In post 747, andrew94 wrote:@Tech, i said nacho and kassadin because i feel that
kassadin is town and that nacho was town at that point of time.
also, i think kass is town due to some gut, but i feel your reasoning
isnt nice either.
you said the maths suggests kass to be more town than scum.
That will always be the case, until we lose....
I dont know about Llama, but i think hes a he. Please confirm that as i have been using he for the whole game. My apologies if im wrong.
He states that he saw someone crumbing and that the person crumbing
is not one of the clears.
IF he were scum, wouldnt he just kill that particular guy he was
talking about? That slightly points him into town but he might be
tricking.
I like Jackal more as scum
How does mafia work? How do townies catch scum? Basically, scumhunting.
So say there is a player called player A, and he basically hasn't posted all game and has been VL/A the whole time. Absolute nulltell. We can't 'scumhunt' him so the only thing we now have to go on is maths. If we mislynched today and confd a towny tonight, there would be one unconf town and three scum, making it far more likely, in that scenario, that kass is scum.
Basically, I don't want to lose this game over a lynch with no leads that has more chance of being town than scum. Later on, this might not be the case.
And if he is actually scum, we aren't missing out on much today by not lynching him. There are two other scum out there waiting for rope.
In regards to Llama, exactly, he might be tricking. It's WIFOM really, not a towntell. And I'm still not sure why he felt the need to say it. That's basically helping scum. I may have noticed stuff from yesterday but I keep it to myself, HOWEVER, I do see a possible way what he said would help town, so I am going to request that we stop talking about this point and leave it as a nulltell.
