Simple Majiffy you are in the same pile as Thor both of you take a while to sort out.
But I did say earlier that I had you as leaning town and so far that has not changed much. I don't see you and Thor as both being scum, as Jacob threw out as a possibility, you two are being too chummy with each other for that. If you both were scum, you would not pay that much attention to each other or bus for town cred. Though with you two anything might happen. But that would be too cruel to town for that to happen, so I am going on the basis that one of you may be town one maybe scum or both of you are town.
In post 232, RachMarie wrote:Ok initial impressions from my skim read ISOs later after more coffee I slept most of the day away (not been feeling well).
JS I hope you are ready to play major catchup with only 8 days to go and you on V/LA for 3 of them. I really want to get a handle on your slot.
Melmond makes me twitchy. It is more like he pops on periodically just enough to keep from being considered lurking.
Orci is probably newbtown. The whole froofroo with Majiffy seems town v town. Townies often can be very stubborn and I think a newbscum would be working harder to blend in and not draw so much attention to him or herself.
FT has been on site long enough not to be a newbie anymore. I want to read this ISO because like melmond FT is making me twitch.
Voded and Majiffy will definitely take some time to digest, both are very good players and not the easiest to read. ATM though I am placing them in the likely town pile.
@ Majiffy it does not surprise me that you and Thor have a hydra dang that is a powerful combination. and LOL at your intro. I am just NS's gf ♥
Pretty much still on board on this atm.
Which is why my vote is where it is.
As you pointed out earlier, the slot does not change because of a replacement, so I am trying to determine if I was mistaken about your predecessor (I definitely can make mistakes), or if you pulled a scum slot this time.
In post 655, Majiffy wrote:Am I supposed to be faulted that you've not a lot of recent scum games completed?
No, but you are faulted for making an assumption about my scumplay with only one game.
Nevermind that the other most recently finished scumgame of mine (A Double-Day Unlimited Open, the one before the currently ongoing one) didn't have me defend my scumpartner at all (first one was lurky, so that goes neither way, but Gunny and I bussed each other pretty damn hard D2).
Given a clear 1:1 ratio between "defending my partner" and "bussing/distancing from my partner", your meta argument is flawed.
2011 scummies winner (BTS help) and participant;
coming back to Mafia...slowly. Keep an eye for me as a mod.
Also keep an eye for setup review requests.
meta arguments are fuckin terrible either way, people change the way they play game to game. THe degree of clutter in this game is annoying as hell. I'm still sticking with majiffy/mollie as scum unless Thor has a good argument on someone else - not Human Destroyer yet, he has some really towny posts, not gonna vote him as things are atm.
In post 657, Voidedmafia wrote:Nevermind that the other most recently finished scumgame of mine (A Double-Day Unlimited Open, the one before the currently ongoing one) didn't have me defend my scumpartner at all (first one was lurky, so that goes neither way, but Gunny and I bussed each other pretty damn hard D2).
Given a clear 1:1 ratio between "defending my partner" and "bussing/distancing from my partner", your meta argument is flawed.
1) Gunny wasn't playing strongly as scum.
2) I didn't say defending your partner universally, I said defending strong partners.
Your misrep is noted.
Only playing in games at personal moderator and/or 50%+ playerlist request.
In post 659, Majiffy wrote:1) Gunny wasn't playing strongly as scum.
2) I didn't say defending your partner universally, I said defending strong partners.
1.) He was playing as well as he could given his position and the game's position. I think he played as well as he could've.
2.) I don't think Gunny is bad as scum. And he can be pretty darn strong.
*shrug*
2011 scummies winner (BTS help) and participant;
coming back to Mafia...slowly. Keep an eye for me as a mod.
Also keep an eye for setup review requests.
In post 656, RachMarie wrote:As you pointed out earlier, the slot does not change because of a replacement, so I am trying to determine if I was mistaken about your predecessor (I definitely can make mistakes), or if you pulled a scum slot this time.
Walk me through what steps you're doing to accomplish this feat - I'm clearly not noticing the work.
In post 658, FourTrouble wrote:not Human Destroyer yet, he has some really towny posts, not gonna vote him as things are atm.
In post 661, Majiffy wrote:1) That's great, we don't give stickers for participating here.
2) Well he wasn't in that game.
1.) Just because you're in a bad position doesn't mean you can't be strong scum. Defending yourself well against attacks, providing (or doing your role well) towards helping your teammate(s) get towncred or survive just that little bit longer to win; both of these and other things contribute to being strong scum players. It's not just about being able to act town very well, and given the situation Gunny was in and what he and I had decided to do to win that game I think he played very well.
2.) Meh. Rach is good enough as scum, too, so I don't really see the point?
2011 scummies winner (BTS help) and participant;
coming back to Mafia...slowly. Keep an eye for me as a mod.
Also keep an eye for setup review requests.
In post 663, Voidedmafia wrote:Meh. Rach is good enough as scum, too, so I don't really see the point?
... That is the point. You defend your buddies when they're strong scum. Or, to state it more accurately, you ignore or bus your buddies if they don't look like they're going to make it or in general aren't good as scum.
Only playing in games at personal moderator and/or 50%+ playerlist request.
In post 665, Majiffy wrote:... That is the point. You defend your buddies when they're strong scum. Or, to state it more accurately, you ignore or bus your buddies if they don't look like they're going to make it or in general aren't good as scum.
It's still only one game, though...
2011 scummies winner (BTS help) and participant;
coming back to Mafia...slowly. Keep an eye for me as a mod.
Also keep an eye for setup review requests.
Well one thing that sticks out in my mind Thor is you are not all bent to get me lynched? Which since in every game you have wanted to do I find that odd. You even tried to get me lynched in a game where I was already dead lol. So what is different now?
Thor stop trying to convince me to sheep you, Mollie's the only case I'd even care to sheep, and even then I find her scumminess weak; I prefer my vote where it is.
Did we miss deadline or is it just me?
RachMarie wrote:Well one thing that sticks out in my mind Thor is you are not all bent to get me lynched? Which since in every game you have wanted to do I find that odd. You even tried to get me lynched in a game where I was already dead lol. So what is different now?
