Mafiastuck (GAME OVER TOWN WINS!)

[Zdenek]

Third party is a bad lynch.

Care to talk us through that, Zdenek?

What part of the word "or" don't you understand?

[Mehdi2277]

I think he meant how does brood fit 3rd party (response being that complex role fits a 3rd party role with strange win con more then a scum role).

And forgot, but VOTE: Brood.

[Vifam]

NOPE, YOU'RE LYNCHING FATE

[Mehdi2277]

Nah even if I accept you as both town (which is all I'm really left with) that still has fate as town. I don't see fate scum (for what pushing you, protecting AV a claimed watcher, for defending mae an easy mislynch?).

[Vifam]

idk what to do with you

[Phillammon]

UNVOTE: .

Sorry, have a habit of leaving votes on longer than intended. My bad.

Vifam: He looks fairly townie both from posts and from activity to me (I know that that reflects badly), and I don't honestly know why he was being lynched in the first place. Davesprite as a doctor makes sense from a flavour perspective, but there is one niggling doubt about the claim (flavourwise) that I'll try and follow up some time. In the mean time, from a mafia stance, uncc'd doctor is a no go for lynching.

Fate I hate with a fervent passion at the moment and I could DEFINITELY go for that as a lynch. The demeanour isn't helping, I'll admit, but the spamposting rather than content posting and AtAC (Appeal to AllCaps) as an argument form doesn't impress me in any way shape or form. The content feels off by gut as well, which combines into a scumread from where I'm standing. Brood hasn't made much of an impact on me either way as of yet, and I can't honestly remember what I thought of his ISO when I originally went over it. I'll go back and check now, if you like.

[Mehdi2277]

AtAC can't be a scum tell for him when it's basically his trademark too as both alignments. Spam I think he's made clear who he suspects so if it's spam it's good spam.

Checking brood would be good. He has the most votes I think and still works best lynch wise.

[Phillammon]

Fair enough. I'll freely admit that I don't know Fate's meta. While Fate's made suspects clear, the arguments have been less than stellar, hence my suspicion.

I'll do a check over brood. If I don't report back, I probably fell asleep.

[Maenara]

Aldusskel has felt ridiculously fake the entire game. One of his very first actions was a list of essentially nothing, to make him seem town, along with an opportunistic vote on, huh, me.

Seriously, go ahead and ISO him. Look at every reference he's made to cE/Sanjal. It is so obviously a scumpair.

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

VOTE: Fate

[DeasVail]

Someone tell me why Fate is scum.

[Mehdi2277]

Since he's annoying or too narrow when he's already said he mainly comments on things he disagrees with other people on.

Deas have you given a read on brood ever? If not now would be the time.

[Bumi]

Why Mehdi night 2?

[Vifam]

Claimed vig and seemed that he'd be more useful that Porf in the long run

[Vifam]

than*

[ActionDan]

Claimed vig and seemed that he'd be more useful that Porf in the long run

I bet you saved him tbh. It goes well with only one pro-scum kill that night

[Bumi]

(ponders)

I like Fate better than earlier in the day. This game is becoming a head ache.

Dan, 3 Kills last night? Who do you think Por killed?

[Mehdi2277]

Por likely shot xtoph. He had a scum read on him. I shot cheery. So one missing kill or overlapping kills.

[DeasVail]

Deas have you given a read on brood ever?

I'll ISO him quick now.

-1362- contrived reason for thinking tazaro scum.

-Um, the rest of his posts aren't really too enlightening to me, other than maybe a slight scummy feel. Nothing I see that is that townish. My read really depends on the claim, which I have no idea about. I think that the ring crumbs indicate that he probably has a role associated with a ring (whether scum or town I don't know). Someone needs to tell me how likely a role it is and whether it would be a town or scum role.

[Bumi]

Are you okay with protecting AV, Vifam?

[Mehdi2277]

So far his role would be the first truly complex one. And I think the info is pretty much made to allow false positives/negatives easily so it doesn't seem like as great a town role as it might sound. I'm treating it as null right now. And then play as scum so yeah i you have a scum feel he'd be a good place to vote.

[Vifam]

Are you okay with protecting AV, Vifam?

I don't see why not

[Mehdi2277]

Shoot wise I'm not really sure now. Philla/Sanjay/Dgb is the current lean for a pool of shots.

[Bumi]

What is a KP that Brood was talking about? Might want to lynch him for dave control... Although I could think of a convoluted reason to leave him alive.

[Bumi]

Dave control? That's what I get for using my new phone.

Dave = damage.

Funny given Vifam's name.