NY 159: RUST game over

[Cheery Dog]

Cheery is town and should feel town.

I don't think that meme works in that fashion.

I'm not seeing it being DGB, I although I may go have a browse around Josh's meta to see if he is always "needs catchup" lurk heavy to see if that can sway me. But I can't see DGB's posts actually coming from scum.

I'm still also unsure about Darthe. looking at his iso, I can only see 966 as being scum motivated with the correction of removing CKD from his acceptable vigging list.

and the "info lynch" hammer of Dcore still stands out as an antinomy, I'm still not sure what that means.

Just looked at the votecounts posted to see if they were lined up with my read and apparently there were no scum on the BC wagon.

BloodCovenent (8) -

drmyshotgun

, Darthe,

PeregrineV

, roflcopter,

Rob13

,

Tazaro

, Cheery Dog, TheReverend

[AngryPidgeon]

I really think its PH. Hes doing just barely enough to not be called for lurking. And he isn't really pushing any suspicions, just coasting nicely. And his D1 stance on Dcore is still unforgivable.

[Cheery Dog]

Josh meta got nowhere, his last completed game was 3 years ago. (although he was more active before being replaced in those I don't trust it) and I can't really get much out of his 6 posts in reverse mafia redux where he was scum.

I'm good with maybe switching to ProHawk, I can at least see him being scum from his ISO. (him being apparently roleblocked by scum doesn't mean much in way of clearing him)

[AngryPidgeon]

If people are going to try and argue that SCUM CKD cleared PH with his hypothetical tack then they will be laughed at by me. The fact that CKD was so eager to out his PH targeting results only makes me think it was a distancing ploy.

[DrippingGoofball]

If Cheery is scum, he bussed hard on CKD and to a lesser extent DC. After reading his ISO with the confirmed members of the scum-team, I do not believe he is scum. His night actions are questionable at best, but I saw very little in their interactions that points to anything but Cheery-town.

Was Cheery's choice of night action bad? Yes.
Was it anti-town? Probably.
Is he scum? No.

QUESTION.

Did he speak to the scumbags directly, or did he speak OF the scumbags only?

If he's engaging the scumbags directly and engaging them, then he's town.

If not - he's scum.

Why?

I've been scum often enough to know.

[DrippingGoofball]

Its literally PH/DGB. One of those 2. Malp and Darthe are distant possibilities. Cheery is town and should feel town.

Your reads are bad.

Tell you what.

Vote for Cheery today. Tomorrow, I'll vote for anyone YOU want me to.

If we lynch Cheery, there won't be any tomorrow.

[Darthe]

^ Don't like this post. Don't like it at all.

[DrippingGoofball]

How about, if Cheery isn't scum, lynch me tomorrow.

Do you like that better?

[DrippingGoofball]

^ Don't like this post. Don't like it at all.

Tell me what you don't like about this post. I'm extremely interested.

[Rob14]

There was nothing wrong with that post Darthe.

[Darthe]

Yes there was, and the subsequent reaction of changing what she said and then coming back and asking me why after. My read on DGB is moderately town ATM regardless but I didn't like the back scratcher post. (If you don't get that term, it is an individual who says "well hey if you do this for me and I'm right then but if I'm wrong ill give this to you so everything is still cool). Not scummy, I simply don't see it as good town play.

[DrippingGoofball]

And why don't you like the back scratching?

[4nxi3ty]

malpascp

(1) - Cheery Dog

Darthe

(2) - TheReverend, Rob13

Cheery Dog

(5)

- DrippingGoofball, ProHawk, malpascp, roflcopter, Paid Pyro

DrippingGoofball

(1) - AngryPidgeon

Not Voting

(1) - Darthe

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.
Deadline: (expired on 2012-11-14 12:43:07)

[Rob14]

The way DGB said that wasn't back-scratching, as you call it. It's "do what I want today and I'll do what you want tomorrow because if you do what I want, I'm 100% sure there won't BE a tomorrow." That's very, very different than what you described. It's a, in the view of DGB, non-meaningful concession in order to get people to vote Cheery. I think he comes off looking more town for his confidence, personally.

[AngryPidgeon]

Im not going to be able to convince you all of DGB/PH am I? We have < 2 days.

Intent to hammer by the end of today.

[Rob14]

I have no chance of getting a wall on Darthe up because I just was informed I have to work tomorrow and Wednesday, meaning today is homework day for basically the rest of the week. We're not going to get anywhere on that front this day (and AP is right, he's not going to succeed in pushing DGB/PH). No one else has raised any major concerns, with pretty much every active person stating Cheery is a good option. With that in mind, and acknowledging that it's unlikely that we'll make any more progress this day, here's the hammer on Cheery.

Vote: Cheery

If I'm not here tomorrow, look at Darthe. Hard. I've talked about him a lot in my ISO. There wasn't one big wall, I don't think, but if you use Ctrl+F to check for where I talked about Darthe, I've made my opinions clear. Also, just look at his ISO.

[AngryPidgeon]

So Cheery, you scum?

[DrippingGoofball]

If I'm not here tomorrow, look at Darthe. Hard.

WILL DO if game isn't over.

[roflcopter]

don't worry rob, i'm here to put darthe's neck in the noose if necessary (but fingers crossed that its game over)

[Darthe]

Lol, I love the intent to kill. And I suppose that DGB saying malp wasn't mafia was enough for all of you to tuck tail? Do me a favor, speed lynch me tomorrow and go full retard when you're left floundering almost at LyLo with no good choice.

[AngryPidgeon]

cough, cough, Darthe is being pretty obvtown right now, cough. Yall should feel bad about lynching Cheery.

[roflcopter]

Lol, I love the intent to kill. And I suppose that DGB saying malp wasn't mafia was enough for all of you to tuck tail? Do me a favor, speed lynch me tomorrow and go full retard when you're left floundering almost at LyLo with no good choice.

you act like there aren't enough lynches left to take care of malp too, something i've mentioned numerous times and made a point of including yours and his names in the shortlist of people who will be dead before any lylo situation, wah wah wah

[Darthe]

Lol, I love the intent to kill. And I suppose that DGB saying malp wasn't mafia was enough for all of you to tuck tail? Do me a favor, speed lynch me tomorrow and go full retard when you're left floundering almost at LyLo with no good choice.

you act like there aren't enough lynches left to take care of malp too, something i've mentioned numerous times and made a point of including yours and his names in the shortlist of people who will be dead before any lylo situation, wah wah wah

And here was the mafia reply.

[roflcopter]

ap, just be quiet. we get it. you have different opinions from everyone else who is remotely conftown. feel free to gloat in the endgame if you turn out right. you're not convincing anyone.

[roflcopter]

Lol, I love the intent to kill. And I suppose that DGB saying malp wasn't mafia was enough for all of you to tuck tail? Do me a favor, speed lynch me tomorrow and go full retard when you're left floundering almost at LyLo with no good choice.

you act like there aren't enough lynches left to take care of malp too, something i've mentioned numerous times and made a point of including yours and his names in the shortlist of people who will be dead before any lylo situation, wah wah wah

And here was the mafia reply.

come at me bro