Weather Mafia II (GAME OVER)

[Shadoweh]

Just ignore it. The kills are meant to make us wonder. Probability alone says those two were town. Then you actually look at who they were.

##Vote: Kuribo

One of Kuribo or Untrod Tripod is scum. Discuss.

[Untrod Tripod]

how did you come to that conclusion?

[Shadoweh]

You've voted one after the other on every single wagon. I'm pretty sure kuribo is the one that's been following your vote.

[Untrod Tripod]

so your argument is that one of us but not both of us is scum because our votes are in proximity often?

[Thestatusquo]

vote amrun

Will make an in depth case sometime today.

[Amrun]

VOTE: Porochaz

I get the feeling that he's some sort of organic scum.

[Shadoweh]

so your argument is that one of us but not both of us is scum because our votes are in proximity often?

My argument is you've both bandwagoned every lynch. Analysis alone says one of you should be a different color from the rest of us. Before yesterday it was you, kuribo and Staeg, but you're both hugging on the Staeg wagon too.

What do you think of kuribo, UT?

[Shadoweh]

VOTE: Porochaz

I get the feeling that he's some sort of organic scum.

Could you explain this feeling with perhaps anything. I don't recall if you've ever mentioned Porochaz. Being organic has nothing to do with being scum either.

[Amrun]

The thing that makes me think Poro might be bluescum is the same thing that you insist means he is not.

Let's review:

Poro - Initial posting looked good, but then he followed it up with some active filler jokes and provided no further reads. He later votes Uber commenting that the quality of his posts were "crap," but I don't really think this is true scumhunting, it looks more like him trying to appear to be doing something.

He's kind of scummy, but there's something telling me that he might be town, so null on him for now.

Tierce - I'm conflicted. She seemed scummy at first, then for a while she seemed town, but the bullshit she's pulled to push my lynch through un-nerves the crap out of me. She is completely ignoring the context of the meta, acting like I'd play exactly the same in a 13p as a 20p(Protip: I don't.) She's completely ignoring the fact that I'm playing to my town meta, instead opting to say "Oh yeah he's totally faking his town meta." Herp. My read on her is unfortunately going to be affected by my frustration in her terrible cases against me. I'll put her as misguided town for now, but I may change my mind at a later point in time.

What the hell are these.

If BBmolla flips scum, Poro is town. BBscum knows exactly what he is doing here with that read on Poro, which is to get me to call SCUMBUDDY READ:

In post 628 in Newbie #1185, BBmolla wrote:

In post 616, Tierce wrote:BB, why Post 415? That one has been gnawing at me.


Read the Vijay read. Scum always have a hard time placing their partner somewhere, and the "I donno, he's kinda scummy, but he makes sense, I donno" read kind of read as a gut partner read to me.

"Vjay: Sampson's lurkiness didn't help you at all. Made a few cases, but those made senses... Not too much content at the moment, I think... Unsure."



REMEMBER THIS >>> Poro = unlynchable if BBmolla flips scum (or if multiball, Poro is not in BB's team, etc). <<< REMEMBER THIS


The stuff about "I may change my mind at a later point in time" and all those reads "for now" are very bad. Reads are always about the present, why does he need to remark on that they may change in the future? I've never seen him do this.

Not only is your "case" on porotown not at all convincing, I think it's down right silly. It could just as easily apply to you, since his read on you was JUST as "I dunno null" as it was on Poro. That sort of subtle manipulation rubs me the wrong way.

That comment makes Porochaz MORE LIKELY to be a bluebuddy, not less likely.

I also don't like how you start the day saying that Poro is town. How do you KNOW Poro isn't redscum, Tierce? Is it because you are redscum?


And as for your theory, it's wrong, as Yosarian pointed out. This isn't LyLo and we shouldn't be chasing our tails with bluescum. It's wonderful and great if we have a good case on bluescum and lynch it, but we should be lynching whomever we think is most likely to be scum, regardless of color. All factors equal, I would go for blue scum, but all factors are never equal.

[Shadoweh]

Do you have any comments on Poro's posts directly instead of a counter-argument to Tierce's argument for his towniness based on BBmolla's posts?

[Amrun]

Yosarian pointed out, quite well, that Poro's posts seem to be driving lynches on the surface without really believing in them. He supported the UN lynch without appearing to have actually read any of UN's posts.

It's honestly not very much about what's IN Poro's posts and what's NOT in them - scumhunting or anything useful. He's very blah. I think BB's posts point to him being bluebuddy.

At some point, I'll probably go through his posts and put a finger on the things that bother me.

[Porochaz]

I look forward to this expansion because if you search "Porochaz", "Poro" and "Prozac" when iso'ing your posts it makes you look like you're taking advantage

[Fate]

Vote: Amrun

Don't you fucking DARE act like YOU caught her Shea. I've been on this for weeks

[Benmage]

Vote Fate

OH HAIIII, claim now.

[Benmage]

I'll let you try and wiggle Fate.

I did which of the following??:
Cop'd you, tracked you, watched you.

[Benmage]

You're onsite, stop running to the qt.

[Benmage]

Well, I'm going to church with the Fam (easter etc). But you can all stringup Fate, choo choo go go. No need for last words. He's scum.

I should be back sometime late today.

[Fate]

Benmage shut the fuck up. I thought you learned your lesson about trying to fakeclaim guilties on me?

I didn't do anything last night.

[Fate]

BENMAGE I SEE YOU BROWSING

QUIT RUNNING INTO WALLS WITH YOUR GOOD BRAIN CELLS

AND COME CLEAR THIS UP

[Benmage]

That doesn't look like a claim to me.

String up the lying scum.

[Amrun]

VOTE: Fate

[Porochaz]

Good case.

[Thestatusquo]

is benmage claiming JoaT?

He already vigged. I'd need more about his claim to straight up believe him.

[Benmage]

If it wasn't obvious from my D1 play. I am a JoaT of sorts. No need for anything further on the issue.

[Thestatusquo]

I kind of disagree, considering the fact that we've already had a cop claim and its fucking day four.