edmund.angles wrote:RQS: This is my sixth game over several years and I like playing all kinds of games and hiking.
I will confirm my random vote, zMuffinMan saying he knows who the scum are already is pretty absurd.
alsoFoS: sanchocolatesfor making a RQS even though it was not needed. At that point accusations had already started flying.
This post just struck me a little bit the wrong way, not really sure why. I enjoy RQS especially in games where I don't know the players that well and thought it odd you were ok with the fact "accusations had started flying." The accusations and votes to this point have been logical nightmares imo and from a mafia perspective you could have picked up on that and wanted to keep it going. As for knowing the 2 mafia being "pretty absurd", I found that to be a mafia reaction. Town tend to say, "Out your foses. How do you know that? How sure are you?". Regardless, just a hunch vote and there are better candidates today.
unvote
Ghostlin wrote:zMuffinMan wrote:andrew wrote:he knows why
Because you're scum and want me lynched?
I'm thinking C-Worl scum and andrew scum.
Also, policy lynching andrew is win/win even if he isn't scum.
Overtly hostile are we? Why is P-lynching Andrew win/win? A VI that is still town is still Town, isn't it?
This isn't the reaction I like to see after one pressure of a vote in RVS.
Also, scumpairs on Page 1. There'd be no concrete way you'd know that unless you were scum. It sounds like a splendid way to setup mislynches.
Unvote.
Vote: zMuffinMan
This post is the scummiest in the game so far. I get the feeling you are jumping on zMuffin-town for the first somewhat suspicious thing all day and are just push push pushing it. I mean take a step back and THINK if you are town. There is no way zMuffin "actually" knows 2 mafia on page 1. Its clearly not serious. The fact you are taking that comment serious is first-level mafia thinking or just really really bad town play. As for zMuffin, my intuition says he is a competent player and he still could be mafia, but it sure isn't for any of the reasons you or anyone else have been giving to this point. Overall I'm leaning town on Muffin, mostly because you are my top suspect.
Ghostlin wrote:
You called out two people as scum with absolutely no proof that either of them are scum. On page 1 of the game. It's not so much as the fact your connections to C-Worl and andrew now, there's no way to sustain that claim. None. There's no town reason to call people scum at this point of the game w/o some proof or suspicion. So either you're blowing smoke out of your butt during an RVS to see if you can get people to follow you, or you have access to information we don't. We being the townies.
It's more that you shouldn't have a reason to be lynch happy at this stage and shouldn't be calling a scum pair with nothing to substantiate such a claim.
RVS is essentially "blowing smoke out of ass" phase.
Amrun: is probably town although I disagree with most of his reads so far
Tragedy: I just completed a game with Tragedy as scum and my gut says she is town this game but will need more evidence to back this up.
C-Worl: is scummy. A lot of his posts have been to focus on lynching Muffin when I still have yet to seen anything that convinces me I should be voting Muffin.
GreyIce: I like his vote on Ghostlin, but could very well see this being distancing since there has not been a lot of support for a Ghostlin lynch til now and he probably doesn't think a lynch there is going to happen. I'll test the waters.
Everyone else: didn't notice enough to have anything worth saying yet.
vote: Ghostlin
My
