Mini 1415: Fairly Oddparents Mafia Game Over

[Benmage]

MrZepher, why didn't you check the PM before claiming?

I did mine off memory.

Would scum be more likely to go off memory, or would they be more likely to double check themselves??

Cool, guess we have Zeph as conftown.

(imgoodatthis)

This is silly.

How do you know he didn't just screw up an attempt at a fakeclaim?

Can't be 100% sure, welcome to mafia. It's early but I have him as a strong town read nonetheless. And like I said, whose more likely to double check??

Moreover there was an old MD thread which said "slips" happen more often from town acting quickly and making mistakes. I think this is an example of that. Is it irreversible? Hell no. But I'm looking elsewhere for sure.

[-L-]

So now we have the following as town:

Me
Balrog
HD
Sanjay
PV
Vifam (probably)
-L-

[Sanjay]

Also, I got a sort of "testing the waters, do I dare to jump in?" vibe from this post.

[Benmage]

Why not? I just thought it'd be interesting

I don't watch the show all the time, but isn't some teacher always after the fairies? I can imagine scum gaining something from picking off specific characters.

I can't.

The intro seemed real basic.

Town has two wishes. Scum block wishes or kill. 10v3... Thats it. Nothing secret its practically an open setup.

I'd like a claim from you.

[Benmage]

Also, I got a sort of "testing the waters, do I dare to jump in?" vibe from this post.

I'm a little torn to be fair. But would scum really attempt to call out an obviously protown plan, and a protown player? Doubtful in my opinion. I think they'd be more like "oh shit oh shit oh shit" Than actually call Bal out.

[Vifam]

Klick, why is grine town?

[Sanjay]

That was in response to my plan, not Bal's if that changes your answer. The plan involving the mafia claiming and us magicking them over to the good guy team.

[adorkable]

Klick, why is grine town?

[Klick]

Klick, why is grine town?

Two reasons.

1.

No restart.

Things are fine the way they are.

I guess the best question to ask is

@NumQ- How much coordination are we allowed to have/use?

I never said you couldn't coordinate. It's the game breaking I don't like.

2.

Why not? I just thought it'd be interesting

I don't watch the show all the time, but isn't some teacher always after the fairies? I can imagine scum gaining something from picking off specific characters.

This quote, knowing that the Anti-Fairies are the scum, makes me feel that Peregrine isn't one of them.

[Human Destroyer]

1) wat

2) Except fake townslips exist. Therefore I find it null.

[Sanjay]

Either Peregrine is town or he is the hypothetical crafty scum that fakes great ignorance of the setup in order to towntell which I always think about but never run in to.

[Benmage]

That was in response to my plan, not Bal's if that changes your answer. The plan involving the mafia claiming and us magicking them over to the good guy team.

Ohhh I see. No, that strengthens the read more so.

[MrZepher]

I didn't double check my PM until Vifam was like "Well if Chad then Tad" and I realized that I had made a terrible mistake. I originally checked it to confirm last night.

@Klick: I don't feel like the first quote is town-telling in any way....

[Sanjay]

It is a LITTLE weird that Peregrine is both trying to break the setup and hasn't read the first post though.

[Vifam]

It is a LITTLE weird that Peregrine is both trying to break the setup and hasn't read the first post though.

Yeah that's what I was thinking.

Like, if he's really planning to win the game in the best situation possible, you'd think he know that there is no other scumteam.

[Benmage]

I agree with HD, nothing there proves town.

Pedit: Yeah his complain about not breaking the setup seem a little disingenuous. As does his in thread mod question.

[Sanjay]

That was in response to my plan, not Bal's if that changes your answer. The plan involving the mafia claiming and us magicking them over to the good guy team.

Ohhh I see. No, that strengthens the read more so.

The townread? How so?

[Benmage]

Vote PV

you wanna wagon, wagon here.

[Klick]

1) wat

2) Except fake townslips exist. Therefore I find it null.

1) The first quote is numberQ responding directly to PV regarding him coordinating.

2) But it doesn't look fake.

[MrZepher]

Maybe it doesn't look fake because it's just that good.

Things like that are too early to tell.

[Vifam]

This game is gonna rock

[kiwieagle]

Holy shit biscuits can people calm the fuck down
Its 8 pages of shit because everything was nullified due to the mod's post of no strategies.

Can't say I am

that

sad because now we can do weird shit with our muffins (Which is why I joined in the first place...) instead of making this game boring as hell with all of us just doing whats told...

For shit and giggles another strategy that could work is:
Night 1, wish for 12 guns.
Day 2, shoot everyone.
Town win.

Either Peregrine is town or he is the hypothetical crafty scum that fakes great ignorance of the setup in order to towntell which I always think about but never run in to.

Ignorance is a null tell to be honest.
I have done it as both mafia and town.

[kiwieagle]

^ ment to say no gamebreaking strategies.

and
VOTE: Vifam

Just because I got late to the party doesn't mean I cant have my own random vote!

[Sanjay]

You've read the eight pages enough to call them shit. You must have more than that.

[MrZepher]

You've read the eight pages enough to call them shit. You must have more than that.

I was just about to say this. DAMMIT SANJAY.