Mini 1373 - Oh My! (Game Over)

[Hibiki]

and denistown actually

[Empking]

Vote Count 9

redtail896 (3) - satire, Synaesthesia
ProjectMatt (2) - Sach, redtail896
Synaesthesia (2) - projectmatt, crypto, deadjoker
Petapan - robertmontana
Deadjoker - denisatp, petapan

Not Voting: horrordude0125, Hibiki, tuxedomask

[petapan]

I don't want to lynch project while his internet is out, but that's mostly friend bias and I can still be talked into it.

Syn is still an alright choice, and so are Robert, Hibiki, and Satire. I have at least a slight townread on everyone else (guy who hasn't posted is obviously excluded). A Satire lynch won't happen because I'm alone on that read and I know Hibiki is capable of participating more and would hope some votes might get him to towntell.

wait a sec but you unvoted synaesthesia

[Hibiki]

"is still"

[Hibiki]

when i first saw tuxedo posting i was ready to have him ripped to shreds but then he played off the "i know you guys and you don't know me, now watch my excellence" beautifully that i can't fault him

[denisatp]

Peta knows who he is. Also, dave feels really awkward in this game and I'm not sure what to think of it.

[redtail896]

Peta knows who he is. Also, dave feels really awkward in this game and I'm not sure what to think of it.

Who is dave?

[Hibiki]

me

[satire]

Peta knows who he is. Also, dave feels really awkward in this game and I'm not sure what to think of it.

Agreed. So far, I have my lynch pool down to:

redtail
Synaesthesia
deadjoker
Hibiki
RobertMontana

Pretty much down with any of these five (horrordude is exempted until he inevitably talks/gets replaced). I'd be moving to Syn right now but the way people just kinda came up out of nowhere and lazily voted him + his recent post are really giving me pause. I'd like to see more substantive contributions from him before I settle on what I think of him.

The people who've expressed suspicion on projectmatt are doing so on hollow/non-existent logic imo.

Robert's posts are really irritating.

I'm fine with my vote where it is for the moment.

And that's all folks, see you in a couple of days.

[petapan]

horrordude is going to be the permalurker slot that should be lynched before lylo, calling it now

[denisatp]

horrordude is going to be the permalurker slot that should be lynched before lylo, calling it now

why wouldn't he get replaced

Peta knows who he is. Also, dave feels really awkward in this game and I'm not sure what to think of it.

Agreed. So far, I have my lynch pool down to:

redtail
Synaesthesia
deadjoker
Hibiki
RobertMontana

Pretty much down with any of these five (horrordude is exempted until he inevitably talks/gets replaced). I'd be moving to Syn right now but the way people just kinda came up out of nowhere and lazily voted him + his recent post are really giving me pause. I'd like to see more substantive contributions from him before I settle on what I think of him.

The people who've expressed suspicion on projectmatt are doing so on hollow/non-existent logic imo.

Robert's posts are really irritating.

I'm fine with my vote where it is for the moment.

And that's all folks, see you in a couple of days.

yeah lets just lynch deadjoker

[redtail896]

The people who've expressed suspicion on projectmatt are doing so on hollow/non-existent logic imo.

Why do you think the logic behind the matt suspicion is so bad while continuing to harp on syn? The cases seem eerily similar, save syn has a lurking thing going on. Why focus on one and not the other?

[petapan]

why wouldn't he get replaced

it might happen but it'll be a thing where it takes an absurdly long time to happen and then the replacement will be "hai guis lemme catch up" and then not post for 4 days and then prod dodge and etc etc

the read has no bearing on the game it's just strategy/cynicism

[Hibiki]

my last few posts were completely nonawkward i don't know what you nerds are talking about

redtail can you do something that isnt ask questions

[petapan]

yeah but it's out of rvs so that means far less

[projectmatt]

V/LA for a few days while we wait to get a new computer, sorry

[Sach]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: deadjoker

I don't want to lynch Matt why he is away. But dead is kinda odd his posts the first one I read contradicted itself and his post just have been really scummy since then.

[Sach]

I mean while ;_; while is he away

[redtail896]

Sorry to hear about your computer troubles Matt.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Sach

[Hibiki]

redtail can you do something that isnt ask questions

[Hibiki]

silent votes dont count

[redtail896]

silent votes dont count

His reasoning for unvoting matt might hold weight if matt had any chance of being lynched; as is it looks like an attempt to jump from an unpopular wagon to its more popular brethren. Add this to his general lack of saying anything substantial and convenient voting behavior.

[redtail896]

Also Sach: what is your opinion of the synaesthesia wagon?

[denisatp]

Page four and someone is already at L-1? This should be fun. Crypto, mind explaining the logic behind a quicklynch?

bitching about somebody being at L-1 but not doing shit about it. asking crypto a question which he had answered before (i believe) and he didn't want an answer to this question.

petapan - That's what I've been trying to figure out. His RC was not countered, and as you stated earlier jailkeeper is one of the more popular PR, why would scum fake claim a role they know that is likely to exist? The only way this makes sense is that he figured he was going to get lynched, and thus wanted to flush out the jailkeeper before getting hammered. Admittedly that is pretty far fetched, but he stated he is exasperated which makes it plausible for me. So I think there is a good possibility he is scum.

refusing to lynch somebody on the basis of a claim in a open game. while also tipsy-toeing around giving a read on red. the "substance" in this post is also rhetoric.

As far as if red is town, projectmatt is scum. Twice he said he thinks red is town yet he has no problem leaving his vote on red who is at L-1.

these kind of partner tells is NOT how town thinks. this post is just totally fucking dumb.

deni - red claimed a PR that went unchallenged. His lynch isn't going down today.

VOTE: Synaesthesia I am not buying into his defense, too much AtE for my liking.

once again, he hides from the red lynch on the basis of a claim. then implies that AtE is a scumtell.

peta - Include yourself in that pool party, at least in the first few pages of this game. At least you had the good sense to remove yourself from it. And when I responded to you I still thought Red could be possibly scum and was trying to work through my analysis of his claim. You pointed out the flaw in my logic, and I adjusted my read. I do agree with you on one thing - in two posts Robert has shown that he will be useless.

smug post. trying to be totally friendly with peta while disagreeing with him.

deadjoker why did you just totally fucking ignore my silent vote on you when i didn't voice any suspicion before?

I called you bad town or bad scum and called Red town (who you apparently have a "death tunnel" on). Your OMGUS vote on me didn't change my views on you and warranted no more interaction. Want to be taken seriously? Start posting substance, or push my wagon. Your obvious reaction fish is obvious - gimmicks are weak.

trying to imply that i'm scum because i changed my death-tunnel while also saying that my reaction fishes are weak, a contradiction. the tone in this post is awful. once again, tipsy-toes around giving a read on me while heavily implying that im scum.

satire - The fact that red hasn't been counterclaimed either means that he really is the JK, the real JK hasn't counterclaimed yet, or that he is scum who fakeclaimed but there is no JK to counterclaim. I find it hard to believe a PR wouldn't jump at the chance to go 1 for 1 this early in the game. And a JK is one of the more popular PRs on mafiascum, indicating it is unlikely that there isn't one in this game, making possibility 3 also unlikely. So the most likely option is he really is the JK. That is why I said he is town until proven otherwise. If anyone disagrees with me, please let me know.

avoiding a read/lynch based on a uncc'ed claim in a open setup.

Tuxedo - explain riddler logic.

i understand that he didn't know what riddler-logic is but this is another question which he didn't want the answer for and asked for the sake of asking and feigning participation.

[TuxedoMask]

I don't want to lynch project while his internet is out, but that's mostly friend bias and I can still be talked into it.

Syn is still an alright choice, and so are Robert, Hibiki, and Satire. I have at least a slight townread on everyone else (guy who hasn't posted is obviously excluded). A Satire lynch won't happen because I'm alone on that read and I know Hibiki is capable of participating more and would hope some votes might get him to towntell.

wait a sec but you unvoted synaesthesia

Yeah I pussied out of the vote and I honestly don't feel comfortable leaving a vote up until everyone has participated.

Also red is hard town due to his attitude since he's claimed, he seems to know he isn't going to be CC'd in spite of the fact someone hasn't talked. Also, softpushing on Sach as mafia would be the dumbest possible thing since no one wants to lynch her. Re-evaluating based on red being hard town makes me more inclined to a deadjoker lynch.

Satire is probably town and I'm probably reading too much into his tryhard attitude towards the game because I'm dismissing all pre-conceived meta, but I'm not willing to call him hard town yet.

red denis and peta are hard town. crypto and sach soft town. satire null leaning town. syn deadjoker pj hibiki robert all still good lynches. not willing/able to truly PoE it out until everyone's talked, so I'll just sit on my hands like a baby for now.