Micro 28: Kingmaker Game Over

[Klick]

Here's an idea.

We need to pick someone scummy beforehand to be the next King tomorrow and kill guille. It will be somewhat like a lynch. If they refuse, we just have the next King kill them the next day.

Actually, if there is a Hero, we could do this for every lynch.

Thoughts?

[Empking]

I agree with the second paraphraph and strongly disagree with the third.

[Klick]

I didn't really like the idea of using it for every lynch either, but I just wanted to throw it out there because I thought of it.

The second is actually a good idea, IMO.

[guille2015]

I don't think it's a good Idea either. Plus, you can't guarantee that I will survive the night. I'd rather not give scum the power to Lynch, because in the end they would opt to go for a 1 for 1 trade instead of committing suicide. And I don't think to many town are eager to commit suicide also.

[Klick]

1-1 trade is completely fine, IMO. We get scum. And if town gets chosen, they should realize that they will die anyway, so they shouldn't go for someone else, possibly getting another townie killed.

[Klick]

Also, if you're killed, we can suspect the person we chose to be King.

@Mod: Are we allowed to say who we

are

going to choose as King for upcoming Nights?

[guille2015]

1-1 trade is completely fine, IMO. We get scum. And if town gets chosen, they should realize that they will die anyway, so they shouldn't go for someone else, possibly getting another townie killed.

I'd rather just Kill the scummy person, than to give them a chance to kill someone else. If we think they are scummy, we kill them. Period.

Also, if you're killed, we can suspect the person we chose to be King.

If the chosen King is town, scum will likely kill me to make them scummy, if we are going to assume that. There is too much WIFOM in this situation.

[Klick]

Look, the whole reason to do this is to try to confirm your alignment.

[guille2015]

I know, I just think it's a bad idea and there is a better way. I cannot become the King anymore.

[guille2015]

@Mod: I will be V/LA until Tuesday 25th.

[Battousai]

@Mod: Are we allowed to say who we

are

going to choose as King for upcoming Nights?

You may say who you are going to choose for King.

[Nachomamma8]

interesting. I don't think that it would be a good move for guile scum to fakeclaim hero if his partner was under a lot of fire (uct). for that reason, I kind of want to elect uct as king and have him execute guile tomorrow, even though he's almost certainly a lying fucking scumbag.

meaning today I would like to execute lurker ireland.

[Klick]

@Mod: In the event of a tie in King votes, what happens?

I have a plan, but it will be difficult to carry out.

[Battousai]

@Mod: In the event of a tie in King votes, what happens?

In the event of a tie, the person with the most first choice picks becomes King. In the event that they both have the same amount of first choice picks, then it becomes random amoung the players that tied.

[Empking]

interesting. I don't think that it would be a good move for guile scum to fakeclaim hero if his partner was under a lot of fire (uct). for that reason, I kind of want to elect uct as king and have him execute guile tomorrow, even though he's almost certainly a lying fucking scumbag.

meaning today I would like to execute lurker ireland.

My thinking was that Utc was the best candidate for hitting the Hero but I'd rather have him killed today. A righteous policy lynch (AI) seems to best placed to test Guile than the purely scummy Utc. I trust AI more to follow the plan essentialy wheras Utc would probably simply get in an extra scum kill.

Actually, to be frank I'd like to volunteer to test Guile. I'm probably not the super town-reads but I can trust myself absolutely so I think that's be the best way forward (but obviously I have no idea what it looks like from a town non-me POV.)

[Klick]

But I think you're town, so I don't really want you to die if guille ends up being town.

I would be fine with the following shooting guille: AI, Rach, RXK

[uctriton00]

Making me king works since I'm town, but won't scum night kill me if they know that a townie is up for nomination?

[Klick]

Good for us. They killed a scummy player.

I'm thinking of something.

[Klick]

Okay, no night plan would work without us knowing if there's a Town Crier, and if so, who it is.

I'm assuming no one would be willing to have the possible Town Crier claim?

[MaverickMaestro]

Maybe.

[RachMarie]

Kondi?? Fishing for PRs?

[Klick]

You really should know that I have good intentions for this, and that I'm pretty obvious town.

You should also know that you're my top suspect at this point.

[RachMarie]

Why would that be? Just because I found you trying to out a town crier if we have one rather fishy?

[Klick]

Not in the slightest.

You're incredibly easy to read.

[RachMarie]

umm should I point out that I am often thought as scummy no matter what my alignment is? I can post games showing I got lynched even after a PR claim of Doc, not once but TWICE recently. With no CC either.