absta101 wrote:
@Venmar
Venmar wrote:and this play style of mine has thrown me under the spotlight in multiple games.
Again. Can you give examples please.
- I have played as scum before, if you want that as a read for your meta be my guest. Go check out Open 399, that was my very first scum game ever. It was probably the worst game i ever played because of the slips i made, and i think it is a bad example of what you're asking here absta, but it's something. I have played many games off-site on a website called poxnora, and i am not going to expand on that as to avoid looking like i am advertising the game. Other than my off-site game and Open 399, the only other game i completed was a Newbie game, forgot which one so i will look that up later. I can't link you ongoing games, because well, they are ongoing. From a personal feeling though, ever since my very first mafia game, the same behavior i did in that game has got me in trouble in others, like this one. Example are me being cautious and honest.
In post 562, CF Riot wrote:
Venmar wrote:Curious, who did you protect Absta? You did after all claim a protective role didn't you?
This is pretty damn scummy. There's no reason to ask that.
- Why not? Absta did claim a protective type of role am i right? Why should it be scummy to ask for who they targeted? Absta could have very well saved someone and if we looked at that person, we could be able to depict why the mafia would want to attack that certain person. I am maybe just not following your train of thought here, because in my eyes i saw no way how that was scummy, but maybe it was, i don't know. For my own benefit / good, could you explain why it was scummy?
In post 559, absta101 wrote:
@Venmar
Curious, who did you protect Absta? You did after all claim a protective role didn't you?
This rolefishing is so obvious. Venmar have you ever played as scum before?
It was an opening post, showing what i thought of the night results.
Scum are more likely to comment on night outcomes that are detrimental to a faction.
- 1. This is similar to what i said to Cynic, how is my question scummy? However i doubt it was rolephishing because he all already potentially know what role you have, so the harm in saying who is protected.. is what? I see rolephishing as someone trying to find out someone's role. Once you know their potential role i don't think it is rolephishing. Is asking a claimed cop for their night investigation role phishing as well by your logic? Also, yes i have played as scum before, and no i am not scum in this game unfortunately for you. Again, check Open 399 for my latest finished scum game.
- 2. Not necessarily. Definitely not in my eyes. Anyone can comment on the outcome of a night action. If there is no kill, like right now, someone making a conclusions that the chances of there being a SK are really low is scummy? It is something that anyone can note, not just mafia players or town power roles who have done something that has related to the night outcomes. While scum are more likely to comment on this, true, i am not scum and this is not one of those "more likely" situations.
- A fair point. I personally just find the likeliness of a doctor protection more likely, but what you propose is also a very possible possibility. Thank you for pointing that out.
absta101 wrote:
@Venmar
Venmar wrote:and this play style of mine has thrown me under the spotlight in multiple games.
Also, scum reads would be nice.
- I will make a list of scum reads later, i just came home from outside and i want to take a shower and make some food after this post is finished.
-------------
- I don't like to make this accusation but Absta has been tunneling me since the beginning of the game. Also AC partially, but i feel like he has been tunneling me the most and blindly swatting away people who really dare to defend me, while supporting those who go against me. Examples are, denying Vijay who was defending me and supporting Alduskkel who has been against me for the most part of this game.
- I also disagree with his case on AC for the most part, because i don't see how whiteknighting me is a scum tell, because it kind of isn't, and the thing about how AC scumhunts is complete opinion and is not a scum tell on its own. Again, reading some of the thread the cases put forward against AC aren't strong enough for what i feel is a lynch, but strong enough to keep an extensive eye on.
- I will be ISOing Psyche after my shower, i want to look over what he has said and i will make my scum and town reads as i have promised for Absta. Other than that, this post is finished, and more content in my next one.
