In post 249, Rainbowdash wrote:Yes. Im willing to say both of them are probably not scum, but that doesnt mean one isnt scummy town and I need to figure out which one that is.
When defender gives his reasoning I will follow up with mine and probably vote for one of them.
You are waiting for something that is very unlikely to occur. Please supply the reasoning that you have for thinking solid is scum. In addition, you talk about theory and how information from town members about their role will help us trap scum through mass claim. However, you suspect both to be not scum and want to lynch them? In total, that is poor judgment.
AppleJack,
Buck! Get to work. I hardly consider your "slog" to be up to par.
inte, whilst I
agree that is a rather weak point against D3f3nd3r. I forgot your opinion of him. You want him to be killed, but not lynched, correct?
@people saying Solid is scum. I am willing to concede that this
post is bad.
I find Solid's honesty about D3f3nd3r's wagon and attacking a lurker to be honest and motivated by town ambitions. However, the rhetoric employed, specifically the "vague" comments and the questions at the end slightly undermine my confidence in calling him town. He is being antagonistic against D3f3nd3r, who we all know will not react or give the information he seeks. inte's comment that I mentioned above is bad for this reason as well.
In post 269, Rainbowdash wrote: In post 268, inte wrote:at this point in time, would you shoot d3f3nd3r if he was not lynched?
Nope. Never shoot outside of exceedingly rare situations (confirmed scum, forced win, confirmed game goes to and stays at odd numbers)
Vigs will lose town the game far far more then win it.
I fail to see the difference given that you are currently voting D3f3nd3r.
inte, how am I being
scummy?
You have given 0 reasons for suspecting me. You have only called other players to vote for me. Why?
Rainbow, please get off your high ... wait. Posts that sound as insincere as this
one are why I distrust you Rainbow.
Your arrogance and ego are distracting you.
However, thank you for finally posting the
theory.
Rainbow, you think these
actions are town?
Posts like
this and
this strengthen my read in solid being town.
McStab's post
here also has town motivation in my opinion. The tone, the call to pressure Rainbow, it all looks organic.
In post 306, Nachomamma8 wrote:Bitmap is already a pretty decent townread for me. Treating rbd with that healthy dose of paranoia early game makes me feel pretty good about him
And why not add this analysis in for McStab?
Judging from your post, you view McStab as town?
Applejack, please poke at theory. I also believe I addressed your
concerns answering
inte.
I would also like your reasoning behind solidstate scum.
Nacho, have you even
read the game?
Are you voting for me based on my actions or my predecessor's actions?
This needs to stop.
VOTE: Rainbow
I will be back later.
