Mini 1401 - Game over!

[SaintKerrigan]

Vote: Qwints

I was hoping to get more from him today since I came out of Day 1 with him as bipolar scum/town (half his posts felt scummy, half felt town (all figures approximate )), but he's done a lot of recent lurking. At this point it's more about I'm less willing to lynch the other potential candidates than him than actually finding him terrifically scummy, but what the hell.

L-1, I think.

[d3x]

A Lynch is preferable to No Lynch and my Town reads are on the Wagon. I'm probably not going to be around when the deadline hits, so I'm going to...
VOTE: qwints

[Kthxbye]

Yeah, that's a hammer d3x

[Kthxbye]

So Rofl, that was a quick turn around yeah? If you are scum, you played that terrifically, but alas, I explained what changed my mind. Hope Qwints flips scum....

[SaintKerrigan]

I don't see how what rofl did necessarily clears him, kthnx. Anyone can say anything.

[AngryPidgeon]

Vote Tally 2.9

qwints ( ):

roflcopter, Gorgon, Kthxbye, Malakittens, SaintKerrigan, d3x

roflcopter (L - 3):

Singer is Nachomamma, qwints, Nobody Special

d3x (L - 5):

Slandaar

Slandaar (L - 6):

Saint Kerrigan (L - 6):

Gorgon (L - 6):

KthxBye (L - 6):

Nobody Special (L - 6):

Singer is Nachomamma (L - 6):

Malakittens (L - 6):

((expired on 2013-01-13 23:59:59))

[AngryPidgeon]

The day opens and you all continue pointing fingers and accusing each other of guilt once more. Until finally, the sun almost set, someone shouts "Someone must die! And that person is qwints!"

So you lynched him. Qwints didn't even put up much fight.

Spoiler: Le Flip

qwints, Mafia Goon

met his timely demise, Day 2!

[AngryPidgeon]

Night 2! Ends at the end of Tuesday, Pacific Time

(expired on 2013-01-15 23:59:59)

[AngryPidgeon]

Tensions were high but the night was calm. A cool breeze blew through the village and a cloaked figure walked briskly back through the darkness. The cloak wlaked up to the makeshift cemetery and knelt on one of the graves, slipping a white rose out from underneath the cloak and laying it on the grave. *CRACK*

Blood spilled over the rose, and the figure clutched its heart. She was dead.

Spoiler: FLIP

Malakittens,

Town Mason

, slaughtered Night 2

[AngryPidgeon]

Vote Tally 3.1

d3x (L - 5):

Gorgon (L - 5):

KthxBye (L - 5):

Nobody Special (L - 5):

roflcopter (L - 5):

Saint Kerrigan (L - 5):

Singer is Nachomamma (L - 5):

Slandaar (L - 5):

With 8 alive, it is 5 to lynch or 4 to "No Lynch".
Also note that any kill flavor is just flavor and means nothing.

Pacifists (Not Voting):

Nobody Special, Saint Kerigan, roflcopter, KThxbye, d3x, Singer is Nachomamma, Gorgon, Slandaar

((expired on 2013-02-04 23:59:59))

[roflcopter]

i suspect we are dealing with a serial killer. 1xbulletproof goon, two kills night one, but only one kill (on the claimed mason) night two. the 1xbulletproof goon is not a role included to counter a 1-shot vig. mala probably got shot twice last night.

anyways,

vote: d3x

[d3x]

In case anyone was wondering, that wasn't an accidental Hammer. I thought I said as much in that post.

Any particular reason, rofl?

[roflcopter]

Any particular reason, rofl?

first and foremost, gut. the hammer felt like it could have been a forced bus, and under the assumption (see above) that we have an sk running around i think that its going to be found in the you/slandaar "we're not involved in any of the day's wagons" feud.

[d3x]

Is there much precedent for 4 antiTown roles in this size setup? I'm on my phone, so it's not that easy to check.

[Gorgon]

I have been going over the setups of old minis, and there are precedents for having a SK in a 13 player setup but it doesn't seem super-common. NS did say something about having reason to believe that we have an SK yesterday, and since he survived the night he may be ready to say something more about this and his role now.

~~~

Anyway, time for a bit of the ol' post-scumlynch analysis.

I've made my point. I buy that Dun's hammer may have been a forced move from scum rather than a free choice from town. The interaction between absta and conman is the smoking gun. Sucks that you replaced into a slot with that kind of history, but there it is.

This feels to me like rofl is not qwint's partner. A bit too apologetic for a bus. Especially considering how viciously qwints went after Conman.

I'm going to keep my vote where it is because I really don't like the fact that rofl pushes a mala wagon when he agreed with the that the mason shouldn't claim today.

SiN looks really bad for going from really clear posts yesterday to fence-sitting posts today. I think a SiN-rofl team is quite likely.

This comment on SiN feels like distancing to me, however. Why keep going after rofl with old and weak arguments about absta and Dun which were mostly parroted from others, and add to it a very lazy misrep of rofl's case against Mala, but call SiN 'really bad' as pretty much just an aside to that without voting him or making an actual case of it? The latter looks more like insurance than anything else. And it makes sense to me that qwints would refrain from having a town/town pair there.

~~~

Obviously WIFOM is heavily involved here but still ... this is how my gut is calling these posts.

[d3x]

SK+3man Scum Team?

[Singer is Nachomamma]

sk is not top priority today thanks to even numbers
but tomorrow
my top for SK is slandaar, hands down

scum is SK or gorgon, i guess

[roflcopter]

in the firsthand experience column, once upon a (very long ago) time i was an sk in a mini. i think it was even a 12 player mini, back before they expanded by one. other than that, yes sks can and do exist in mini normals. they are not common, but they are possible.

d3x's reaction seems pretty darn sk-ish

re: gorgon - of course i'm not qwints' partner. i agree that sin looks way worse today than i thought s/he did yesterday. it would also fit my expectation that one partner bussed (qwints) and one didn't on day one.

but thinking about it, we should be hunting the remaining mafioso today and not the sk anyway, since we know for sure the mafia exists and the sk is only a theory at this point

unvote, vote: sin

preview edit: even happier with this vote now

[roflcopter]

top town - saint kerrigan, nobody special

prob town / scum alternates - gorgon, kthx

sk lives here? - slandaar, d3x

scummy scumscum - singer is nachomamma

[SaintKerrigan]

I've played in at least one 3-scum, 1-SK setup back when the player cap on minis was 12. It's not that unusual an idea to me.

I still think both Slandaar and d3x are town. Those are the only reads I feel comfortable with right now, but given the accuracy of my reads this game, who knows.

SiN, why am I scum?

[roflcopter]

for reference, and some nostalgic horn-tooting, i give you

mini 592

, which ended in a serial killer win by yours truly. ah, the good old days!

[roflcopter]

I still think both Slandaar and d3x are town.

what makes you so sure one of these two isn't an sk?

[Kthxbye]

there is no sk in this game

[roflcopter]

there is no sk in this game

in that case sin is certainly the correct vote.

in your opinion is today the day for massclaim?

[Kthxbye]

Yup