NY Mafia 155 - New Age Mafia II - Game Over!

[scooby]

can we like lynch sableheart and get shit done instead of postting stuff that happened milliuon years ago

thank you

[Glork]

If Glork is scum, the longer we let him live, the more of a threat he becomes. A Glorkscum with 3-4 left in LYLO is a recipe for disaster. He also pushed for the massclaim D1, which I guess I was the only who thought was a scum-motivated move at the time. We'd really be in the hole if Psyche didn't get that guilty on singer.

My massclaim directly netted us one scum (nham saying "I claim") and indirectly caught us the other scum (singer's refusal to claim leading to the investigation on her). If I'm scum, I literally threw the game away on D1.

Anyway, reading this when I get home tonight. I promise. No matter what.

[Knight of Cydonia]

If Glork is scum, the longer we let him live, the more of a threat he becomes. A Glorkscum with 3-4 left in LYLO is a recipe for disaster. He also pushed for the massclaim D1, which I guess I was the only who thought was a scum-motivated move at the time. We'd really be in the hole if Psyche didn't get that guilty on singer.

My massclaim directly netted us one scum (nham saying "I claim") and indirectly caught us the other scum (singer's refusal to claim leading to the investigation on her). If I'm scum, I literally threw the game away on D1.

Anyway, reading this when I get home tonight. I promise. No matter what.

Or you were banking on getting townpoints from asking for a mass-claim and knew that at least one of your buddies was already "cleared".

[Glork]

Yep, WIFOM with

ZERO FUCKING CLUE

what the town power distribution is a great fucking play for scum to make less than ten pages into Day One of a game. *roll*

[Glork]

Protip: The more ridiculous and massive the WIFOM factor behind a hypothetical scum gambit is,

the less likely it is that it's an actual gambit

. I rarely

rarely

survive to endgame, so the idea that I'd call for a play which historically puts scums into an absolute panic D1 for the sake of "town cred" which evaporates the moment I get investigated, crosskilled, vigged by some idiot on a whim (has actually happened to me), roleblocked it tracked/watched to a dead person... That gambit falls through. There is not enough "town cred" in the world to make a play which is going to get half your scum team killed and not even guarantee that you'll be free of suspicion. Don't even fucking bring up WIFOM bullshit here because you know deep down inside that it doesn't really apply. There are not two equal choices here. One (don't force mass claim) is a good play for scum, and the other (force a mass claim) is literally ritualistic suicide for an entire scum team.

[Glork]

Also, how was one of my "buddies" cleared?

[Quagmire]

If Glork is scum, the longer we let him live, the more of a threat he becomes. A Glorkscum with 3-4 left in LYLO is a recipe for disaster. He also pushed for the massclaim D1, which I guess I was the only who thought was a scum-motivated move at the time. We'd really be in the hole if Psyche didn't get that guilty on singer.

My massclaim directly netted us one scum (nham saying "I claim") and indirectly caught us the other scum (singer's refusal to claim leading to the investigation on her). If I'm scum, I literally threw the game away on D1.

Anyway, reading this when I get home tonight. I promise. No matter what.

You seriously can't use nham as a defense here. Sorry.

[Quagmire]

Noone has correctly explained why exposing the entire town's power role structure has benefitted the town. As I said, Psyche's result on singer was a pretty lucky flip, otherwise we'd be in over our heads. How is it possible you're still defending the idea?

[OhGodMyLife]

Vote Count:

7 to lynch

redFF: 4 (MichelSableheart, JDodge, Rhinox, Quagmire)
MichelSableheart: 3 (scooby, Glork, Bella)
Rhinox: 2 (Knight of Cydonia, redFF)
scooby: 2 (Hoopla, Tierce)
Hoopla: 1 (AGar)

Not Voting: 0

Current Deadline:

Monday September 17th 10 PM EST

Still seeking a replacement for JDodge.

[scooby]

Quagmire, you are voting in a group of scummy people, this should tell you something.

[Quagmire]

No, it doesn't.

[redFF]

Deadline is quite soon. I'm fine with a Sableheart or Rhinox lynch at this point.

vote:Michaelsableheart

[AGar]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: MichelSableheart

This is just as acceptable, in retrospect.

[Quagmire]

I'm V/LA this weekend. Let's lynch redFF instead.

[Tierce]

I'm demotivated about this game in a manner that is really absurd. It makes no sense. I don't think it was the D1 massclaim, it's probably the low activity. Granted, that is also my fault, but... just sitting here, not motivated to go through what was already posted. We're still ahead, there's no reason I should feel this bleh about it--the last time I was so irked and demotivated about a game was Mini 1333, but the circumstances are not the same.

Question, redFF--what alignment do you prefer playing as?

@OGML: I'll be LA from the 15th to the 22nd.

[redFF]

I dunno, don't really think about it.

Probably town at the moment because I've fucked up as scum my last few games (ythan's nightless, otherworld)

[Quagmire]

I'm demotivated about this game in a manner that is really absurd. It makes no sense. I don't think it was the D1 massclaim, it's probably the low activity. Granted, that is also my fault, but... just sitting here, not motivated to go through what was already posted. We're still ahead, there's no reason I should feel this bleh about it--the last time I was so irked and demotivated about a game was Mini 1333, but the circumstances are not the same.

Question, redFF--what alignment do you prefer playing as?

@OGML: I'll be LA from the 15th to the 22nd.

You should probably get a replacement.

[Tierce]

It's limited access, not gone altogether. I'll have internet access at home, but I won't be home much because there are Places To Visit.

I'll check redFF's games once I get up. There's a pattern I'm looking for, let's see if it exists.

[AGar]

Something something confirmation bias something something.

[MichelSableheart]

@KoC: What's your opinion on Rhinox' claim? You've been voting him for most of the day, but have never commented on something that in my opinion is a major towntell for him. I believe your vote would be better placed elsewhere, preferably on red.

@Hoopla: do you still believe a Scooby wagon is the way to go today? There are two significant bandwagons at the moment, and Scooby's not one of them.

@Glork: you promised us a reread a week ago, but it still hasn't arrived. Why do you believe I'm a better lynch then Red?

@Agar: your vote on me is better then one on Hoopla as it helps with the PoE, but I'm getting the impression you're choosing me because I defended Hoopla. Which would be pretty poor reasoning.

@Bella: any chance of you giving an explanation for your vote?

[Knight of Cydonia]

@KoC: What's your opinion on Rhinox' claim? You've been voting him for most of the day, but have never commented on something that in my opinion is a major towntell for him. I believe your vote would be better placed elsewhere, preferably on red.

My opinion of his claim should be evident from the fact I am voting for him.

[scooby]

this game died

can we like lynch sableheart and get shit done instead of postting stuff that happened milliuon years ago

thank you

[scooby]

@KoC: What's your opinion on Rhinox' claim? You've been voting him for most of the day, but have never commented on something that in my opinion is a major towntell for him. I believe your vote would be better placed elsewhere, preferably on red.

@Hoopla: do you still believe a Scooby wagon is the way to go today? There are two significant bandwagons at the moment, and Scooby's not one of them.

@Glork: you promised us a reread a week ago, but it still hasn't arrived. Why do you believe I'm a better lynch then Red?

@Agar: your vote on me is better then one on Hoopla as it helps with the PoE, but I'm getting the impression you're choosing me because I defended Hoopla. Which would be pretty poor reasoning.

@Bella: any chance of you giving an explanation for your vote?

look at this scumbag asking OBVIOUS QUESTIIONS trying to appear ACTIVE

[Bella]

@Bella: any chance of you giving an explanation for your vote?

I'm sure there's some.

[Rhinox]

Umm i was prodded so

I dont really think msh is scum at all. I'm happy where my vote is.