If you understand that was for sarcastic effect, then that was why it was said.
You've played with Piggy. She says stuff like that just to say stuff like that.
Have you ever seen that crying .gif she sometimes posts? She *made* that if that helps you understand her personality any better.
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:I neither prefer or dislike meta.
It's suspect that I use meta.
I don't think you actually know what 'neither prefer or dislike' means. Because, hint, it doesn't mean 'refuse to use...or 'dislike'...in fact it means I don't dislike it...derp.
Bleh I should have worded that better.
What I meant is that you have no opinion on the use of meta either way, that is true, but you have also said you think meta is normally not applied correctly, and then you go and use meta.
I didn't like the fact that while you don't agree with others using meta due to their habit of misusing but then used your own analysis of meta. Again, when I was reading the iso I felt it reinforced the undermining undertones I was getting at.
From the town's resounding "not quite" I guess I was wrong. :\
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:Absolutely.
The ability to use it is so narrow and constrained as to be laughable. Meta is tough enough to work with actual knowledge, much less derp half-knowledge.
I guess this is a follow-up, do you think that you *know* Piggy's meta to make that previous comment?
Agree to disagree about the N thing considering divergent play has to have some explanation and so far no outside influence has been acknowledged.
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:Because either the conclusion was scumhunting, or was just mud slinging, and I wanted to know which. It's a pretty complicated and new edge scumhunting method.
I'm not "groking" this Thor but I think this is because we play vastly different games.
Are you saying that scum cannot scumhunt? My interpretation of Piggy's post was "You look like you are scumhunting by asking questions, but you don't care about their answers"
Does that clarify anything for you?
Mehdi said you had a really big problem with this point and all I can say is... deal with it.
No. I don't present my cases to be entirely for myself and I like to say things to see others' opinions on the matter. This was one of them. I felt your other questions were smarmy whereas this one was more blunt and to the point which is why I felt it was town. I'm sorry I can't quantify the reasons more to feelings but that's just what I feel. So...
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:I'm aware you're attacking me here.
I don't understand how or for what reason. It just looks like sturm and drang.
I'm saying "I [Oversoul] am not putting more into the word suggests. You [Thor] were the one who made a post about it."
Actually... yes. I finally tied you down to something definitive.
However... post 85... point still going whoosh way over my head.
All I see is a comment to Cerulean about them not reading that you already commented on Sixty's case.
Also, so sassy.
That should be your title. *shrug*
Two words.
F.
U.
Wait. Two letters.
And there is a reason why I find that scummy.
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:Or because I got a town read on them and announced as such.
I'm crazy like that.
Crazy? No.
Convenient? Yes.
Suspect? Yes.
It isn't something I'd expect from you as a player.
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:The thing is, that's like an elementary scumtell - so much so that scum avoid it like the plague.
Which is exactly why scum would do it, especially if you are a confident scum player and have plausibility on your side. The plausibility in this specific case? WIFOM that it is so scummy not even scum would do it.
Yes, reactions can be gained but aren't those also inherently helping scum? In my opinion yes as it allows scum to feel the waters of what will be accepted and what will not be accepted by the town in the future. It is essentially a litmus test of how far they can go with scummy actions.
so much rage.
How dare Oversoul express discontent with Thor!
Soooo stupid!
(although that last bit may be true, I haven't been tested)
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:Actually - that would be actively defending Sixty - I called out Cerulean for questioning the case and said I thought the case was good and also claimed the case was based off my thoughts.
Good ISO work.
I think by this point since you've made so many snide comments about my opinions it is clear that we definitely do not see eye to eye and that I have different expectations to you.
Active and passive are yet another difference in opinions. But either way you have still proven my point and you don't deny as such except to try and undermine my work with "Good ISO work."
Active Lurking - posting without any real content in order to keep activity physically up
Active Lurking (1) - posting questions that really do not contribute to discussion/scumhunting
Active Lurking (2) - posting good questions without any follow up
At this point I think I just walked into a trap and you are going to word lawyer me.
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:When I did my second section of catchup I started from Post 206.
Good ISO work.
I just want to see you say smurf at this point because honestly....
FUCKING FUCK THOR
Stop being so god damn degrading to me because I misunderstand your fucking cryptologic text that I need a mother fucking cipher to use.
Do you think slowly changing your read is bad then?
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:Except - it's quite valid.
Y'see, all this silly "case" It's not a case.
The case (thus far) is "Thor is dismissive of others, changes his reads in awkward ways, soft defended Sixty, and is active lurking through pointless questions."
That's the case.
This is 'examples' or, if you wish 'proof'.
Big difference.
If you boil everything down to this level of simplicity sure. Why not.
What would be in your opinion the pointless questions?
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:That's the closest thing I've seen to a scum case on me thus far.
I disagree with your definition of 'passively pushing'
and why wouldn't you?
You've disagreed with me on literally every other single fucking point. And you don't even deny the most important part of that point's validity.
At this point I think Thor's responses speak for themselves and for those of who read my original case you will see my point.
I'm not spoilering this.
In post 1205, Thor665 wrote:But...'meh, I disagree with you' is probably the core answer to everything except phrased in different witty and sarcastic ways.
Pretty fucking much...
Anyway, I'm on the precipice of very troublesome times and I am contemplating replacing out and having Mehdi fly this plane solo.
School has become a jumbled mess that I really only see myself getting hurt more from and to top it all of my family dog of over a decade has passed away and the last thing I fucking remember doing before leaving to go back to college is yelling at him for peeing on my rug.
So ya. That's where my life as it right now.
Also, side comments and shit.
Absta potentially replacing out for spoilerage problems would almost definitely mean he inadvertently discovered a scum member's identity because at that point it would break the game. Finding a town member's idenity would not be as detrimental but more likely and I don't know if he would make comments like that if he thought he found definitive town. So I do think there is potential easywin if we can look at his interactions but that is up to the ethics police whehter it is right to continue searching or not. So far, I haven't found anything.
Another thing, why did Jesse replace out? From what I saw, he just... flaked.
Is that normal for him? If it isn't I find it suspect because that is after he was pushed for his notes and then he refused saying the core of his gameplay would be ruined... when earlier he said he had been playing on alts.
Why would it matter if Jesse's play was ruined if this was one of his most recent games on that account in a long time? He can always deny being someone on an alt and get away with it. Replacing out unless it was a real life reason seemed suspect because of that weird inconsistency with the fear of others "knowing" his play when he primarily played on alts where no one would know him.
Still looking into Zach's insane world for more information
OS
