Newbie 1170: DarthYoshi's Medieval Mafia! (Fin--Who won?!)

[DeasVail]

Shinki, what do you think about duck flipping town?

@Deas
I suspect Shinki. Because I played a lot with her and I don't see a town vibe from her game on day 1. However, that can be because she was very absent on this game. In any case, I'll see how the day develops.
Aside Shinki's meta... nothing, really. There are many little things to considerate but no great opinion formed, yet.

In my opinion, even the little things are worth discussing at this stage considering how quiet it is...

[Shinki]

That argument is only even plausible if you already suspect me. If you truly think I'm scum, what else have I done that's scummy? Don't just sheep DV's case, because none of what he is accusing me of is scummy in the least.

lol, sheeping DV case? You know, I voted for you before< him with my "reason", not explained, but it was there. :T

Shinki, what do you think about duck flipping town?

@Deas
I suspect Shinki. Because I played a lot with her and I don't see a town vibe from her game on day 1. However, that can be because she was very absent on this game. In any case, I'll see how the day develops.
Aside Shinki's meta... nothing, really. There are many little things to considerate but no great opinion formed, yet.

I am disappoint. with you, not duck
About duck, what else can I say? Only that there's scum riding his wagon.

[DarthYoshi]

Day Two, Vote Count the First

DeasVail (1): DaLetterEl
Shinki (1): Kirbyoshi
Kirbyoshi (2): Shinki, DeasVail
Not Voting (3): Fakinha, gamer, LyingBrian

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch and 4 to no-lynch.

The deadline is currently set for 8:00 pm Pacific Standard Time on November 8.

As ever, any questions or concerns, please let me know.

[Kirbyoshi]

Shinki, your "reason" for voting me was that sorgster, who is now confirmed town, suspected

you.

Do you seriously not see the backwards logic in that?

[DeasVail]

Shinki, your "reason" for voting me was that sorgster, who is now confirmed town, suspected

you.

Do you seriously not see the backwards logic in that?

Why are you saying that it was because of this?

It seemed fairly obvious to me that Shinki's reason for voting you was your suggestion that she's mafia and killed sorgster in the night.

[Kirbyoshi]

DV: It is simply much more plausible to think that Shinki killed sorgster than that I did. Use your thinking cap for crying out loud.

[Shinki]

Yeah, Kirbyoshi is scum.
Where's the IC? And everyone else?

[DaLetterEl]

Posting going to be limited for the next 3-4 days because of school stuff and parents coming to town for homecoming, but I don't know if that's a formal V/LA or not.

Just a heads up; will try to post something substantive tomorrow before they arrive though.

[DeasVail]

DV: It is simply much more plausible to think that Shinki killed sorgster than that I did. Use your thinking cap for crying out loud.

The sorgster kill was never the main reason that I suspected you, but it doesn't make me all that suspicious of Shinki either. I've asked this before and I'll ask this again: How seriously do you actually suspect Shinki and what are your reasons? Do you have thoughts on anyone else?

Yeah, Kirbyoshi is scum.
Where's the IC? And everyone else?

Shinki, what makes you so sure that Kirbyoshi is scum?

I agree with you regarding how quiet it is. Lyingbrian, gamer, your thoughts would be much appreciated.

[Shinki]

Maybe I don't wanna answer you, 'cause maybe you're his scum partner, and I don't like it
If you read the last page, that should be quite clear. (why I think Kirbyoshi is scum)

[Fakinha]

[
I am disappoint. with you, not duck

That's the kind of post that make me want to lynch you.

@Deas
Nope, sometimes it's better to keep some infos to yourself and do a better analysis. And it's really nothing much, I'm not giving the attention this game deserves. But I'm almost done with P4 =D. Love Adachi.

[Shinki]

Why? That's scummy of me?

[Kirbyoshi]

@DV: At first, my vote on Shinki was actually semi-random. Saw a little thing and went with it. But the fact is, she hasn't been real helpful. And when someone expresses their suspicion of her, she either responds with "oh, you suspect me, so you must be scum" or "lol, you're so stupid." I really wish she would at least post something of substance if she's town.

[Shinki]

@DV: At first, my vote on Shinki was actually semi-random. Saw a little thing and went with it. But the fact is, she hasn't been real helpful. And when someone expresses their suspicion of her, she either responds with "oh, you suspect me, so you must be scum" or "lol, you're so stupid." I really wish she would at least post something of substance if she's town.

Ahn.. nope, as you said, sorgster suspected me and he wasn't scum like you
Something of substance? You being scum is a big one.

[Kirbyoshi]

No it's not. Simply saying I'm scum is the exact opposite of substance...think of it as Mafia anti-matter.

[Shinki]

So, let's pretend that we believe in your "semi-random vote" at D2, then you saw it was a weak case for a vote (although it has been planned by you during the night) and decide to take one step further to make it not look so suspicious and actually looks like a 'case', you say "she's not helpful, I really wish she would at least post something of substance if she's town" says the substance guy, but this is hardly a decent reason for votes. Plus, that I "attack" everyone who suspects me, lol (not true, as I didn't said anything to sorgster even with his suspicion on me, you're starting making up stuff here) aaand yep, you're scum.

[gamer]

checking in I forgot about this game I shall now read the 10 pages

[DeasVail]

checking in I forgot about this game I shall now read the 10 pages

Thank you gamer

[Fakinha]

Why? That's scummy of me?

Yes, bot another kind of scum ;/

VOTE: Kirbyoshi

[Kirbyoshi]

Uh, guys...that's L-1. Don't accidentally hammer, k? Especially since I haven't seen a real case on me yet.

[DeasVail]

Lyingbrian, gamer, please share your thoughts...

Also, Fakinha why do you think that kirbyoshi is scum? Do you still suspect shinki of being scum?

Kirbyoshi, before the duckhunter lynch why did you ask everyone who they would suspect in the case of duckhunter being town/scum without providing your own thoughts? As I've asked before, What benefit was there other than for mafia collecting information for their night kill?

[gamer]

sorry I fell asleep >.< I will really read up now thought

[gamer]

actually tomorrow I may fall asleep again if I try now

[DarthYoshi]

Prodding LyingBrian.

[Fakinha]

@Deas
I don't really know, but if I were to take I move based from the posts, I think #240 is ok. And yes, I'm mostly sheeping...

But to be honest, my gut says Shinki is scum.

I will unvote so kirbyoshi leaves L-1, too early for sudden hammers.

UNVOTE: