NY 159: RUST game over

[Tazaro]

more likely to be scum than BC

[Cheery Dog]

@Rob13 It's not the exact same, just similar in that it was likely to have been missing a word or two.

In my point of view, both claims are true. It's too much of a coincidence for BC

to fakeclaim before I did

. So if I somehow flip, then BC will be confirmed town miller. Voting for him is stupid, unless you think we are both fakeclaiming. Will reread and make reads later.

Thanks for just admitting you fakeclaimed, that makes it so much easier for me to decide which one of the miller claims I'm down for lynching.

VOTE: Malpascp

[Rob14]

I suppose the coincidence does make malpascp more likely to be a scum who is fakeclaiming miller after BloodCovenant's claim.

No, it doesn't. Assuming mal was truthful about not reading the thread, then they were two independent events. It's like flipping a coin. If you flip the coin once and land on heads, you still have a 50/50 chance of landing on both heads or tails the next time. The firsts event is independent of the second event. The WIFOM involved in trying to figure out the motivations of any miller claim applies equally to both. This is, of course, assuming that mal wasn't lying about not reading the thread.

If mal was untruthful about not reading the thread, then he's scum and an idiot. He would have immense pressure on him if BC flipped town miller, and BC had the most pressure on him when mal claimed, making him (at the time) the most likely lynch candidate. That would be the dumbest scum move ever - guaranteeing you pressure on Day 2 for no gain.

I really can't explain this any other way, so I'm going to ignore any future attempt at WIFOM discussion on these miller claims. It's a waste of time.

[Tazaro]

AngryPidgeon: town.
Y:Intuition

[Tazaro]

Therefore

VOTE: Zabriel

[Demon Core]

Sorry about the recent inactivity people. Been

cramming

thoroughly preparing for the GRE for the few days and have had a very, very limited time on here.

[drmyshotgun]

Can we like lynch fucking "Miller" right now?

[malpascp]

Can we like lynch fucking "Miller" right now?

Why not lynching scum?

[drmyshotgun]

That's bonus in lynching you thanks.

[Josh Lyman]

Oh, look, I'm here. I hate miller claims. I'd almost policy lynch anyone who does so, but everyone seems to hate that more than miller claims. So, I'm apparently fucked.

I need to thoroughly re-read all 15 (!!!) pages of this game and get back to you soon.

[4nxi3ty]

AngryPidgeon

(2) - zabriel, curiouskarmadog

zabriel

(4)

- ProHawk, roflcopter, Dathe, Tazaro

Rob13

(1) - PeregrineV

DemonCore

(1) - Rob13

malpascp

(2) - Cheery Dog, drmyshotgun

Darthe

(2) - AngryPidgeon, BloodCovenant

Not Voting

(6) - malpascp, Josh Lyman, PMysterious, scooby, DemonCore

BloodCovenant V/LA til monday morning.
curiouskarmadog V/LA til sunday.

prodding ProHawk, zabriel, PMysterious.

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.
Deadline: (expired on 2012-10-23 15:08:03)

[zabriel]

Oh hey, actually here.

Malpascp's hardcore defense of BC is one of the things keeping me off Mal's wagon. Town got pretty burned on a popular policy lynch in another game I'm in, so I'm a little bit wary of charging forward on this one.

[AngryPidgeon]

Cool, we should vote DemonCore, CKD or Darthe then.

[Rob14]

Cool, we should vote DemonCore, CKD or Darthe then.

DemonCore is the extremely obvious option. His ISO speaks for itself.

[AngryPidgeon]

Hi Rob, lemme ISO aforementioned peeps.

[scooby]

Imma reading and ronight Ill post

if not replace me

peace

[AngryPidgeon]

I can actually almost see Prohawk scum after a glance of his ISO. Still working slowly. Playing dominion. Lol. gimme an hour

[ProHawk]

I disagree with a Miller policy lynch.

[drmyshotgun]

Oh hey, actually here.

Malpascp's hardcore defense of BC is one of the things keeping me off Mal's wagon. Town got pretty burned on a popular policy lynch in another game I'm in, so I'm a little bit wary of charging forward on this one.

Yeah? Fucking longer the both Millers live, more advantage for scumteam to keep playing with goddamn WIFOM and shits like that.
Finish this day already please.

I disagree with a Miller policy lynch.

It is not a policy lynch. Malpascp is legitimately scummy. Kill it with fire.

I can actually almost see Prohawk scum after a glance of his ISO. Still working slowly. Playing dominion. Lol. gimme an hour

So far I recall you calling many people scums recently. List them all in one post for me thanks.

Also: Anyone thinking PMysterious is being pro-Town and will do us good if he (she?) survives longer, I dare you to say it out loud.

Cool, we should vote DemonCore, CKD or Darthe then.

No.

[AngryPidgeon]

It is not a policy lynch. Malpascp is legitimately scummy. Kill it with fire.

Agree, I think.

Let me finish ISOs?

Top of my head I'd like to lynch Darthe, DemonCore, CKD, Malp, Zabriel. In roughly that order. Prohawk I need to reread. I do think I'll be able to read him more accurately than I do almost all other peeps.

[Rob14]

Also: Anyone thinking PMysterious is being pro-Town and will do us good if he (she?) survives longer, I dare you to say it out loud.

I don't think he's pro-town or anti-town. He's done nothing in-game. He'll probably be replaced. Stop your anti-PMysterious nonsense. We get that you don't like him as a player. If he prod-dodges and remains a lurker, then I'll consider lynching him. If he gets replaced, we might find that we have someone that is pro-town and a benefit to the town. He's clearly not our best Day 1 lynch target.

Mal is legitimately scummy, but my vote stays on Demon for the day. Unless someone does something new that is unbearably scummy or provides amazing new insights in a new case, then he's our best option for the day. Mal is worth looking at in Day 2.

[drmyshotgun]

It is not a policy lynch. Malpascp is legitimately scummy. Kill it with fire.

Agree, I think.

Let me finish ISOs?

Top of my head I'd like to lynch Darthe, DemonCore, CKD, Malp, Zabriel. In roughly that order. Prohawk I need to reread. I do think I'll be able to read him more accurately than I do almost all other peeps.

Did you forget about me or something here. I thought I was like Conf-Scum to you? No more?

Mal is legitimately scummy, but my vote stays on Demon for the day. Unless someone does something new that is unbearably scummy or provides amazing new insights in a new case, then he's our best option for the day. Mal is worth looking at in Day 2.

Why the wait? What advantage does it give us to leave a WIFOM lying around when we can take care of it now? Is Malpa precious asset to Town or something.
Well I agree that Demon is pretty useless and I also acknowledge people's cases on him.
But I'd much rather cut the crap coming from Malpascp and Tazaro by double combo.

[drmyshotgun]

I don't think he's pro-town or anti-town. He's done nothing in-game. He'll probably be replaced. Stop your anti-PMysterious nonsense. We get that you don't like him as a player. If he prod-dodges and remains a lurker, then I'll consider lynching him. If he gets replaced, we might find that we have someone that is pro-town and a benefit to the town. He's clearly not our best Day 1 lynch target.

Oh please. He's a waste of space. I'd much prefer he does one pro-Town thing and that is to get replaced out.
Where did I say I want to lynch him recently? My point was that I'd like to see him disappear from Playerlist asap.

[AngryPidgeon]

Did you forget about me or something here. I thought I was like Conf-Scum to you? No more?

Naw you're town. No way scum tunnels me after le slip.

[AngryPidgeon]

Darthe's reaction to it is obvscum though.