Mafiastuck (GAME OVER TOWN WINS!)

[Sanjay]

Also, a lot of the common reads suck.

[buldermar]

Maenara is confirmed??

Well, Mehdi-confirmed.

I must have missed something. Could you elaborate on it?

[BT]

Maenara is confirmed??

Well, Mehdi-confirmed.

I must have missed something. Could you elaborate on it?

He went out and admitted that his role confirmed Maenara to him in one way or another.

I don't know how one could

miss

it (and the two pages that followed....), but here.

[Titan]

Mehdi - without giving out more information about your role than you have to, is maenara mod confirmed innocent to you?

[Vifam]

Sanjay why exactly do you think Nacho is scum

[DeasVail]

Zdenek is probably my favourite lynch now then.

[Mehdi2277]

Well it's going along as I read so I'll end up reading the flips fully later anyway. And explain how pasche looks scummy for x is bad?

From where I'm at other read wise is town on titan, xtoph (primarily for 262), nika's slot, and deas. Saw some discussion on vifam but so far weak town read.

Mehdi - if you had role related reasons tht made maenara for sure town from night one, why didn't maenara shoe up in your reads list at the start of day two here? This post comes after deasvail voted maenara and AD said she could be black scum.

I could have, but the point would have been? I gave myself a reason to town read mae soon after that when I saw her posting, but I didn't want the town read to look like it was for role reasons before I decided to claim.

Tammy she's mod confirmed town to me.

[Maenara]

I find it a bit un-freaking-likely that Mehdi has both vigilante powers

and

way of having players modconfirmed to him without their knowledge.

[Maenara]

EBWODP:
Why did we assume there'd be two vigs, again?

[Mehdi2277]

Since I'm either scum using the night kill to only shoot suspected people, a SK who vig claimed for no good reason day 2, or I'm a vig. That and it's something awesome called being town read. Games are so much more fun that way.

[Mehdi2277]

And I'd like to know what these roles that discover someone is town while telling them are? Most investigation or other roles that can find out someone's town don't tell that person they're town (mason being the main exception).

[Bumi]

Read nacho.

Ask yourself if his reads seem like they seem organic or artificial.

You keep going after townie people like BT and Nacho. Is this because you don't want to committ to other more common reads?

How you think Nacho seems townie is beyond me.

(blinks)

You aren't looking at the motivation of his actions. Try reading them for their purpose.

Titan can be town.

I really think a townbloc should be formed while we still have numbers.

[Bumi]

Zdenek is probably my favourite lynch now then.

(scratches head)

Why is that?

[Mehdi2277]

Me + mae + bumi + dan + S&r + buld + titan + BT

Anyone you'd argue for/against town block wise?

[Mehdi2277]

I want vifam there too, but he's more split.

[DeasVail]

Zdenek:

254 is a pretty bad attack on Alsark from Pasch. So much so, that Pasch probably knew it was.

Zdenek's first few posts are pretty null. I guess I kind of get a gut scummy feel from his content dump and quote stripes.

1570- slightly scummy. The way it's worded (I guess the lack of confidence behind the statement) just seems strange because if he's town it doesn't really matter how accurate his statement is?

Calling Zeta obvscum seems exaggerated.

My scumread on Zdenek himself is pretty weak, although there's not much I find too townish about him. The main thing is Pasch's attack on Alsark which I think is the type of thing Pasch wouldn't dare to attempt unless on a scumbuddy.

[Bumi]

I want vifam there too, but he's more split.

Dan confused me a little but I can see it although he wouldn't be my first choice. I'd rather Vifam on there than Dan.

I'd probably like Avox on there as well.

Nacho too but he is split like Vifam.

I guess it is a good place to start.

Deas, I don't understand how you can go from weak scum read to preferring his lynch when he has not been here and others have made content?

[DeasVail]

I would be interested in being part of a townblock.

PEdit: All my other scumreads are weaker.

[Sanjay]

Nacho is basically avoiding my question because no one is making him.

Sanjay why exactly do you think Nacho is scum

I feel like I've answered this?

[Mehdi2277]

AV depends on his play for tomorrow, but thinking I'm leaning to let him in. For now I don't want (although having vote with us is always good) him in but a day later that could be changed. Forgot nacho and currently his play has been actually fairly strange. Not bad, just odd gut wise. Choices he's making while explainable still seem weird. Wouldn't want him in it.

UNVOTE: Sanjay VOTE: Brood If that block is formed let's see how well it works (that and sanjay's reaction isn't bad at all to getting that many votes).

[Sanjay]

I'd like to say more, but I'd like nacho to talk more about his pachendale read first. Also why he's avoiding that question for basically no reason. That is a new question.

[BT]

DeasVail I don't know about others but you're damn null to me.

If we're considering Titan we may as well consider Nacho even though I'm uncertain about both (Nacho in particular read better until it turned out his tunnelreads were wrong).

Everyone else is ok.

P-Edit: Okay, Nacho out, but I still don't know about Titan.

I'm personally not seeing the goodSanjay reaction but you're not the first to say that so I'll go with it. I think I still prefer Sanjay though.

UNVOTE: Sanjay
VOTE: Brood

If this is bad we're switching back.

[DeasVail]

DeasVail I don't know about others but you're damn null to me.

Uh what?

[Mehdi2277]

Specifically a. he didn't lurk, b. he's responding continually and staying with his line of thought, c. he's scum hunting not defending too much, d. he's not taking into account viability of a lynch at the moment with his scum hunting. D and B are the main ones.

[Sanjay]

Aw shucks.