If you didn't notice shotgun, I am very good at missing questions.
Anyways, I do not think so...
It can identify mason in this setup, and that's why I usually overlook it- Because it can mean town just as much as scum. Although, for the same reasons scum wouldn't buddy, mason's wouldn't either I guess. So no, not really useful.
Lucky DID rvs. But he tried getting out using a wifom post. this one. check the 2nd sentence and the last one. That was scummy.
So he did, my mistake.
Rather, so he did participate in RVS.
He got out... of RVS? using a wifom post?
Oh, no, wait. He got out of being attacked for an RVS vote by claiming it was to get a read-- a reaction test.
Good scumhunting, Luckyjt!
In post 92, Kcdaspot wrote:My scum list was a early one and was subject to change. I SAID THIS IN THE VERY POST. And while its true you don't forgive SCUM, you forgive scummyness. He's prolly the newest one here so I let him slide.
Hey, look, a lie! Or at least, an inaccuracy. (That's me giving you the benefit of the doubt). Look here:
I seem to be missing the part where YOU SAID THIS IN THE VERY POST.
You didn't. You said it in the post you explained these reads in. Your scumlist was just a scumlist, and then your explanation was, "Whoa, whoa, these are early reads! They'll probably change!" and then you gave weak reasoning.
Also, Darkling_Perhaps is newer, raspberrylicious is newer, Luckyjt is newer, --there's two of your TOP SCUMREADS RIGHT NOW,
Also, Chimi is only one month older (onsite) than Kassadin.
In post 92, Kcdaspot wrote:The first reason I suspect chirmi is the sheeping or piggybaking as I said it. Shotgun's question was legit but arbitrary. Chrimi, as town, would do nothing and accomplish nadda if he did what he did. He didn't come up with it himself he let someone else do his work for him. And just sheeped off of that what really gets me is that he gloated after I call him on it. He needs to stop being cocky and play. If he just said I dunno something else like why he did it like that then something like that Id back off. BUT NOPE. WHY DOES HE THINK HE'S ABOVE ME? LAUGHING AT ME HE SAYS. I had a concern he threw it in my face and now he needs to die.
Let's begin at the top here.
-"Piggybaking" is for when you finally blow that brick house down.
-Shotgun's question was not arbitrary, you gave a list of reads with no explanation. His question, "why," is like, the nicest thing he could have asked of you-- he let you explain your reads, instead of just attacking you for bad reads and no reasoning.
-Chrimi, as scum, would also accomplish nothing by agreeing with DrMyShot, except for some buddying.
Tbh, I also was totally behind Shotty's (sorry, it's just faster) question when I read it. It was too late to post, "this" by that time, pages had gone by.
But look, he didn't attack you for not having reasoning-- he's "sheeping" Shot's question? (That's not Sheeping, btw.) This would be scummy if Chimi had rephrased the same question and made it sound like it was his own, but he didn't, he went "Shotgun has a point, kcdaspot is full of shit."
And you called him on... what? "it"? Adding weight to Shot's question? Not doing any work of his own? Yeah, he laughed in your face, because that's ridiculous and a really, really poor accusation. He is playing. He's doing fairly well at it too, afaict, but I'm fair and I like to see all three sides of things-- Town, Mafia, and werewolf-- so I'll do an ISO of Chimi, too. Maybe something will turn up!
But I doubt something will turn up to validate your points.
In post 92, Kcdaspot wrote:You vote me 3 times. And accuse me of like 3 things I didn't do. Cool that chainsaw down.
Incorrect! I accused you of & voted you for ONE thing you didn't do. Here, let me explain:
In post 82, Whiskers wrote:Post #4, Kcda tells us that his scumread on Darkling is for not making a random vote.
Then... eh, lastly, I accused you of not doing any scumhunting, which is I guess kind of objective or something? Besides, I'd have to quote all of your posts to show that you're not. The short way to put it is-- I read your ISO. When I made that post, you hadn't done any scumhunting. I dunno if you have now, I haven't been reading your posts, just making my own.
But look at me, I'm 2/3 points against you, and you're 0/3 points against Chimi.
Now, why don't you look around and try again to tell me who is scum and why?
drmyshotgun wrote:Actually, cancel DK Town read. He's bored. So he might be anxiously expecting some Night partying.
I am being misread. :[
Anyway, Whiskers is my only townread.
And Lucky, you're vote is still on me, it's way after what you guys call 'RVS'. So I'm definitely going to vote you.
Vote Luckyjt
DK, is that your only basis for a read on Lucky?
I feel like Darkling explained himself adequately.
Vote: rasberrylicious
until he does something, because right now, his posts are scum.
Yes, and why? Do you think that it's town to ignore a vote that's been on you so long?
Lucky has no reason to be voting me.
You said it yourself, it's an RVS vote. There is no way you will lynched until he actually pushes you. Maybe flat out ignoring the RVS isn't the best course, but it's not exactly town cross voting because of it.
What, are we suggesting that raspberryliscious is somehow more vile than Kassadin? At least raspberrylicious is paying attention.
Or, Luna forbid, than Kcdaspot?
RBL only has three posts and they're all better than, say, BBMolla's posts.
We're five pages into the game and I have a strong scumread, can anypony else contribute? Information, analysis, anything?
In post 109, Trevor wrote:I feel like Darkling explained himself adequately.
Vote: rasberrylicious
until he does something, because right now, his posts are scum.
Trevor, why are you voting for raspberryliscious? Couldn't you be voting for Kassadin with the same reasoning?
Trevor, why aren't you voting for Kcdaspot? Regardless of what lurkers are doing, I feel I've made a compelling case for why he is mafia (or werewolf) and why should we putt around until May 11? What do you have to say about my case against Kcdaspot?
Is it more important to persecute lurkers than scum at the beginning of the game?
Trevor, who are you scum with: Kassadin, or with Kcdaspot?
I'm SORRY!?
You're right, you do have better posts, I was exaggerating.
But these really LOOK like filler when you're scanning and ISO to make sure you can call the lurker better than BBM. If I look at them optimistically, I can say, the first one was a real vote with real reasoning... and, uh, it's still early in the game, so it doesn't even have to be real strong reasoning. Right? And the second one, uh, was asking a question. Nopony likes to be attacked without basis. Right?
But your phrasing makes me skip them and ignore them.
I will be ordering from more town to most mafia (In actions). Middle is Null.
-Whiskers by far the most town in the group. Relevant posts and has a good case on Kcd.
-Chrimi basically almost null, but low town read since i havnt seen him do anything yet which catched my eye that he is scum.
-havingfitz- Null, has he/she even posted?
-Trevor Null possibly low scum.
-drmyshotgun low scum (still pretty close to the middle)
-Darkling_Perhaps we are getting a bit more scummy here.
-DeityKabuto low scum for reactions on my vote. (And no I wont be taking my off you yet)
-raspberrylicious middle scum. Havnt seen you post much and dont like your post(s) that you have made.
-Kassadin your reasons for your votes seem...odd and suspicious. Mid tier scum
-BBMolla dont like your playing style which makes you look extremely scummy in my eyes.
-Kcdaspot whiskers has a good case on you and I agree on a lot of things that do make you really scummy.
