Open 455 - Tit for Tat - OVER

[guille2015]

Oh, Wait, I'm actually the vig!

[MagnaofIllusion]

So while we wait for the post by the Mod -

Why did you shoot Cheery over Guile Shamrock? After reviewing wagons and intereations Guile was my choice as scum (and my investigation which our lazy Mod never sent a result me on).

[Shamrock]

Oh, I just picked Cheery arbitrarily, I didn't bother looking since we auto-won today no matter who I shot.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Fair enough.

[guille2015]

And of course, I'm just messing around. It was a good game. Can't talk more though, I'll give my impressions soon,

[Messiah]

Vote Count 4.2 - LYNCH

LYNCH

guille2015

- AngryPidgeon, MagnaofIllusion, Shamrock

MagnaofIllusion

-

Lord Mhork

-

AngryPidgeon

-

Shamrock

-

Not Voting: Lord Mhork, guille2015

guille2015

has been lynched Day 4. He was a

Mafia Backup Jailkeeper

.

A win condition has been met:

AngryPidgeon

,

Cheery Dog

,

MagnaofIllusion

,

greygnarl

,

Klick

,

Lord Mhork

,

Bitmap

,

Shamrock

and

the director

win with the Town!

[Messiah]

MoI, either I'm woefully inept and deleted your investigation PM for last night without reading it or I didn't get it somehow. Not sure what's going on there, but I will consider myself fortunate that it's of little consequence. I'll post more later, no time now.

[MagnaofIllusion]

MoI, either I'm woefully inept and deleted your investigation PM for last night without reading it or I didn't get it somehow. Not sure what's going on there, but I will consider myself fortunate that it's of little consequence. I'll post more later, no time now.

You aren't either. I went to look at my sent messages and it is not there either. Apparently I didn't actually send it but hit Preview and navigated away. In the end it was academic due to Disturbed being Mafia.

I am interested to read the Scum QT myself.

[Messiah]

Decided to send a PM about the game ending to everyone before I left, which reminded me: A big thanks to all the replacements, and an equally big thanks to the people that stuck the game out from the beginning. There was a lot of flaking going on in this game.

re: Scum QT - I won't force them to post it, I know some people have a strong desire to keep them secret for whatever reason. They're welcome to link it themselves though.

Here's the graveyard QT, very lively that one.

[guille2015]

Here is the mafia QT. http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/yx4FSp26pzG. I do not think there will be a problem. If they do have a problem, then I guess we can delete it.

Nekoko and Disturbed played a very good game. I feel bad that I failed them and I take full responsibility for this loss.

I made two fatal mistakes: The first was to send disturbed to make the kill rather than myself on night 2. I failed to take into account the implications that meant him getting blocked. When I saw that our kill on Cheery did not go through, I immediately knew that we would have lost if Disturbed got Lynched, which is the standard approach for when someone is jailed and a kill doesn't go through. So I had to come up with a plan to save the game. I figured I had to get Cheery Lynched. But then I paniced and Said I blocked Disturbed. 10 minutes later I realized my 2nd fatal mistake in which I should have said that I blocked Cheery instead. That would have gotten us a better chance of winning.

Regardless it was fun playing this game even if my heart almost flew out through my mouth when the Night 2 results came in.

MoI was the best player and our biggest threat. He figured out the best strategy to win this game even if I tried to convince him to kill Cheery.

Messiah, Thanks for running this game! I think I'll play this setup again, at some point. I also liked playing with this group of players especially MoI. I look forward to facing you again.

[AngryPidgeon]

I should have said that I blocked Cheery instead. That would have gotten us a better chance of winning.

Not sure that would have mattered. Mhork was getting a pass either way. The only thing that may have changed was more pressure on me over Disturbed.

But GG, that was definitely the fastest game I've replaced into.

MoI played very well.

[guille2015]

I should have said that I blocked Cheery instead. That would have gotten us a better chance of winning.

Not sure that would have mattered. Mhork was getting a pass either way. The only thing that may have changed was more pressure on me over Disturbed.

But GG, that was definitely the fastest game I've replaced into.

MoI played very well.

After the CC, three town who commented said they thought Cheery was scum, including MoI. I had the advantage at the time.

I was going to try and get pressure on you, but the votes on D1 came too fast, and Real Life is taking a tow on me this week.

[AngryPidgeon]

Hm. I still would never have supported lynching a JK over the VT pool. I think MoI was of similar mind.

[Cheery Dog]

You guys never gave me time to post in the dead thread

Good job anyway. If I hadn't blocked disturbed I don't know what would have happened. I originally planned to block him night 1 until the director came in and changed my mind.

[AngryPidgeon]

Cheery, if I ever have a gut scumread on you in the future, Im going to go ahead and assume you are town

[Disturbed_One]

guille:

I would not blame this loss entirely on you (though I do feel your claim of blocking me was rash). In fact, I believe you played a rather good game all things considered. The reason the town won is because the town played an excellent game. Plain and simple. So while your claim didn't help things, I do believe that had you played to the plan, we may have very well been caught anyway.

That said, thanks to all for a great game.

[Cheery Dog]

Cheery, if I ever have a gut scumread on you in the future, Im going to go ahead and assume you are town

You should always assume I'm town, I'm yet to have been scum, so if you assume I'm town, based on my past alignments, you get a 100% chance of being right

[Cheery Dog]

Based on the 13 games where I've flipped/game has ended anyway.

[AngryPidgeon]

That was the most meta town slip ever.

[Shamrock]

AngryPidgeon MVP

[AngryPidgeon]

True. I only ever voted scum all game.

Oops.

[Nekoko]

The first was to send disturbed to make the kill rather than myself on night 2.

Yeah I think disturbed shouldn't have sent the kill but regardless,
I think you did a great job and perhaps you just panicked.

The town is just awesome
lol I wished MoI never replaced in hahahaha

[Nekoko]

So how was my real first game as scum?
I think I got carried away in the first day with Disturbed_One.
If I'm town, I would definitely doubt that Disturbed was scummy.

[Om of the Nom]

lol I wished MoI never replaced in hahahaha

I agree with this.
MoI played well but I hated his attitude (not saying I had the best attitude either but still). That plus my partner doing basically nothing made this game really draining for me and the slot was basically being wasted.

[Lord Mhork]

Yay! We win! Huzzah!