Open 446: C9++ (Avast! Viruses!) - GAME OVER

[Nachomamma8]

@Yoshi, #235:

Mafia as a whole: Not everything in a game is LyLo.

This game in particular: I know yabba (mod) from elsewhere on the internet.



Solid: I'd get a larger read if possible, but I was struck by 226.


Also, why was the early wagon on me over other wagons?

This post reads like him being offended that someone called him bad at mafia and asked why he played.
implying that he is good at mafia
so he should be playing seriously because he knows yabba

BUT

Is the game over? If so, you're fine. If not, I don't think so.

he pulls out the scumtastic prod dodge
and then goes V/LA afterwards
no
fuck that
he doesn't want to ISO the ponies while one is getting lynched
he wants to get one lynched and kill the other

LYNCH THIS FUCKING SCUMBAG

[Nachomamma8]

AtE

why do you care so much about ate, anyways?
why don't you care about appeals to experience?
because mcstab is dropping that shit like so many breadcrumbs

[solidstate]

Nacho, I voted him, dont yell at me. Yell at seil and bitmap, they are the potentially townie people that need to move wagons.

[inte]

good job rbd, you always find a way to make easier targets out to be bad
lynch applejack
cop investigates rbd
we go to d2

pedit:

experience -> more likely to be right
emotion -> more likely to be a manipulating baby

who do i want helping me scumhunt?

[solidstate]

Well, confirmed townie person + potentially townie person. Obv.

[solidstate]

inte, if you really believe that AtE stuff so strongly, maybe you need to do an ISO read on McStab.

[inte]

inte, if you really believe that AtE stuff so strongly, maybe you need to do an ISO read on McStab.

you can't keep all emotion from your posts.

applejack is the main offender. plus, i already had a town read on mcstab before the bullshit case came up.

[yabbaguy]

zabriel replaces Demon Core. To allow them time to contribute, +2 days to deadline, you now have until Sept. 27 @ 23:59 EDT.

[Nachomamma8]

experience -> more likely to be right
emotion -> more likely to be a manipulating baby

who do i want helping me scumhunt?

this doesn't make any sense.
do you want applejack helping you scumhunt, who has actually done shit and gave opinions, or
DEFENDER
fucking defender
who is also probably scum and won't help you find scum for shit

[Nachomamma8]

mcstab is proveable, so obviously we aren't lynching him today
so it's between applejack and defender
why not defender?

[Rainbowdash]

good job rbd, you always find a way to make easier targets out to be bad

What part of my logic there is wrong?

MS claims unproveable T2 which means doc which auto wants to lynch a T1 claim of same type. Heck I would never touch a T1 claim below me apart from them being confirmed before a massclaim. So either he is trying to lynch somepony who is somewhat confirmable or is lying about his claim, both which point to him being scum. We arent lynching him today but he is probably scum which adds to AJ-town and defender-scum reads.

[Nachomamma8]

pause for a moment?

It's provable by the existence of a T1 role.

RBD, what the fuck are you talking about?

[Rainbowdash]

pause for a moment?

It's provable by the existence of a T1 role.

RBD, what the fuck are you talking about?

He has it reversed.

T1 existing doesnt mean T2 exists.
T2 existing does mean a T1 exists.

It would be like being one shot doc. It means that a doctor does exist. A doctor claim means a one shot CAN exist.

I think at somepoint he said the role was not confirmable through action meaning that it would have to be a doc, meaning his attack on what DOES exist from a one shot doc standpoint feels wrong. Even if he thinks DY is scum, if a massclaim happens and nopony else claims doctor - DY to MS as a one shot doc is confirmed town.

[DoomYoshi]

Ok, we have time. Mcstab needs to claim.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: mcstab

[Rainbowdash]

Ok, we have time. Mcstab needs to claim.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: mcstab

No...

He just claims BEFORE we massclaim. If he is scum he has to get lucky already. If he is derp town it means scum gets to worry about what he is which given an IC around is huge.

[solidstate]

I hate the pony shit but that picture made me laugh.

[inte]

its a cult following i don't understand

ANYWAYS, applejack is dying today

[Nachomamma8]

Ok, we have time. Mcstab needs to claim.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: mcstab

NO BAD BAD
get to defender

[solidstate]

inte you should respond to Nacho.

He made a very good point in counter to you: You said you want experience for scumhunting. In what way does Defender's existence contribute to this?

[zabriel]

Okay. Hi. Just finished reading everything.

Protip: 30 pages of mafia posts in one sitting mostly just gives you a headache. Not even going to try to put up a huge wall of stuff right now.

Basically:

Ponies: I'm feeling town on RBD and AJ. They seem to be playing a clean game.
Nacho: Seems town. Gonna stick there.
Yoshi: Strong town before claim, less town after claim. Tucked in the "we'll see" folder. PEdit: Didn't like the claim request on MS. Just bugs me to have too many claims on D1.
McStab: I'm not really sure. The whole thing between him and AJ helped me form my town read on AJ, but I don't know if he's fake-claiming or just a really unpleasant townie.
Defender: Play has been ass. My vote will probably land here.
Bitmap: Played with Bit before.
Inte: Rather aggressive. Not a huge fan of the playstyle. Not a fan of the AJ tunnel. Not sure.
Solidstate: Been back and forth. I like his last question.

Eyes are bugging out. Stopping for now.

[inte]

aint that some shit

ponies having town reads on each other

[Rainbowdash]

Bet MS is going to comment on it...

[Nachomamma8]

aint that some shit

ponies having town reads on each other

so stubborn

[inte]

im just sayin'

if there isn't any bias whatsoever, i'm crazy

[Rainbowdash]

Not going to lie and say I dont want AJ to be town more than most others, but I do have reasons for having a town read at the same time.