Newbie #1185 (Game Over!)

[haycorn]

Cross my heart, I am not a VT trying to fake claim. I read that game too, and even if I hadn't, I know better than to fake claim.

[BBmolla]

Good.

Haycorn if lynching SOAD today wasn't an option, who would you want to lynch?

[Tierce]

Spoiler: Voting patterns

BBmolla - haycorn ^[2nd],

unvote by JK claim

,

fathom42

fathom42 - Tierce ^RVS,OMGUS, Sampson,

inte

haycorn -

SOAD

^{[3rd, now 2nd]}
inte - fathom ^OMGUS, Tierce,

unvote

Sampson - Cav ^RVS,

unvote

^[V/LA]
Shiidaji - haycorn ^RVS,

SOAD

^{[2nd, now 1st]}
syndromeofadown - Shiidaji ^RVS,OMGUS, Workdawg,

unvote

,

haycorn

Tierce - fathom ^RVS,

unvote

, inte ^[2nd], haycorn ^[3rd],

unvote by JK claim

Workdawg - SOAD,

unvote

^{[# voting position]}

Current vote if any.

Unvotes

marked when there's significant time or events between them and a new vote.
YMMV on OMGUS.
Didn't count Cav's RVS vote.

I have jumpy votes in a scummy bandwagon position.

SOAD, who are your scum reads?

[iamausername]

-=Vote Count #5=-

syndromeofadown (2) - Shiidaji, haycorn
haycorn (1) - syndromeofadown
inte (1) - fathom42
fathom42 (1) - BBmolla

Not Voting (4) - Sampson, inte, Tierce, Workdawg

5 to lynch.

Deadline falls in (expired on 2011-12-10 14:00:00)

[haycorn]

@BB- I don't have a scumread on any of the other players. I do find fathom's questions without much analysis from the first few days of the game worthy of concern, but I want him to have a chance to say his piece. I guess if I had to make a choice, it would be Sampson-- he said he'd have internet access and be able to post, but he hasn't. If it's just that he's busy, I can understand that, but he stopped posting right when the topic exploded, and that could be seen as an attempt to lay very low and let the town beat itself up.

@Tierce- You said "I have jumpy votes in a scummy bandwagon position." Do you mean "people are voting for me in a scummy, bandwagony sort of order" or do you mean "My analysis is that people are voting in scummy, bandwagony sorts of orders?" Am I totally misreading?

[Tierce]

@Tierce- You said "I have jumpy votes in a scummy bandwagon position." Do you mean "people are voting for me in a scummy, bandwagony sort of order" or do you mean "My analysis is that people are voting in scummy, bandwagony sorts of orders?" Am I totally misreading?

Oi, not at all. Talking about my own votes on others.

[haycorn]

Ah! Got it now. Thanks for clarifying.

[syndromeofadown]

The way I see it, there are two possible outcomes from this-

1. You don't believe me. You lynch me anyway. Maybe something turns up in the discussion that leads to a spark of thought that catches scum. You can start Day 2 and have more information to work with. Town benefits.
2. You believe me and lynch someone else. Maybe they are scum. I almost certainly get Nightkilled, but that means that if there's another power role, they stay alive for another night. Town benefits.

And what happens if you're not lynched and you don't die n1? This question isn't just for you, it's for the whole town. What are we prepared to do if haycorn survives to day 2? Do we believe her jailkeeper claim? huge wifom tommorow if you're still alive.

If haycorn is scum, it's most likely with an experienced player.

Care to explain this?

SOAD, who are your scum reads?

(in order from most suspicious to least suspicious)
scum-leaning
haycorn
sampson - It's a pretty sad day when the moderator has more posts and more content in this thread than one of the players. I realize you're on v/la but you better post something good when you get back!
fathom42 - for reasons previously given. Also he's kind of annoying me with the false-deadlines. I'm still willing to give him a chance if he stops lurking and posts something substantial, though.

neutral
workdawg - something's bugging me about him that I can't put my finger on. Not getting strong town vibes from him, but he hasn't done anything to warrant lynching him

town-leaning
tierce
shiidaji - the more I analyze his posts, the more townie he seems.
BBmolla - Didn't come off town at first, and I was confused as to why he had a strong town read on me and shii. Of course, after rereading the thread and trying to put myself in his shoes, I'm pretty sure I know where he's coming from and why he thinks what he thinks. Could be wrong though.
inte - gut instinct is telling me he's playing a bored townie.

[BBmolla]

Care to explain this?

Jailkeeper would be a wierd role for newbie mafia to fake claim. That's my only reasoning in regards to that.

In regards to SOAD not dying, it happens. Mafia sometimes get scared there's a doctor, which there might be. Sometimes mafia want to frame the claimed role. Or they're just mafia.

It really depends who does die.

You should switch to fathom though, we're not lynching a PR claim d1.

[Shiidaji]

I'm not really inclined to believe Haycorn's claim, but if anything now that she's claimed, she's under the threat of being NK'd anyway. So if that doesn't happen we can solve the problem later.

Shii why do you think SOAD is scum?

I'll admit my scumreads are rarely as good as my townreads (Led a D1 cop mislynch recently <__<;) , but...
It was mostly gut, lack of scummy reads on other players, and his OMGUS on me - "I'm voting you to appease you! But hey, this is still an RVS vote, amiright?".

Actually, the second point implies that one of my more null reads is probably scum. {Fathom/Sampson/Work}
I'd be willing to go on one of those three if SOAD/Haycorn pressure doesn't reveal anything more.


I'll be honest though, my scumread on haycorn is now bigger than the one on SOAD. Considering her claim (and my luck) though, I'm not really feeling good about lynching her either.




SOAD, who were you referring to in #105?

Swamped with schoolwork today and tomorrow, I'll have more time for this game on Wednesday

[BBmolla]

Actually, the second point implies that one of

my more null reads is probably scum. {Fathom/Sampson/Work}

I'd be willing to go on one of those three if SOAD/Haycorn pressure doesn't reveal anything more.

Shii please stop stealing my thoughts before I say them.

I am okay with lynching any of those three.

[inte]

Soad's point number 3 in post 176 is still bothering me. Igmeoy haycorn

[Tierce]

I have this game saved, still have to format it, will put it up when I'm done; might take a while.

[BBmolla]

Please do this game was one of my favorites D:

[syndromeofadown]

I think sampson and fathom are scum

vote: fathom

[Tierce]

I think sampson and fathom are scum

vote: fathom

I'm gonna do you one better and say two people who are not in the game are scum:

VOTE: LostGirlChan
VOTE: vijay2vasandani

[Tierce]

I think sampson and fathom are scum

vote: fathom

I'm gonna do you one better and say two people who are not in the game are scum:

VOTE: LostGirlChan
VOTE: vijay2vasandani

And you should all totally sheep me because I'm conftown.

[BBmolla]

Lol Vijay didn't even replace in yet.

And ninja'd

[BBmolla]

On the bright side this was probably the last really good newbie game I played, once I started ICing things started going downhill.

[Tierce]

On the bright side this was probably the last really good newbie game I played, once I started ICing things started going downhill.

The question is,

what

games did you IC?

Jedi mind tricks, y'all.

[Tierce]

Archived version of this game

Let me know if you spot errors in the file.


Quick summary: Town won by D2.

fathom42/LostGirlChan, mafia goon, lynched D1

BBmolla, Townie, killed N1

Sampson/vijay2vasandani, mafia rolecop, lynched D2

[Shiidaji]

Haycorn = Jailkeeper

Night Actions:

-N1-

Haycorn jails Tierce
Vijay kills BBMolla

End

---

This was a fun game.

[UberNinja]

On the bright side this was probably the last really good newbie game I played, once I started ICing things started going downhill.

Nah, I quite liked 1201.

[BBmolla]

On the bright side this was probably the last really good newbie game I played, once I started ICing things started going downhill.

Nah, I quite liked 1201.

Yeah it was good for you, I sucked pretty hard in it.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Last post.