Open 441 - Chosen Mafia (OVER)

[McStab]

I highly suspect he is, and I'm not willing to let him get lynched to find out. At this point, this is my reads; I said this earlier but I'd imagine you don't want to read all the walls:


RC - Chosen Townie.
RGF - Chosen Townie.
Eidolon - Townie.
Whiskers - Unknown (used to be town, before someone jumps all over this)
Inte/Crypto - Unknown
Greywing - Scum
Myself - Townie

Shyeahh, nope.
VOTE: McStab

What in particular strikes you as scummy? And is this really all you have to contribute to the game? If I didn't think you were Chosen I'd push for you to be policy lynched.

[realgodfather]

What in particular strikes you as scummy? And is this really all you have to contribute to the game? If I didn't think you were Chosen I'd push for you to be policy lynched.

reaching

[Whiskers]

Not doing it, this just reaffirms my belief he's Chosen. For some reason you and Whiskers seem to be pushing rather vehemently for this, despite lack of mentioning anything except that he's a lurker. I've also already explained why I think he's Chosen earlier.

Well, you haven't been pushing "vehemently" for it, but is that really who you want lynched? What about the Me-RC, or Eidolon vs Whiskers-RC debate earlier? Sure, RGF hasn't played a great town game, but for the amount of flak he's receiving for posting so little (especially relative to Greywing) it's pretty absurd. Someone just hammer Greywing and be done with it; I won't jump on an RGF lynch.

This is exactly why lurking is scummy. You can't GET another read on him, he's lurking. If you will not lynch him because the case on him is "he sucks" and "he is lurking," then ScumRGF rides to the endgame for a scum win.

Whiskers - Unknown (used to be town, before someone jumps all over this)

If your case is based off a single townslip and some lurking, then you need a better case.

I believe the wagon on Pasch was largely town motivated (at least myself, Eidolon and RC) and the wagon on RGF was an attack on a Chosen Townie led by scum-Greywing. Hence why lynching RGF came up so often but lynching crypto never seemed to get beyond the conception stage.

And, oh yeah, I meant to ask you about this.

[Mortontfrh]

Vote Count 1.08

With 7 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Greywing (3): Mcstab, Eidolon, Rapidcanyon

Rapidcanyon (1): Greywing
McStab (1): Realgodfather
Realgodfather (1): Whiskers

Not Voting: Inte
Deadline is in (expired on 2012-09-06 11:32:00)

Still searching for a replacement for Greywing.

[McStab]

just hammer him for the mods sake

[Whiskers]

First, explain why you s-- actually, no. Fine.

We'll talk about it tomorrow.

Vote: Greywing

[inte]

ugh if he flips chosen you're done whiskers

[Eidolon]

ugh if he flips chosen you're done whiskers

LOL.

the hilarity never stops with you huh?

whiskers would be at no more fault than anyone else.

[inte]

except we have 6 days till deadline and that i already declared hammer = scum

you people are really dense aren't you?

[Whiskers]

except we have 6 days till deadline and that i already declared hammer = scum

Yes, except that "hammer=scum" is bullshit. Hammer =/= scum, and you saying it does not make it so. If you feel I am scum for delivering the hammer, then feel free to make a case on me tomorrow. You'll need more than "she hammered".

[rapidcanyon]

Off topic, Whiskers, you are a guy, right? Why say "she hammered?"

But yes, hammering doesn't mean scum and I have no idea where inte is coming from. If all hammerers are automatically lynched, nobody will ever hammer regardless of affiliation and no lynches will ever happen.

[inte]

its because i declared it

do you guys not realize the value of discussion now that you have a fresh set of eyes on the case?

ugh people who rush things don't understand

[inte]

w/e go ahead and dont listen

[Whiskers]

I recall that I was feeling Greywing scum-- I think mostly for attacking RC, but I don't remember. Anyway, if he's not hammered now, then the mod has to find a replacement, and then that replacement, presumably, reads the game and spends a bunch of time, and

then

is hammered.

Anyway, your "fresh set of eyes" hasn't gone nuts with that valuable discussion or anything. You said

there is stuff to discuss atm

yesterday, but... are you stalling? Is there some reason you couldn't discuss yesterday? Some reason you still won't now? If we're waiting on you to "discuss" with your "fresh set of eyes," then by all means, hurry the fuck up.

[Whiskers]

8) The town may opt to 'no lynch' in lieu of lynching a player on any day. VOTE: No Lynch is the format for this.

Lol.
I guess I should have read the rules more carefully, we should just No-lynch each Day and let mafia kill off non-chosen townies until endgame. 1

[Eidolon]

Inte, a fresh set of eyes is nice but you really haven't offered much details or analysis. You say "there's stuff to discuss" but then don't discuss any of it...

So if whiskers wanted to hammer, and the day period was stalling, why hold it off any longer?

[inte]

I recall that I was feeling Greywing scum-- I think mostly for attacking RC, but I don't remember. Anyway, if he's not hammered now, then the mod has to find a replacement, and then that replacement, presumably, reads the game and spends a bunch of time, and

then

is hammered.

Anyway, your "fresh set of eyes" hasn't gone nuts with that valuable discussion or anything. You said

there is stuff to discuss atm

yesterday, but... are you stalling? Is there some reason you couldn't discuss yesterday? Some reason you still won't now? If we're waiting on you to "discuss" with your "fresh set of eyes," then by all means, hurry the fuck up.

we have 4 more days till deadline

if, I were scum, what effect would stalling have if i didn't put forth any content yet?

whos fault is it that i have't put forth any content? i made it clear that i had a few things that may be important to say, and i strictly said hammer = scum claim for that purpose

i am a full time student with a part time job and MTW are the only 3 days I work. people DO have lives outside of mafiascum, no matter how much they seem to spam.

ever hear patience is a virtue?

8) The town may opt to 'no lynch' in lieu of lynching a player on any day. VOTE: No Lynch is the format for this.

Lol.
I guess I should have read the rules more carefully, we should just No-lynch each Day and let mafia kill off non-chosen townies until endgame. 1

the purpose of this post was? ... scum would just no-kill every night and then the game would get abandoned

what if no-lynching to get more time was going to be one of my strategies that would cut short?

why suggest this option after the fact?

Inte, a fresh set of eyes is nice but you really haven't offered much details or analysis. You say "there's stuff to discuss" but then don't discuss any of it...

So if whiskers wanted to hammer, and the day period was stalling, why hold it off any longer?

because there were things i could have commented on, but no longer have the opportunity to do so because of an idiotic hammer. is that pro-town to you?

buncha kids in this game with no foresight sigh

[inte]

except my vote to be on whiskers the whole day with little discussion. the lack of thought is appalling
if you are town, are handing scum the game

if you are scum, you are obvious

[Whiskers]

I recall that I was feeling Greywing scum-- I think mostly for attacking RC, but I don't remember. Anyway, if he's not hammered now, then the mod has to find a replacement, and then that replacement, presumably, reads the game and spends a bunch of time, and

then

is hammered.

Anyway, your "fresh set of eyes" hasn't gone nuts with that valuable discussion or anything. You said

there is stuff to discuss atm

yesterday, but... are you stalling? Is there some reason you couldn't discuss yesterday? Some reason you still won't now? If we're waiting on you to "discuss" with your "fresh set of eyes," then by all means, hurry the fuck up.

we have 4 more days till deadline

if, I were scum, what effect would stalling have if i didn't put forth any content yet?

Fair enough.

whos fault is it that i have't put forth any content? i made it clear that i had a few things that may be important to say, and i strictly said hammer = scum claim for that purpose

i am a full time student with a part time job and MTW are the only 3 days I work. people DO have lives outside of mafiascum, no matter how much they seem to spam.

ever hear patience is a virtue?

...except that you go and do this.
It is YOUR fault you haven't put forth any content. If you wanted for us to wait for a specific purpose, then you should have said so. We don't know your schedule. You went HAMMER = SCUM which is clearly untrue, so we ignored it and made fun of you for it. Even now, hammer =/= scum, hammer = inconvenience for you because you didn't bother telling us you were busy.

8) The town may opt to 'no lynch' in lieu of lynching a player on any day. VOTE: No Lynch is the format for this.

Lol.
I guess I should have read the rules more carefully, we should just No-lynch each Day and let mafia kill off non-chosen townies until endgame. 1

the purpose of this post was? ... scum would just no-kill every night and then the game would get abandoned

what if no-lynching to get more time was going to be one of my strategies that would cut short?

why suggest this option after the fact?

I made this post because the setup disallows no-lynching.
If you had "strategies" you would have posted them. You didn't. That they got cut short is your own fault. Let me rephrase:

you were posting and clearly had the time to post.

If you didn't post a specific thing, then it's your fault.
Moreover, you STILL have time to post things. Want to introduce a strategy? Now is the time,

BEFORE

Night.

Inte, a fresh set of eyes is nice but you really haven't offered much details or analysis. You say "there's stuff to discuss" but then don't discuss any of it...

So if whiskers wanted to hammer, and the day period was stalling, why hold it off any longer?

because there were things i could have commented on, but no longer have the opportunity to do so because of an idiotic hammer. is that pro-town to you?

buncha kids in this game with no foresight sigh

Bullshit. You have things you STILL CAN comment on, and STILL HAVE the opportunity to do so. But won't, because of an idiotic hammer. is that pro-town to you?

btw if he DOES flip scum, you are so my next target.

[Whiskers]

Are you arguing with yourself?

except my vote to be on whiskers the whole day with little discussion.

the lack of thought is appalling. if you are town, are handing scum the game

[inte]

long hair, don't care

it is

YOUR FAULT.

i clearly stated that we have 1 more mislynch before LyLo and you opted to ignore that

[inte]

town literally deserves a loss for its poor play here

[Whiskers]

That includes you, inte.

Or... does it?

[rapidcanyon]

Inte, why not give your analysis before the mod closes the day?

[Mortontfrh]

8) The town may opt to 'no lynch' in lieu of lynching a player on any day. VOTE: No Lynch is the format for this.

Lol.
I guess I should have read the rules more carefully, we should just No-lynch each Day and let mafia kill off non-chosen townies until endgame. 1

This is not the case and I apologize for that. I stripped the rule set from my previous game and I forget to make amendments like this that were specific to this game type. To clarify: You can not no lynch in this set up. Wiki for Reference.

Vote Count 1.09

With 7 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Greywing (4): Mcstab, Eidolon, Rapidcanyon, Whiskers

Rapidcanyon (1): Greywing
McStab (1): Realgodfather

Not Voting: Inte
Deadline is in (expired on 2012-09-06 11:32:00)

Greywing the

Mafia Goon

has been lynched. Night two deadlines ends in (expired on 2012-09-02 11:57:00)