Mafiastuck (GAME OVER TOWN WINS!)

[xtopherusD]

Xtoph Vifam doesn't read as scum at all.

Okay, noted?

Also I don't understand why you took so much time and effort to analyze jokes?

There was little to no effort in posting those few sentences. A quarter of it was direct quotes from their posts. Half was summarised from the post(s) they'd made previously. The other quarter was so simple it nearly hurts that I had to say it.

I haven't nearly spent as much time as some other people have on Alsark's joke. I don't understand why you're calling me out on taking "so much" of

my

time and

my

"effort" to say what I wanted to say.

[Vifam]

Vote: Robocopter87.

Cheery Dog probably scum too.

VOTE: Robocopter87

One scum caught.

ha ha...

can we get a votecount?

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

I haven't nearly spent as much time as some other people have on Alsark's joke. I don't understand why you're calling me out on taking "so much" of my time and my "effort" to say what I wanted to say.

Because you really could've focusd on something that was more productive. Here it just looks like you are trying to gain towncred by analyzing stuff when it's really not helpful to the town at all when all you conclude is that the claims were a joke. You know, town's posts come from town thought, and I would very much like to understand why chose to focus on those specific things and analyze them.

[Titan]

I haven't nearly spent as much time as some other people have on Alsark's joke. I don't understand why you're calling me out on taking "so much" of my time and my "effort" to say what I wanted to say.

Because you really could've focusd on something that was more productive. Here it just looks like you are trying to gain towncred by analyzing stuff when it's really not helpful to the town at all when all you conclude is that the claims were a joke. You know, town's posts come from town thought, and I would very much like to understand why chose to focus on those specific things and analyze them.

Sigh. I have to remember to switch the accounts when I go on a phone <_<

[Alsark]

Vote: Robocopter87.

Cheery Dog probably scum too.

VOTE: Robocopter87

One scum caught.

^ That was scummy.

And you're a funny man, Paschendale! You think that I seriously was claiming a role where I had to speak in the confirmation phase while the GM specifically told us we can't speak during the confirmation phase? Bravo, bravo! xtopherusD is actually right - it was mostly a joke, but I was also hoping that somebody on the scum team had the IQ of a retarded goldfish. No such luck .

I'm not really seeing the Phil lynch, nor the Vifam lynch. Unfortunately, the lot of you have the advantage of knowing one another and knowing how one another players - I have no such knowledge. From an outside perspective, however, I see nothing wrong with either of these individuals.

Meanwhile, I don't like DeasVail's posts at all. For example:

know who I'll be voting for when the game starts...

He says this as though somebody just said something that makes him want to vote for them. Okay, that's legit - but who? And what did they say?

VOTE: NumberQ

Also, sunman is badman.

And I don't like the rubik guy either.

PEdit: Well that was easy.

What? So the person you wanted to vote for was somebody who hadn't even posted yet?

What really alerted me to DeasVail, though, is his reaction to Pandorica's post 225. I'll be honest, I hate when people ask, "Are you scum?" It's a stupid question. What do you expect them to say? But his reaction is, for one, way too serious - and then he just pointlessly returns the question. Then he's like, "um... I

may

think of something eventually." May? "No! Try not! Do! Or do not! There is no try!"

Anybody wanna provide me with a meta read on this guy?

[Alsark]

Oh, I forgot the most important part:

VOTE: DeadVail

(( That typo was initially an accident, but I decided to leave it. Adds some flavor. ))

[Epic]

he's (probably) town and your post is stretching

[Pandorica]

^ That was scummy.

No?

[Epic]

see what you see as "way too serious and pointlessly returning the question" i see as just being nonchalant (which is not why i think he's town it's that i think there's an implicit thought process to his vote that i like. not that i like the vote itself)

[xtopherusD]

I haven't nearly spent as much time as some other people have on Alsark's joke. I don't understand why you're calling me out on taking "so much" of my time and my "effort" to say what I wanted to say.

Because you really could've focusd on something that was more productive. Here it just looks like you are trying to gain towncred by analyzing stuff when it's really not helpful to the town at all when all you conclude is that the claims were a joke. You know, town's posts come from town thought, and I would very much like to understand why chose to focus on those specific things and analyze them.

Again, it's how I talk.

Where most will say "Guys get over it, it looks like Alsark was joking", I will say what I think and tell you why I think it. So my posts will be {evidence and conclusion} so another player can post {agreement or disagreement}, instead of {conclusion} then {questioning} then {evidence}. It ends up taking less time (in theory), plus it helps me to organise my thoughts both while posting and while reading through the thread.

I won't post random thoughts or baseless arguments. If I don't know why I think something, I work out why I do. If I can't work out why, I don't voice that opinion.

[Alsark]

see what you see as "way too serious and pointlessly returning the question" i see as just being nonchalant (which is not why i think he's town it's that i think there's an implicit thought process to his vote that i like. not that i like the vote itself)

So why do you think that he is town?

[Epic]

i answered that in that post please read it carefully

[Epic]

xtopher is scum, also.

[Robocopter87]

^ That was scummy.

Caught scum did something scummy?

Tell me more.

[Vifam]

Robocopter please stop

[Epic]

Robocopter please stop

[Robocopter87]

Robocopter please stop

OR WHAT

[Alsark]

No, I mean, can you elaborate? Why do you like somebody randomly voting somebody who he supposedly knew he would vote who hadn't even posted yet? What sort of "thought processes" there seem town?

[Vifam]

I have pink eye and Im stuck in my house on Halloween night, I could be fucking some girl dressed as my favorite Japanese cartoon character right now, you're breaking me down and hurting me emotionally, please stop.

[Alsark]

I could be fucking some girl dressed as my favorite Japanese cartoon character right now

That Vifam lynch just became legit.

[Robocopter87]

I have pink eye and Im stuck in my house on Halloween night, I could be fucking some girl dressed as my favorite Japanese cartoon character right now, you're breaking me down and hurting me emotionally, please stop.

My only concern is that I am too town and will draw the nightkill and since I am obviously a PR I better not continue my rampaging towniness.

You win this round.

But don't yell at me at endgame when I told you to lynch obvscum and you told me to stop.

Unvote

[Epic]

No, I mean, can you elaborate? Why do you like somebody randomly voting somebody who he supposedly knew he would vote who hadn't even posted yet? What sort of "thought processes" there seem town?

the "i know who i'm voting" post was

probably

him getting hella mad at me trolling the scrubs, but regardless it then became unimportant, numberq's post was kind of bad so he decided to vote for it

really i'm not going to go into a wall of words on a d1 gutread because it makes my conviction seem stronger than it is

[Vifam]

Thanks

Anyway I don't think xtoph is scum, I mean he could be, even though his posts are a whole lot of nothing (which is hilarious cuz that is what he is apparently calling me out on lmfao), I don't think it was particularly scummy.

I haven't nearly spent as much time as some other people have on Alsark's joke. I don't understand why you're calling me out on taking "so much" of my time and my "effort" to say what I wanted to say.

Because you really could've focusd on something that was more productive. Here it just looks like you are trying to gain towncred by analyzing stuff when it's really not helpful to the town at all when all you conclude is that the claims were a joke. You know, town's posts come from town thought, and I would very much like to understand why chose to focus on those specific things and analyze them.

Again, it's how I talk.

Where most will say "Guys get over it, it looks like Alsark was joking", I will say what I think and tell you why I think it. So my posts will be {evidence and conclusion} so another player can post {agreement or disagreement}, instead of {conclusion} then {questioning} then {evidence}. It ends up taking less time (in theory), plus it helps me to organise my thoughts both while posting and while reading through the thread.

I won't post random thoughts or baseless arguments. If I don't know why I think something, I work out why I do. If I can't work out why, I don't voice that opinion.

This post could probably better but I think he was honestly trying to convey his way of communication even though it sounds retarded and scumlike.

[xtopherusD]

In Day One of any game, my posts do tend to include a whole lot of nothing. There usually isn't a whole lot of anything to make conclusions from, so I don't have a lot to say I believe. Also not helping with the current content level is the fact that we are only seven hours into the game, and so nearly half of the players haven't posted anything since day start.

So, it does sound "retarded and scumlike", but that's how it is.

[Vifam]

Okay I didn't ask