Mini 1203: Set's Speed Mafia - Game Over.

[Toast]

Eh, I didn't really expect to be convincing, I'm just trying to form my opinions right now.

Form opinions != make accusations. Unless you're trying to apply pressure and doing it badly.

[Beck]

So toast, since this is your first place for forum mafia, explain how live works, I never played live mafia. Didn't know it was possible

..It works exactly the same way as forum mafia, only instead of talking via forum, you sit in a circle and talk in real life. For night actions, everyone "falls asleep" and closes their eyes, and then the host tells mafia/cops/whatever to wake up in turn and they point to who they want to kill/investigate.

So why are you leaving out you have actually played forum mafia before on another site?

[Toast]

So toast, since this is your first place for forum mafia, explain how live works, I never played live mafia. Didn't know it was possible

..It works exactly the same way as forum mafia, only instead of talking via forum, you sit in a circle and talk in real life. For night actions, everyone "falls asleep" and closes their eyes, and then the host tells mafia/cops/whatever to wake up in turn and they point to who they want to kill/investigate.

So why are you leaving out you have actually played forum mafia before on another site?

I haven't.

[Beck]

So toast, since this is your first place for forum mafia, explain how live works, I never played live mafia. Didn't know it was possible

..It works exactly the same way as forum mafia, only instead of talking via forum, you sit in a circle and talk in real life. For night actions, everyone "falls asleep" and closes their eyes, and then the host tells mafia/cops/whatever to wake up in turn and they point to who they want to kill/investigate.

So why are you leaving out you have actually played forum mafia before on another site?

I haven't.

So why did you say you have in that newbie game?

[Toast]

I was probably lying? Give me a link to that post and I'll see if there was a good reason for it

[Beck]

Not sure if posting a link will get me mid killed but you were town cop and it was your first post ever on site

Why would you lie about your experience as town cop?

[Beck]

Mod, not mid

[Toast]

Not sure if posting a link will get me mid killed but you were town cop and it was your first post ever on site

Why would you lie about your experience as town cop?

For credibility. What kind of explanation are you fishing for, anyway?

[Beck]

You act like you are new to forum mafia
But you say you are not
You have played in 2 games on site, only the newbie game told you the roles
Generally forum mafia you have no clue what roles or how many mafia

What im getting at is why you acted like you were a noob and lied about it?

If you say as town cop u lied about your experience, I swear ill virtually smack you.

[SensFan]

Sens, the only justification you're giving for why you're so convinced Beck is scum is a list of his posts which you claim are obvious reads. I'm not as experienced as you, and I don't see how you could possibly be so convinced.

I'm not asking for you to understand how I'm so convinced; I'm not even asking you to be convinced yourself. I'm just asking you to vote with me. Thanks in advance.

I've also said it already, I don't see it in there and more explanation would help, instead of accusing me of being scum because I don't understand your (badly pointed out) reads yet.

Cool. I'll wait until the people with eyes read the post, then. I think I've been pretty clear that I'm not going to be holding anyone's hand here.

You're not going to hold anyone's hand but you're going to find all the scum for us?

Sounds about right.

Not sure if posting a link will get me mid killed but you were town cop and it was your first post ever on site

Why would you lie about your experience as town cop?

It doesn't matter if he's lying in this game, lied in that game, or is an alien with abysmal memory. He's Town in this game, so pick another mislynch target. Alternatively, take me up on my offer and start bussing.

P.Edit: Seriously, drop it. He's Town. Pick. Another. Mislynch.

[Beck]

Not sure if posting a link will get me mid killed but you were town cop and it was your first post ever on site

Why would you lie about your experience as town cop?

For credibility. What kind of explanation are you fishing for, anyway?

So this game you don't want to look credible?

[Beck]

Sens, stfu. Seriously.

[Toast]

Not sure if posting a link will get me mid killed but you were town cop and it was your first post ever on site

Why would you lie about your experience as town cop?

For credibility. What kind of explanation are you fishing for, anyway?

So this game you don't want to look credible?

I do. But I no longer have to pretend to have a history with this game if I actually have a history with this game. You're wasting time.

[Toast]

Sens, the only justification you're giving for why you're so convinced Beck is scum is a list of his posts which you claim are obvious reads. I'm not as experienced as you, and I don't see how you could possibly be so convinced.

I'm not asking for you to understand how I'm so convinced; I'm not even asking you to be convinced yourself. I'm just asking you to vote with me. Thanks in advance.

If you had spent a third of the time and energy you have spent on screaming scum at Beck on actually explaining why you think he's scummy, you'd have my vote

[Beck]

The only way you can know he is town, is if you are scum.

P.edit - since the game hasn't started, I have nothing but time to waste.

I point out things that don't make sense, let everyone decide on their own if its a scum tell or not.

[SensFan]

Sens, stfu. Seriously.

Nope. Not going to let you keep tunneling on this mislynch if I can help it. I want to see you jump on someone else, so I can find out if that person is a mislynch or a bus for you.

P.Edit: Toast, you're Town. Everyone who has two brain cells to rub together and is Town is calling you Town. You don't need to keep arguing with Scumbags.

P.P.Edit: 197

P.P.P.Edit: I know he's Town just like I know you're Scum.

[Beck]

Well you are wrong on me so does that mean you are wrong on him?

Shrug

[SensFan]

Well you are wrong on me so does that mean you are wrong on him?

Shrug

The fact that you keep insisting there's a chance that Toast is Scum isn't helping your case.

[Beck]

Beck. You never explained how Toast's 'slip' was not genuine to you, instead of it just being a null tell (Which it should be)
You claim Sensfan is scum for very bad reasons. No where do I see him trying to look like town. Humor is NOT a good tell for alignment. Also him saying you are lying is a null tell.

You say I'm sheeping, but I am merely agreeing with Sensfan's stance on you.

I took it more in line with twisted's jester comment. I didn't feel it was a genuine question, especially since he has been on site a long time.

P. Edit - the rule about on-going games is why

I've finished one newbie game and that's it (I signed up for a second game but had to leave). I know it doesn't really carry much weight to say "I'm too noob to trick you" but your point that I've been around for a while is moot

So are you experienced or are you noob?

If my point was moot, that would mean you are still a noob

Yet you claim to have experience elsewhere

Besides read posts 21,24, and 58

Those posts don't come from a noob.

You need to decide are you a noob or experienced?

[YankCane151]

Well you are wrong on me so does that mean you are wrong on him?

Shrug

The fact that you keep insisting there's a chance that Toast is Scum isn't helping your case.

Questioning someone != Insisting they're scum

[Beck]

Well you are wrong on me so does that mean you are wrong on him?

Shrug

The fact that you keep insisting there's a chance that Toast is Scum isn't helping your case.

Questioning someone != Insisting they're scum

BINGO

I have not once said he was scum. not once has that come out of my mouth.

i am trying to figure out how he can claim to be noob and than later claim he is experienced, all when lying about his experience.

He thought I was lying about my experience and voted me, REMEMBER THAT?

so when I question him about his exprience and how he has lied about it, you don't see that as a little bit of a CONTRADICTION?

[Toast]

Hold your horses, Beck.

You need to decide are you a noob or experienced?

What do you mean "I need to decide"? I have now played mafia both in forums and in live play. You tell me if this means I'm "experienced" or not.

He thought I was lying about my experience and voted me, REMEMBER THAT?

so when I question him about his exprience and how he has lied about it, you don't see that as a little bit of a CONTRADICTION?

I thought you were lying IN THIS GAME about your experiences. I was lying in A PAST GAME (and which I'm being honest about right now) about my experience. If you're of the lynch-all-liars persuasion, you should at least agree that whether or not you lied in a previous game has no relevance to this game.

[rblinker123]

I feel that Beck's probably more town. From what i've seen him play (although very little but) he's more of a aggressive player, i dont care what you think, sort of thing, it can rub off as scum but its not neccessarily.

SensFan: Your, I'll be dead tonight stuff is weird. Why did you need to buddy up with Beck, so he doesnt lynch you on the night. You dont no he's scum and half players hadnt confirmed, why do you feel you would be lynched first through the night.

Also Although atm i dont find much suspicion on Toast. I think it does matter if toast lied about the amount of games his played. Although it doesnt matter what happened in those games, in this game it seems he may be trying to pass himself off as a newbie, when this might not be the case. Why lie, was it simply a mistake or his he setting up a defence of im new here, incase things turn against him.

[Toast]

I think it does matter if toast lied about the amount of games his played. Although it doesnt matter what happened in those games, in this game it seems he may be trying to pass himself off as a newbie, when this might not be the case. Why lie, was it simply a mistake or his he setting up a defence of im new here, incase things turn against him.

You do realize that, in this game, I have not lied about how many games I've played?

[Beck]

Hold your horses, Beck.

You need to decide are you a noob or experienced?

What do you mean "I need to decide"? I have now played mafia both in forums and in live play. You tell me if this means I'm "experienced" or not.

He thought I was lying about my experience and voted me, REMEMBER THAT?

so when I question him about his exprience and how he has lied about it, you don't see that as a little bit of a CONTRADICTION?

I thought you were lying IN THIS GAME about your experiences. I was lying in A PAST GAME (and which I'm being honest about right now) about my experience. If you're of the lynch-all-liars persuasion, you should at least agree that whether or not you lied in a previous game has no relevance to this game.

1. it means that you are expereinced enough to not have asked that question, which is why like I said you don't get an automatically town read like others are doing.

2. how do we know you lied in that game and are not lying now? I can't think of a single reason why you would need to lie about your experience in a game where you are town cop and when you replace in there is not a single vote on you.

the other theory could be you were telling the truth there and are lying now.