So, my thoughts from a readthrough:
Bitmap's 57 looks really bad. I agree that scum are more likely to be defensive there because they actively have something to hide as opposed to town. If that's true, then it must follow that one of the three that got replaced for cheating is also scum (so Hiraki, RachMarie, and inte).
Page 4, not liking Bitmap at all. Hiraki's defense of Bitmap is making me think he's his partner. Like AngryPidgeon's attack.
Page 5, ahhhh, quote walls already. Getting gut feeling of town Cooldog. inte jumps in looking like he wants to derail the Bitmap bandwagon, which doesn't sit well with me.
Page 6, shos gets attacked, Bitmap jumps in and tries to derail it, suggests Konowa for doing the same thing. Like the attack on shos, though. Bitmap/Hiraki/shos? Could also see Bitmap/inte/shos at this point. And if Bitmap flips scum, Konowa is most likely town.
Page 7, Bitmap using what looks like essentially appeal to fear, questioning what roflcopter will do if he's wrong. Why hasn't Bitmap been lynched yet?
Page 8, shos attacks Bitmap. Could be a bus, he's bringing up older posts that have been covered, but he hadn't posted in a while, so meh.
Page 9, as for the case on Arugula and his (typed her first out of seeing it all the time from BabyBlue) playstyle being different from that last game weird and Arugula were in, I'm not really seeing a difference, I'm getting a town vibe from Arugula (although I'm not super confident in that given how that day you were alive was stupid). Bitmap posts that he'll hammer Arugula, it just seems like he cares about his survival more than anything, I'm getting nothing but scum reads from him.
Page 10, inte seems to flip on his Bitmap town read.
Skipping ahead slightly...
Everyone unvoted Bitmap? Jesus christ. I understand Tangion isn't looking great, either, but come on. I'll eat my hat if Bitmap isn't scum.
Reads:
Town: AngryPidgeon, Arugula, Cooldog, Konowa
Null: wierdalexv, roflcopter, RachMarie
Scum: Tangion, shos, inte, Hiraki
Super Ultra Mega Scum: Bitmap
vote: Bitmap