Mini 301: Berry Kingdom Mafia II -- (Game Over!!)

[Turbovolver]

Among every player in this game, he has acted the least townlike, and the most scumlike, and that is even more than you sir, the claimed SK.

What

about Cherry's actions have been scumlike, or townlike? I'm not letting you get a free ride, here, because I think you are scum.

And good job admitting to dodging the question
You do realise it's hard for me to dodge an answer if you aren't giving one by dodging the question, right?

[Ameliaslay]

Perhaps Cherry should be replaced?

[Bacde]

Perhaps Cherry should be replaced?

Agreed.

[Lloyd]

After ~ 1 1/2 months (since April 17th) spent on Day 2, I'm starting to lose interest in this game.

At this point, I'm starting to lean toward just lynching Cherry. I'd rather not drag this game on any longer by waiting for a replacement.

If scums win, they've out-patienced me.

What do others think?

In addition, does anyone else want a mass claim?

[ziliu]

After ~ 1 1/2 months (since April 17th) spent on Day 2, I'm starting to lose interest in this game.

At this point, I'm starting to lean toward just lynching Cherry. I'd rather not drag this game on any longer by waiting for a replacement.

If scums win, they've out-patienced me.

What do others think?

I haven't lost patience in this game completely. Yet.

I'd say we let the mod at least respond to the request to replace Cherry. If we can't find a replacement, I'm up for just lynching Cherry.

[Yosarian2]

Yeah...I don't really want to lynch cherry without giving him (or his replacement) a chance to post, but I will if I need to.

[Bacde]

Blaaaaaaacckkberrrryyyyyy, wee neeeed youuu.

[Blackberry]

sorry, i've been really busy

8-12:45AM Sat Test (FUN STUFF!)
1-8:30PM Work (WOOHOO!)
8:30-11:30 Graduation Party
11:30-Night Sleeping After A Long Day

lol

it's 7:30 AM and im off to work again *YAY*

Anyways, I told Cherry he'd be replaced if he hadn't posted by Friday. So I'ma go shopping for a replacement ASAP

[Turbovolver]

I'm still around, waiting for a Cherry replacement and an answer from Bacde...

[Bacde]

I'm still around, waiting for a Cherry replacement

*SNIP*

Agreed.

[TheCesspit]

Still here as well. Though I do share Lloyd's frustration.

And why the snippy there, Bacde?

[Turbovolver]

Looks like he's still unwilling to tell us

why

Cherry is scummy.

[Blackberry]

/Ibaesha is replacing Cherry, sending her role now

[Blackberry]

Kanika Village Vote Count

[/color]

Ibaesha

:: (2) :: (Bacde, TheCessPit)

Ameliaslay

:: (1) :: (Lloyd)

Not Voting: Ibaesha, Turbovolver, ziliu, Ameliaslay, Yosarian2

Five Votes to Lynch.

[ibaesha]

Reading. Will post soonish.

[Blackberry]

I will probably set a deadline within the next few days.

[Kain]

@ Blackberry

Hey there's some really fatty delicious butter lathered popcorn for you in Mormon Mafia II....ya want it?

[ibaesha]

Alright. I've read through once to get a feel for things, but it's going to take a more thorough read and analysis. I would like to make a few comments/questions though.

1st: I have no explanation for my predecessor's lack of scum hunting and his lurking. As far as I can tell he was a lurking newb and there's really no defense for that.

2nd: Why was Lloyd allowed to drop a 4th out of 6 vote on page 1 and get away with it pretty much without question? His use of daykill was questioned, but not putting someone dangerously close to a lynch that early? I don't really care for the whole 'Scum wouldn't drop the final two votes' blah blah reasoning because it's WIFOM.

3rd: Why has Yosarian been declared practically innocent except for slight suspicions thrown by Lloyd? (This is the vibe I've gotten anyway) I don't really see much scummy by Yosarian, but the vibe is a bit strange. And if Yosarian is indeed as clean as he looks/has been treated, why has Lloyd cast suspicion there?

My apologies if there's answers to these questions and I just need to read more thoroughly but I know that you're all waiting for me to post something.... anything.

At this point I'm leaning towards Lloyd being scum that's managed to fly under the radar with his 'style'.

Ameliasay doesn't look too great either. She's pretty wishy washy and the entire, 'I'll let you know my suspicions' later rings major scum bells for me. Also noted that she defended Lloyd's behavior early on.

I think Bacde is either doing an incredible job as scum twisting things against the good guys or he is genuinely looking for scum. I'm pretty content to go with the latter for today.

Yosarian also looks pretty good, I am just skeptical of the 'cleared' vibe that surrounds him.

The Cesspit has been fairly contributive and analytical to the point of analyzing his own suspicions and retreating from them when he discovered they didn't add up. Looks pretty pro-town to me, although the same thing I said about Bacde could be applied here as well.

I'll go with a

vote: Lloyd

for now and give it a more thorough reading.

[Yosarian2]

I'll go with a

vote: Lloyd

for now and give it a more thorough reading.

Interesting. What do you think about Lloyd's roleblocker claim and supposed breadcrumbing, then?

[ibaesha]

Forgot about the roleblocker claim. Roleblockers can be scum neways. And his supposed breadcrumbing means nothing to me. Both scum and town can/will use that tactic.

[Bacde]

But you are forgetting he blocked a kill. I'd much rather lynch someone who hasn't at least proved some form of ability. There are much scummier players out there, IE your former self.

However, I will give you the benefit of the doubt and

Unvote

for now, seeing as you've probably sparked more discussion.

[Yosarian2]

But you are forgetting he blocked a kill.

Well, we don't know that for sure. If CA told the truth (and there's no real reason to assume that he did), then last night both scum groups targeted the same person, so there would have only been one kill no matter if Lloyd told the truth or not.

Still, if Lloyd really is a roleblocker, then he might be the biggest power-role the town has left, and one that's really useful in this kind of situation; one blocked attempt to kill a townie tonight would put the town into a much better spot mathmatically speaking.

[Lloyd]

ibaesha,

No counter claim of masonship from you then.

There was only 1 kill type last night. If multiple scum groups targetted Coron and succeeded, Coron probably would have been bashed and crushed.

Based on lack of responses about my question earlier about a mass claim, I guess that's a consensus no.

[ibaesha]

unvote

No counterclaim on masonship.

[Bacde]

unvote

No counterclaim on masonship.

Interesting. You seem to be the only one here that truly was willing to vote for Lloyd at this point in the game. I'd really like to know what made you think he was the most likely scum candidate.