NY136: The Death of ReaperCharlie (GAME OVER, Town win!)

[Iecerint]

(Both last night AND today.)

[petroleumjelly]

No -- it can't even be his role. Which is why I am voting for him.

As explained in the Normal Guidelines, roles that can change somebody's alignment are explicitly forbidden in Normal Games. mastin2 just claimed a role that changes somebody's alignment from Serial Killer to Town. Therefore, either the set-up is illegal, or mastin2 is lying. I suspect the latter, although I have also sent the Mod a PM to confirm to us whether this set-up is legal for the purposes of a Normal Game.

[Iecerint]

Oh neat. I've never actually played a normal before.

[Iecerint]

Gosh, it's like a conf-boring game. You can't even have insane Cops? O_o

Oh well.

[Iecerint]

NO OFFENSE, MAFIA GODS.

[Meransiel]

No -- it can't even be his role. Which is why I am voting for him.

As explained in the Normal Guidelines, roles that can change somebody's alignment are explicitly forbidden in Normal Games. mastin2 just claimed a role that changes somebody's alignment from Serial Killer to Town. Therefore, either the set-up is illegal, or mastin2 is lying. I suspect the latter, although I have also sent the Mod a PM to confirm to us whether this set-up is legal for the purposes of a Normal Game.

Our luck is astonishing.

Vote: Mastin

Doctor on me, please.

[Parama]

vote: mastin2

YAY I CAN PUT OFF READING FOR A DAY

By the way all large normal setups get reviewed so the setup can't possibly be illegal.

[Iecerint]

Vote: Mastin

I WONDER WHO I SHOULD KILL NOW THO.

[Iecerint]

Kinda wish we'd waited to see if DH would claim SK...

[Meransiel]

Vote: Mastin

I WONDER WHO I SHOULD KILL NOW THO.

Try....NOBODY.

At least for 1 night.

[Parama]

That won't do much good :/

[Meransiel]

That won't do much good :/

Won't do much bad either.

The ONLY vig kills I would condone are you or DemonHybrid anyway.

[Parama]

And why would that be?

[petroleumjelly]

Hey Parama (and technically Meransiel, though I consider that question informally answered), MrBuddyLee asked you a question. Please answer it.

[Parama]

My excuse is that I still haven't read yet :U

[Meransiel]

At the time of that question, Iecerint.

Now, Parama or Demonhybrid.

And I will ask again, for the sake of it:

@everyone in the neighborhood: Do. You. Have. Any. Powers?

If you are doctor or powerless, please claim powerless. If you are not doctor nor powerless, please claim your power. And your target. And I will track you to see if you are telling the truth. Is it. That. Hard. To. Understand?

[petroleumjelly]

1.)

Meransiel, that's still a bad question. Even though you're a claimed tracker (which I will note does not necessitate you being Town, though I am presuming you are Town for today), now that you've claimed we also have to presume you have a high chance of not getting useful results if there exists a scum role-blocker. Alternatively, you might die overnight. And in either of those cases, having the Neighbors claim to sate your curiosity isn't really going to help us.

2.)

Parama, regardless of whether you have read, I just directed you to the question. So now you don't even have to search for it! And I'll even re-ask it here: what is your opinion of saporovirus?

[Parama]

PJ, the problem is I have no clue what this game is about. All my reads would be from page 10 or so. I WILL read eventually, hopefully sooner than later, but until then,

SCREW OFF.

[petroleumjelly]

EBWOP (and this is why I shouldn't do things from memory):

What is your opinion of saporovirus and Meransiel? Not that I expect the Meransiel portion of the question is entirely relevant at this junction.

[petroleumjelly]

Hi, Parama.

It's not my problem that you claim you haven't read past page 10. That's your problem. You had an extended Night to read over the game, and you are not doing yourself any favors by claiming you apparently haven't done anything at all during that time. Frankly, I don't entirely buy it -- at the very least, you have "skimmed up" the game, so I do expect you to "know what this game is about."

If you don't have an opinion on saporovirus right now, isolate her posts and give a tentative opinion. Then, when you claim you have finally "read" the game, give a full opinion.

I get that your "meta" is to be a complete asshole, and to be abrasive towards anybody who is not buddy-buddy with you. Fine. I'll deal with it. But you need to understand that I have to scumhunt and try to get a read off of you just the same, so I am not going to "screw off" and leave you alone just because you tell me to.

Man up and play the game. There is no excuse for you to not be caught up.

[MrBuddyLee]

@MrBuddyLee

, you seem to be asking far more questions than usual and giving far fewer opinions than usual. Could you explain why?

Spoiler:

MBL, I'm sorry if this offends you, but I feel like a vast majority of your questions accomplish little to nothing.

Do you ever even follow up on your questions, MBL?

other then the Ecto wagon, you haven't given much in the way of useful reads on people; a lot of interesting questions, but I don't know what, if anything, you've gotten out of the answers to all of those questions.

I meant in a very concise format instead of a wall. Walls have their place, but they also promote obfuscation. I want a one or two word read on him from you, MBL.

I just wanted to note this quote that is MBL saying he doesn't obfuscate as town after 200 obfuscating walls.

The questions are what catch scum. I'm undefeated as town since returning to MS (and I found at least 4 scum in the game I just got modkilled in.), primarily because I ask scum the questions that are difficult to answer. My old thought was that posting my stream of consciousness thoughts on who I think might be scum was helpful to town. I'm learning that most people here consider those to be useless and annoying.

I got lynched as town for the first time in three years, which was super lame considering I nailed both remaining scum in that game.

So I'm trying to cut back on the "fluff". I'm fine with answering questions.


My top suspect was Parama before Snow White/mastin apparently claimed scum.

@mastin

, why'd you claim that role now?

[Meransiel]

Meransiel, that's still a bad question. Even though you're a claimed tracker (which I will note does not necessitate you being Town, though I am presuming you are Town for today), now that you've claimed we also have to presume you have a high chance of not getting useful results if there exists a scum role-blocker. Alternatively, you might die overnight. And in either of those cases, having the Neighbors claim to sate your curiosity isn't really going to help us.

1. If I am roleblocked, I will obviously know that.
2. Almost all games that have a serial killer have a doc. And this is a Large. So nah, I don't think I will die.
3. Dude, I knew exactly what Iecerint did this night. We are either scumbuddies or we are both confirmed town.

[Meransiel]

I just wanted to note this quote that is MBL saying he doesn't obfuscate as town after 200 obfuscating walls.
The questions are what catch scum. I'm undefeated as town since returning to MS (and I found at least 4 scum in the game I just got modkilled in.), primarily because I ask scum the questions that are difficult to answer. My old thought was that posting my stream of consciousness thoughts on who I think might be scum was helpful to town. I'm learning that most people here consider those to be useless and annoying.

FWIW, I don't agree, I like your style now, but it was even better before.

Fixed tags... I think. -Amrun

[Meransiel]

@Mod: Sorry for the quote thing, again. Can you ?

[Iecerint]

^ Or you are a scum tracker.

Probably unlikely, though, as there was no need to out yourself like that under the present circumstances.