Mini 1,384: Dirty Dealing (Game over!)

[Soul2277]

^~Mehdi

~Mehdi

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

Nobody Special (1): Salamence20
Salamence20 (1): GreyICE
Not voting (7): AngryPidgeon, killerjester, Nobody Special, PiggyGal15, PMysterious, Soul2277, Voidedmafia

With

9

players alive, it takes

5

players to lynch.

[Salamence20]

*Notices Mod doesn't say Piggy is in trouble*

*Notices Mod has AP voting me, when GreyIce was voting me*

*Wonders if Piggy is faking a post restriction*

[AngryPidgeon]

VOTE: GreyICE

[StrangerCoug]

*Notices Mod has AP voting me, when GreyIce was voting me*

Fixed.

[killerjester]

What would your initial response have been if PM died last night?

Are we assuming he'd flip town?

[GreyICE]

*Looks at GreyIce*
*Confused look*

I'm voting for scum.

I know you Salamance. You've got some cute plan running here where you want to show off. You always do this. Have a cute plan. As town, you claim scum. As scum, you figure "this super fake post restriction won't draw any attention to me."

You picked the same post restriction as Hascow used in Storm of Swords, and it has the same flaw.

*Asks the group why this = scum*

How is that an action, Salamance?

Dayvig/Kill/Destroy/Nuke: Shahrizai

How is that following your post restriction Salamance?

*Looks at GreyIce Wagon*
*Refuses to take part*

"Refuses to take part"

Really?

An action is "refuses to take part?"

Really Salamance?

This is super fake, and you're super scum.

[GreyICE]

*Wonders if Piggy is faking a post restriction*

Yeah, uh huh.

The guy with the post restriction wonders if someone is faking a post restriction.

"Wonders if Piggy is faking a post restriction"

What sort of action is that again, Salamance?

Is your post restriction that you have to put little stars around each sentence you type? If so, why aren't you typing normally, with stars?

[AngryPidgeon]

What would your initial response have been if PM died last night?

Are we assuming he'd flip town?

Yes, I mean assume he flipped VT. Basically Im saying imagine someone not as active died instead of MoI/VM/Me/Soul

[Salamence20]

*Laughs hysterically*
*Sarcastically claims scum*
*Claims conftown*

[Salamence20]

kill: PMysterious

[Salamence20]

before I could claim

something

.

Dayvig/Kill/Destroy/Nuke: Shahrizai

[Salamence20]

kill: PMysterious

*Waves gun*
*Points and shoots himself*
*No bullet*
*Looks at mod*
*Points middle finger*

[Nobody Special]

I rather think Salamence is very anti-town, too. So anti-town, in fact, that he jumps the shark into Scumland.

Vote: Salamence

[Salamence20]

VOTE: NS

[AngryPidgeon]

Ok, so NS and Soul are probably town.

[GreyICE]

*Laughs hysterically*
*Sarcastically claims scum*
*Claims conftown*

Ah, so what is your post restriction exactly?

You don't seem able to explain

[Soul2277]

Ok, so

NS

and Soul are probably town.

Explain. I personally find NS to be really likely scum. Still think sala is town and shouldn't be voted (faking a pr is an excuse to coast a whole lot with little opinions, but that's not what he's been doing). Parama flipped town and even stated SC loves PRs so I'm not surprised with a teller type pr.

[Soul2277]

^~Mehdi

~Mehdi

I really suck at remembering this at times.

[AngryPidgeon]

I rather think Salamence is very anti-town, too. So anti-town, in fact, that he jumps the shark into Scumland.

Vote: Salamence

Does this post honestly come from scum? I think its too awkward for that.

[Soul2277]

VOTE: NS

It's blatant sheeping like all his votes that have little thought or conviction. Bah, I wanted to wait before posting this, but I'll assume OS wouldn't mind (yup more then one wall was made during the night phase):

We wrote this during the night so we have to link to posts instead of quotes. Thank goodness Nobody Special is not very active... or verbose. Makes it very easy to analyze all of his posts.

Nobody's first content post. He never explains his reasoning for the DrMyShotgun vote and despite the mislynch you think he would at least express some opinion about the previous day. No, the previous day's history is like water off a duck's back to NS.

He asks Voided a pointless question that both Mafia and Town will answer the same. However, I have seen people try and gauge the tone and the syntax from that answer as a ways to analyze their sincerity. We will let this slide for now.

He asks Salamence, the player who can only post through Teller-like mime actions, what his PR is. What was the point of this question again? The PR has been used a few times within the last year and a half that if NS really cared about knowing he could have easily asked anyone else what it could be.

A good question to Piggy, but it is interesting that he names Voided and MoI after we have stated our suspicion towards both those players. We are noting this for potential relational tells in the future.

A question to MoI about his objective for this game. Again, like the question to Voided a completely pointless response as the overall answer will be the same for both Mafia and Town. Stylistically there will be some variance, but I (Oversoul) never took NS to be about the verbose or deeper meaning.

A good question towards Killer. See above about the question to Piggy.

Why didn't he ask Grey about MoI and Voided?

NS's answer to our question.

Has NS given reason for *anything* he's done this game?
Rhetorical question - the answer is no by the way.

NS answering our accusation that he is scum. This is the type of response I would expect from scum. Trying to play off the severity of the accusation while not getting into why, or even delving into the reason why we suspect him.

This post and this post are votes without reason, again like his DrMyShotgun vote. Have you noticed a pattern yet? It is called NS does not care about who he votes. He does not care about his suspects (he asked 7 people questions, yet he is suspicious of none of them).

The original vote on Shah is important because it shows he does not legitimately think she is scum. The second vote, one to pressure GI is useless and an attempt to divert the wagon now that Shah has claimed. He does not think Shah is scum. And he does not think GI is scum either.

Who does NS think is scum?
Rhetorical question - no one.

Hammers Shah for again, no discernible reason. At no point ever in this game has NS stated who his suspicions were. At no point in this game has NS attempted to scumhunt.

The hammer on Shah? For the sake of a hammer and a kill on someone that isn't him or one of his buddies.

~Mehdi

[Nobody Special]

You just don't understand the way I play.

[Soul2277]

Self meta isn't enough to excuse you from being on the wagons of two townies near the later stages while showing 0 suspicion of them before which just lets you sheep easily. You've shown 0 suspicion of sala all game, but yet jump on him quickly after grey? No, you are just wagoning people hoping meta or lurking will be enough to not get you attacked enough to be lynched.

~Mehdi

[AngryPidgeon]

Ok, Im going to run some ISOs. And then

cry in the corner about Shah flipping Jester, seriously write a guide for me

figure out which of these is the best lynch: {PM, Killer, Piggy Sally}

GreyICE, you are ignoring me on purpose. I want you to answer me. Am I town? Was my push on Shah townie? Is it weird that I didn't die last night?

[AngryPidgeon]

Fair warning Grey, you are more of an empath than most people on the site and see shit from not-you perspectives quite well. Im ready for any bullshit WIFOM you may say.