NY 159: RUST game over

[Rob14]

Maybe I'm wrong about this, but what do you feel about this:

Assuming one scum is left and Josh hasn't logged in since Day 2, we can conclude he is town because someone sent in the NK.

[Paid Pyro]

Prohawk why Josh over me.

Cheery, I admit I missed most of D3. It went by so fast, it's no excuse.... but by the time I would get on line I would have so much to catch up on I spent most of my time trying to catch up before I felt I could post. Honestly, I'm still pretty far behind because I'm not going to spend a bunch of time reading if I'm NKed. Soooo.. What do you want to know, so you can clarify my spot?


With the claims/fake claims how is malp conftown?

Isn't AP "not scum" based on someones claim (town or SK). Rob you are a JOAT with a one shot correct?

Rob I've claimed.... Look at my iso and you'll see it..... ummm you might miss it since my ISO is soooooo long.

[ProHawk]

@ PP - He has even less info in his ISO than you do, but we all have to start somewhere.

@Rob - This is assuming that he can't send in a kill from the QT. You are also assuming that there is only one more scum slot left?

Looking more closely at times, he should have been replaced already.... so vote stays until his replacement arrives.

[Rob14]

Prohawk why Josh over me.

Cheery, I admit I missed most of D3. It went by so fast, it's no excuse.... but by the time I would get on line I would have so much to catch up on I spent most of my time trying to catch up before I felt I could post. Honestly, I'm still pretty far behind because I'm not going to spend a bunch of time reading if I'm NKed. Soooo.. What do you want to know, so you can clarify my spot?


With the claims/fake claims how is malp conftown?

Isn't AP "not scum" based on someones claim (town or SK). Rob you are a JOAT with a one shot correct?

Rob I've claimed.... Look at my iso and you'll see it..... ummm you might miss it since my ISO is soooooo long.

I'm JOAT with one-shot cop, one-shot vig. It's all used up, so consider me a vanilla townie for the rest of the game.

[Rob14]

@ PP - He has even less info in his ISO than you do, but we all have to start somewhere.

@Rob - This is assuming that he can't send in a kill from the QT. You are also assuming that there is only one more scum slot left?

Looking more closely at times, he should have been replaced already.... so vote stays until his replacement arrives.

Assuming one scum left because there are normally ~25% players as anti-town, so 4.25 scum in a 17 person game = 4 scum. Five scum are unlikely considering town miller (weakening town) and scum PRs (JOAT and doctor are significant).

[Rob14]

Prohawk why Josh over me.

Cheery, I admit I missed most of D3. It went by so fast, it's no excuse.... but by the time I would get on line I would have so much to catch up on I spent most of my time trying to catch up before I felt I could post. Honestly, I'm still pretty far behind because I'm not going to spend a bunch of time reading if I'm NKed. Soooo.. What do you want to know, so you can clarify my spot?


With the claims/fake claims how is malp conftown?

Isn't AP "not scum" based on someones claim (town or SK). Rob you are a JOAT with a one shot correct?

Rob I've claimed.... Look at my iso and you'll see it..... ummm you might miss it since my ISO is soooooo long.

I assumed you hadn't claimed because, well, you haven't been here much. Can you catch up and give reads? I promise we won't end this day until you do if you commit to getting us reads within a week. That way you aren't wasting time.

[Darthe]

Hey, I wanted to help out a bit here by giving you all a link to a game that shows my town meta and a game that shows my mafia meta since I am new. Perhaps not the best time but since Rob is willing to give PP a week I figure this is acceptable now:

Mafia: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic ... vier-wins/

Town: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic ... ighborhood

[Cheery Dog]

Maybe I'm wrong about this, but what do you feel about this:

Assuming one scum is left and Josh hasn't logged in since Day 2, we can conclude he is town because someone sent in the NK.

That is the reasoning I produced for why I voted Paid Pyro out of the two.

I'm not seeing rofl scum from his day 1 play, his reaction straight away to DC's claim was

vote: demon core

hammer it

Although the unvote on L-1 before the claim was also weird.

[TheReverend]

It's 6am and I'm drunk. WHY AM I STILL AWAKE? I'll read up tomorrow. wn
roflcopter* - leaning town
Josh Lyman** - leaning town based on rob's town tell
Paid Pyro - scummy
AngryPidgeon - town
The Reverend - town
Rob13 - town

[TheReverend]

lol I posted that before I intended, was still making my reads list. Fuck this I need sleep, I'll reassess tomorrow.

[TheReverend]

my other scum reads are darthe and malp fwiw. Good nnight all.

[AngryPidgeon]

Guys, the last scum is still in Darthe, Malp, Rofl. Its literally one of those.

Cheery, that quote actually made me think hes scum. Rofl's entire interaction with the Dcore wagon is silly considering his lack of concern about Dcore up until the point he became a wagon.

[Rob14]

Guys, the last scum is still in Darthe, Malp, Rofl. Its literally one of those.

Cheery, that quote actually made me think hes scum. Rofl's entire interaction with the Dcore wagon is silly considering his lack of concern about Dcore up until the point he became a wagon.

He voted for D-Core and at the same time said that he wanted to lynch Zab tomorrow, keeping momentum on Zab alive. Why would scum ever do that? He's pushing to have two less partners by Day 3. That has some pretty intense town motivation and no scum motivation.

[Darthe]

Meh, I am still and have been VT. Where the hell did malp go?

[TheReverend]

lol I don't even remember posting this morning. And now I have a hangover. Fuck off world, I'm going back to sleep.

VOTE: darthe

[Rob14]

Darthe is extremely pingy. If I ignore my prior opinion about his gambit reaction (which rofl/AP did a pretty good job convincing me that it was not a good way to form a read), then he's the scummiest person left alive.

[4nxi3ty]

Darthe

(3)

- roflcopter, AngryPidgeon, TheReverend

Josh Lyman

(1) - ProHawk

Paid Pyro

(1) - Cheery Dog

Not Voting

(5) - malpascp, Darthe, Josh Lyman, Paid Pyro, Rob13

@Mod - What's the status of Josh Lyman on prods/replace?

he gets one more prod before being replaced.

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.
Deadline: (expired on 2012-11-14 12:43:07)

[Rob14]

My Reads, for all to see:

Definite Town: Me, AP, rofl, Rev
Highly Probable Town: ProHawk, Josh Lyman (based on what I said earlier), Cheery
Possible Scum (basically meaning "not a town read" at this point): Mal, PP
Probable Scum: Darthe

[Rob14]

And before you ask "why no Darthe vote?!?!?!?"

I will not be voting while waiting for PP's catch-up, because I do not want a lynch during that time. If a lynch were to occur during that time, then I will have strong words for the Darthe wagon.

[AngryPidgeon]

He voted for D-Core and at the same time said that he wanted to lynch Zab tomorrow, keeping momentum on Zab alive. Why would scum ever do that? He's pushing to have two less partners by Day 3. That has some pretty intense town motivation and no scum motivation.

The hilarious part is the obvious scum motivation.

[TheReverend]

Ok rob I'm ok with holding back to so PP can catch up.

UNVOTE: darthe

[Rob14]

He voted for D-Core and at the same time said that he wanted to lynch Zab tomorrow, keeping momentum on Zab alive. Why would scum ever do that? He's pushing to have two less partners by Day 3. That has some pretty intense town motivation and no scum motivation.

The hilarious part is the obvious scum motivation.

Which is?

[AngryPidgeon]

That you think hes town.

[Rob14]

That you think hes town.

It's still a stupid move to get two of your partners killed in the first two days when you don't know about vigs, SKs, and cops who could kill/investigate you. By your logic, I have an insane scum motivation to have pushed for the lynch of DC and CKD so hard.

[AngryPidgeon]

You can't clear someone because they "must have bussed too hard"

Gah, I remember seeing some quote from rofl in another game about how he dislikes playing scum and typically busses hard anyways. Can't find it, but w/e.