaps maneuver on.
end of D1:

is gorrad at 9 votes or 10 votes? I am considering dropping the hammer

beginning of D2:

Yo DGB I wasn't on any wagon at the end there. I was not all caught up. I did get caught up during the night though so thats all good. I wrote this during the last night. [etc]

Oh no I wouldn't have voted not caught up! Also, Katsuki was on Chevre, which DGB notes in the wagons analysis, and to which Pokerface replies with this misunderstanding; overly conscious on wagon placement.
Mostly I just get shivers from non-specifically explainable stuff; posts rich with using "questionable" instead of scummy (funny with the Dutch wagon starting with the fact that Gorrad was on Dutch's questionable list, not scummy list, Dutch mixing this up and PF bringing it up), "considering" to do things, being happy on the Dutch wagon waiting for Dutch's responses and generating content that looks like it's generated for the sole purpose of generating something, thoughts I don't think a person with a good scumdar would spout. His last post, as an example, is gut bad.

I honestly don't remember if I read katsuki's posts earlier. He is me so I already know what he is. No need to scumhunt I guy that is me. I think that may be why I didn't or at least didn't care too much about what he said. I don't think he was even paying attention to the game really

As far as whether I was or was not going to vote, caught up or not, well take a look at my posts up til that point. I was reading Gorrad as scum and I didn't think I was going to change my mind with how things were going. Both him and werewolf looked pretty bad and I didn't have really any other big reads. So yay part of me wanted to hammer so game would go to night and since their won't be game posts during night it would become way easier for me to get caught up

As far as busy work and saying I'd check anti and what not, well I've kinda been getting a bit bored waiting for dutch and what not. Dutch hasn't really done anything new so I've probably started to come off like a broken record there. So I've wanted to see if my vote would be better served elsewhere. Use it to find other scum since dutch obviously can't be the only one. Why I didn't look into it anti or some others yet, only answer I can give is general boredum spilling over and being busy in real life. I have never been replaced in a game and I think I've only been prodded during mass game prods in the past so I guess I didn't want to start, so I had to post something.

And if you are asking why check anti and not others well I wanted to check anti first seems he has been important to the current game state with his wagon and even more so now

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 0#p2814370
Bob's misunderstanding of CKD was reasonable, I can see how he might have missed what CKD was refering to, but what he said after it looked like a really bad reach. Like he was just searching for any reason to keep voting CKD. I am starting to loose the read I had on him earlier

Bob's post was merely stating a possible obvious scum motivation, perhaps no more likely than the town motivation, but I really don't see the reach.
"I'm staring to lose the read" bothers my gut.

Here's the thing though. Without bob's misunderstanding all he has is a possible motivation. A theory. Where's the backing for it? He jumped from A to point D without B or C. It felt like he was missing a step or reason to keep voting because the reason he gave when he voted was a misunderstanding.

PF, how can I pick a side when all I have are vague innuendos? Hell, who's to say they aren't both town?

Your point is valid and I am of the current thought they both are town, but the thought you portrayed earlier went after both of them so it was like you were saying they were both scum. It is possible that they are but I don't see how anyone could have jumped to a conclusion like that.

Aggressivity is the way to go about questioning things, I just can't feel this at all from RC's post.

The rest is not all that insightful either, sort of fluffy or stays on an obvious, superficial level.

Pokerface, you stated earlier you think you have a good guess who I am and based a townread on that hypothetical meta. Who am I and why town?

Then you and I understand aggressiveness on different levels. I usually only display agression towards those I think are scum and am trying to get others to agree with me. He went after both anti and xtoxm in that post, and that didn't make sence especially if he is considering them both to be town

Are you sure you want me to say who I think you are? If I'm right then what will you do? I'll tell you what, i'll say who I think you are but you don't need to say if I'm right or not. You obviously joined this game as an alt and you want to keep some animonity after all. Your playstyle feels alot like incognito's. I've played with him in a couple of games where he was town and you seem to have a simular style. Incognito hates playing as mafia and has stated as such on occasion as he doesn't feel he is good at it. If you were him and scum you definatly wouldn't be playing as you are. Though I suppose if you are him or not you haven't done anything that strikes me as scummy so I don't think you are scum whether you are him or not. I'm just even more certain you are town if you are incog

[Antihero]

Fuckin' lol.

newsboy = brashly

Thanks, iPod autocorrect.

The funny thing is that newsboy could actually make sense.

[Kublai Khan]

Hold up one second:

@Mod:

Would non-investigative roles (Hider, Bodyguard, Delayer, etc) be aware of the success of their actions?

Once their actions are submitted, I would not PM a Hider, Bodyguard, or Delayer to let them know if they were successful or not.

[SpyreX]

Bah, humbug.

Unvote, Vote: Dutch_one

[Antihero]

Why is it so hard for you all to see that DGB is scum?

She slapped the vote on me after my claim, thinking everyone would go "lolscumblocker" at my claim. Well, she misguessed this time. Since she doesn't give a reason why she thinks I'm scum (ever), I think we have scum.

[DrippingGoofball]

Xtomx is Xtomx, but what was the point of YOU claiming?????

That's why.

[Antihero]

Xtomx is Xtomx, but what was the point of YOU claiming?????

That's why.

Obviously hasn't read the thread