NY136: The Death of ReaperCharlie (GAME OVER, Town win!)

[Meransiel]

Link me to a game with a scum tracker. I will wait.

[Iecerint]

I had a scum tracker on my scumteam in Kdub's Square Enix Gaiden: Outsiders. I think you were in that with me?

It's also my understanding that normal game site meta is also hedging toward putting "unusual" roles on scum because of a perception that it is wrong that people think that trackers are town or whatever.

THOUGH, like I said, don't think it applies here.

[Iecerint]

link'd.

[Meransiel]

Oh, damn...

[Meransiel]

Damn my prejudices...

[petroleumjelly]

Oh, I can one-up the Scum Tracker scenario: A Game of Thrones Mafia. I was playing as Confucius. I replaced in on Day Two, and my predecessor had actually tracked the Vigilante into making his kill. I tried to get the Vigilante lynched by arguing he was a Serial Killer, but after I decided I could put my thumb over his nightkills, I let him live.

In other words, I've not only seen (and played) a scum tracker, but I've played a game as a Scum Tracker who had a damning result on a Vigilante on Day Two. True story.

[Parama]

Example from a normal game, because examples from theme games are IRRELEVANT JUST FYI.

[Shanba]

Just for the record, I never actually said I had a town read on Parama, MBL. I do though, so I can answer your question.

Parama made the whole "KONDI TOWNSLIPPED" post which to me a pretty big towntell in and of itself. His attack on MoI was meeeeh, but whatever. I would like if he would pursue leads instead of "just throwing that out there" but again whatever.

I dont want to comment on the mastin thing before he posts, but I don't think he is scum (in fact I'm fairly sure he's town at this point.)

Vote saporovirus

[DemonHybrid]

I was hoping that this could wait until Demon had posted, but with the vig kill already known...

Claim: Psychiatrist

.

I didn't target anyone N1 because I asked the mod about what would happen if I targeted the SK, and the mod said they'd become a VT--and I wanted the SK to act like a true vig, for at least one night. Since we apparently have a vig AND an SK, now I can safely cure the SK.

Demon, you're the SK, right?

Could you be a good lil' SK and lynch Parama? You KNOW he's scum, right?

Vote: mastin2

[DemonHybrid]

I'm a real stickler with normal setups.

[DemonHybrid]

At the time of that question, Iecerint.

Now, Parama or Demonhybrid.

And I will ask again, for the sake of it:

@everyone in the neighborhood: Do. You. Have. Any. Powers?

If you are doctor or powerless, please claim powerless. If you are not doctor nor powerless, please claim your power. And your target. And I will track you to see if you are telling the truth. Is it. That. Hard. To. Understand?

You're just a role-outing machine, aren't you?

[Iecerint]

If there is scum in the Neighborhood, I doubt you'll find them by having them claim it first. Scum will change who performs the kill so that you don't catch them, or scum will disable you.

[Meransiel]

If there is scum in the Neighborhood, I doubt you'll find them by having them claim it first. Scum will change who performs the kill so that you don't catch them, or scum will disable you.

If a real power role outs and is killed, it is obvious that there is no scum in the neighborhood, otherwise they wouldn't take the risk. If a fake power role outs, I can catch him. If nobody says power role, then nothing really changes, cause that doesn't really narrow it down much for scum: I am outed, you are outed, the alien is dead, and I am a strong enough power role that town doesn't have roles stronger than mine (a game having both a tracker, an alien, a vigilante AND a cop is very meh).

[petroleumjelly]

Are your purporting to know what the Alien role does?

[DemonHybrid]

Alien's in the wiki. He roleblocks and rolestops the target.

Like a jailkeeper, but instead of protecting, he reverse-roleblocks anything but kills.

[petroleumjelly]

Hunh. I guess I should have looked it up. I just assumed it was something Amrun concocted within the boundaries of a Normal.

[saporovirus]

@MBL: I'm thinking mastin has to be scum due to 1) his claimed role being impossible (pending further discussion), 2) his choosing to not actually target anyone and 3) being like "DH IS THE SK HA HA SK PLZ KILL PARAMA." Could just be a joke, but why wouldn't he address that to the vig? Sounds like a cover for not targeting anyone.

[saporovirus]

vote: Mastin

[mastin2]

Claim: Mod-confirmable role.

I'll look at the votes, see how close I am to a lynch, and make the decision on whether to PM the mod and reveal.

@mastin, why'd you claim that role now?

Gambit to get Demon to claim SK. I'm convinced we've got a 1-1-1 neighborhood, but wanted Demon to confirm it. Asked the mod last night about a Psychiatrist, since I thought that it'd work.

But those blasted Normal Guidelines...

[Parama]

noooope.

[mastin2]

L-2.

Claim: Innocent Child

Sending PM to the mod.

[mastin2]

(For the record, voting order was
PJ -- town.
Meransiel -- town. [Obv-town before claim, conf-town after.]
Parama -- scum.
Iecrint -- town. [Vig.]
Demon -- SK.
Sapo -- HEAVY scum lean.)

[Parama]

unvote

I see no reason for you to lie about THAT except for LOLIJKGUISE reasons but the mod will tell us all we need to know anyways so

oh hey mastin just wondering why am I scum?

[DemonHybrid]

...a gambit to have me claim SK?

What are you, mad?

Unvote

Meransiel, I'm a town neighbor with no other powers. There. Now stop being absolutely batshit crazy. All of you.

[saporovirus]

unvote

vote: parama