Open 422: Polygamist Mafia (Game Over)

[Jal]

I think DJD is at L-1.

[BridgesAndBaloons]

I am DJD's partner, we are town. Part of me wants him to die as well for being stupid VI. I warn you that he is town and lynching him for an apparent "scumslip" is stupid,

we are here to win, not teach meta lessons.

@Hiraki: If I am right and I die, kill them, Kill scum. If I am wrong feel free to laugh at endgame.

I Saw this claim coming that's what my mental note was in my previous post. As of this point in my read-through I'm starting to think this is a true claim.

[BridgesAndBaloons]

Also, can you explain this post for me?

I get it.

This is a secret variant on conspiracy

Where the goal of the game

Is to convince them it's not a conspiracy if it is, or make them think it's a conspiracy when it's not

And all y'all's win condition is to make me think you're scum.

MY GOD IS ANYONE IN HERE TOWN
EXCEPT MY MOTHERFUCKING MASON BUDDY

lol l I was thinking the same thing.
and thus greyIce gets townie points...

except wait there's this

MY GOD IS ANYONE IN HERE TOWN
EXCEPT MY MOTHERFUCKING MASON BUDDY

HIRAKI GET YOUR BUTT IN HERE

. . . are we supposed to take this as you claiming?

How is the fact you were thinking the same thing = townie points? And then why were they taken away just because you think that was a claim? Does that mean you also think the other two claiming lovers are something other than town?

Ah, I think there's a misinterpretation here. It wasn't taken away, I was asking if this was a claim since he said "Except my motherfucking mason buddy hirake get your butt in here." That seemed like a claim and Iwas asking about it.

Thinking the same thing as me when I'm town is the most powerful town-tell I have. I'm not talking about thinking the same ways as in who is suspicious, but more abstract meta-levels sentiments akin to the ones grey-ice expressed. Therefore I've got a decently strong town read on greyIce.

also before I forget

unvote

too much has happened in the past bit.

I would like to propose a mass-claim

, Thoughts?

[Jal]

After what has happened and that we're most possibly near a lynch: My answer is yes to a massclaim.

[GreyICE]

How can we allow the claimed scum to live BaB?

It can't be allowed to happen. There's no townie motive. And I'm not talking "there's no townie motive" like "there's no townie motive for being stupid." No, literally the only motive is to confuse the town so much that we dont lynch them, when they were on the very threshold of being lynched already.

I fucking don't like it, but they cannot be allowed to live. DJD and his scum claiming loony partner cannot survive this game. So they die. Then we worry about mass claim (no night kill means no difference).

[BridgesAndBaloons]

oops just got to the part where sala claimed scum.

Dear Salamence20,

what you did was very selfish of you. You are giving up. That ruins the fun for everyone. This is a game. It's about having fun. Yes, emotions come into play. Yes, it is hard to be in a losing position. But fighting in those losing positions is what makes you a better player in the long run. Regardless of whether you're scum or town you're doing a huge disservice to yourself and to everyone who wanted to play a fun game.
In short, you're acting like an asshole. You're probably not an asshole in real life, very few people are. So next time you want to give up, consider replacing out, instead of ruining the fun for a bunch of people you don't know and will never meet. I know it doesn't mean much, but unless this is some sort of crazy gambit where you're scum and claiming lover who is town or something*, you will be banned from all games I mod.

vote: Salamence20

*although the gambit would never work in the game since the real partner would counter...

[DeltaWave]

VOTE COUNT 1.12

DoubleJD (4): Jal, Slandaar, Arugula, The Acting Method, GreyICE (L-2)
Salamence20 (2): Hiraki, BridgesAndBaloons (L-5)
Hiraki (1): Slandaar (L-6)
Jal (1): SnakePlissken (L-6)

Not Voting: Nyalite, Salamence20, yellowbounder

With 12 alive, it's 7 to lynch.

Fun fact: Hiraki's attempted DayVig has failed.

[Nyalite]

Hey Slandaar,

I don't see this as a slip. Playing passive is a style you can do as scum or as town. It's worth comparing playstyles as both alignments because both alignments share some things in common (want to be able to construct cases on people that are convincing, want to avoid getting suspicion, want to get reads on other players).

So, exactly what I said in post #328.

Want to try again?

[Nyalite]

Ah, I think there's a misinterpretation here. It wasn't taken away, I was asking if this was a claim since he said "Except my motherfucking mason buddy hirake get your butt in here." That seemed like a claim and Iwas asking about it.

Okay, your wording made it like you were saying I'm getting a town read

except

...

Thinking the same thing as me when I'm town is the most powerful town-tell I have. I'm not talking about thinking the same ways as in who is suspicious, but more abstract meta-levels sentiments akin to the ones grey-ice expressed. Therefore I've got a decently strong town read on greyIce.

Really though? I think both scum and town can agree there are lots of face palming moments in this game. So if that's the best you've got pretty weak there.

[Jal]

Nyalite

:

So, exactly what I said in post #328.

Want to try again?

It looks like he was posting as he was going through the thread and made that response to Slaandar right after seeing it for the first time, not having gotten to your post #328 yet.

BridgesAndBaloons

: Why put the vote on Sal instead of his partner DJD? I entirely agree with what you said otherwise.

What the hell is this?

[BridgesAndBaloons]

oops JD has more votes

unvote

vote: DoubleJD

@Nyalite, yeah looking back at your post it looks like we agree. Why should I "try again"?

also @Nyalite again: I don't need you to believe me. I know how to town-hunt, probably better than I know how to scum-hunt. I'm stating clearly in the thread that I think G-i is town. It's a personal reasons based on what I was thinking, and I can't expect anyone other than my lover to believe me when I say what I was thinking. I can't expect anyone to get the same town-read form him since they didn't

think

the same thing in the same way. Makes sense? Probs not. going to bed now

[Nyalite]

The reasoning for the lynch was horrible.

But lets play a game.

Lets take Sally at his word that he hates JJD and wants to ruin the game for him. And that they are scum, and he is throwing it. (Many of you have already done this.)

Why then can we not believe that Sally hates JJD and wants to ruin the game for him. And that their alignment has nothing to do with it.

If you wanted to be lynched claiming scum will get that done.

Sally is a confirmed asshole now. So why do believe he isn't jerking us all around. And if so, why give scum a free mislynch.

[Nyalite]

@Nyalite, yeah looking back at your post it looks like we agree. Why should I "try again"?

also @Nyalite again: I don't need you to believe me. I know how to town-hunt, probably better than I know how to scum-hunt. I'm stating clearly in the thread that I think G-i is town. It's a personal reasons based on what I was thinking, and I can't expect anyone other than my lover to believe me when I say what I was thinking. I can't expect anyone to get the same town-read form him since they didn't think the same thing in the same way. Makes sense? Probs not. going to bed now

Try again to add something useful to the thread instead of lurking it up.

Your "read" is that someone else felt the same way as you. And that feeling is that everyone in this game is being scummy. I'm sure lots of people noticed this.
I'm sorry to disappoint you but you were not the first to notice the sky is blue, the sun is bright or half the people in this game look really scummy. And you didn't find some special bond in GreyIce.(

"He thinks just like me!!"

)

[Jal]

You can play either game.

Point is: We don't know which one we're playing and right now we're currently dealing with one big WIFOM mess.

I'm rather pissed off with either outcome, because you're right - he's a confirmed asshole.

[Jal]

And

now

they are at L-1.

[Nyalite]

Sally if you are really scum, name your other partners.

No one hammer until he does.

DO NOT DO IT.

[GreyICE]

Do you want to be dealing with this cockbag tomorrow nyalite?

I mean suppose he came in here and said "no I'm sorry I was just so frustrated, you have no idea." what then?

This lynch needs to happen right now. Claiming scum is choosing death

[DeltaWave]

VOTE COUNT 1.13

DoubleJD (6): Jal, Slandaar, Arugula, The Acting Method, GreyICE, BridgesAndBaloons (H

O

L

Y

F

U

C

K

I

N

G

S

H

I

T

L-1)
Salamence20 (1): Hiraki (L-6)
Hiraki (1): Slandaar (L-6)
Jal (1): SnakePlissken (L-6)

Not Voting: Nyalite, Salamence20, yellowbounder

With 12 alive, it's 7 to lynch.

Fun fact: Now with rainbow colos

[SnakePlissken]

Unvote

I'm going to re read later today, but I will put it ou there now if I concur with e rest of us I will place an intent to hammer down now. That a place holder intent, it may be rescinded After my read up.

I will post some overdue thoughts and comments too.

[yellowbounder]

FUCK IT. I can't stand defending this moron.

I'm scum, I want to die. Kill me.

Fuck you DJD.

Sorry Hiraki, I wanted to play a better game, but I can't stand him. Kill me, end my misery.

What is this I don't even

[Slandaar]

Its a scumclaim.

Lynch.

[Hiraki]

Unvote, Vote: DJD

[DoubleJD]

Still town.

Amish tell is bs, slips are bs and have never caught scum imo. Town refuses to talk about other players, a mass claim is a terrible idea at this point in the game. There are about 6 players that could be partners with pretty much anyone.

Thoughts: is it weird that people believe sala's scum claim...or argue against it? The scum know hes lying. Idk

Other thoughts: Scum made up reasons to lynch me. I really like greyice as scum. im null on hiraki and arugula

[DeltaWave]

DAY 1 FINAL VOTE COUNT

DoubleJD (7): Jal, Slandaar, Arugula, The Acting Method, GreyICE, BridgesAndBaloons, Hiraki (H

O

L

Y

F

U

C

K

I

N

G

S

H

I

T

A LYNCH)
Hiraki (1): Slandaar (L-6)

Not Voting: Nyalite, Salamence20, yellowbounder, SnakePlissken

With 12 alive, it's 7 to lynch.

Fun fact: doublejd got deaded :[

[DeltaWave]

Everyone was having a pleasant evening, enjoying dinner at a local restaraunt. Suddenly, for some reason, DoubleJD blurted out that he was a polygamist. This inflamed the passions of everyone else at the table, causing everyone else to pull out baseball bats and beat him up like so:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_hF_RhD-xE

Upon further inspection, it appears that he was town. Oops.

Also, his lover committed suicide. So sad.

DoubleJD

,

town lover, lynched Day

1.

Salamence20

,

town lover, suicided Day 1.

***

DAY 2 HAS BEGUN

With 10 people alive, it's 6 to lynch.