Mini 1415: Fairly Oddparents Mafia Game Over

[-L-]

I have no clue. This game is not playing like mafia - it feels more like everybody yelling nonsense and hopping on any old wagon. I am spending most of my time trying to figure out benmage's motivations for leading the town.

[Vifam]

Soooooo I'm assuming Timmy in this game?

Pretty weird if he wasn't

[Vifam]

In literally every game I'm in there is always one guy saying "This does not feel like mafia"

[Benmage]

I am spending most of my time trying to figure out benmage's motivations for leading the town.

I didnt think I had led too much yet, but why wouldn't I?

[MrZepher]

Explain to me how making a mistake is a scum tell (lol).

It's not

Because I thought his first post coming in was bad, add that up to "mistake" and the fact that no one else was really standing out as really scummy at the time aside from Grine, it seemed like a viable wagon.

So here are the okay lynches:

kiwieagle
L

Grine

Zeph

VOTE: Vifam

[Balrog]

I just asked Q and apparently wishes can change alignment. Mafia claim. We change them to town. BOOM.

Broke the game in three wishes.

I'm soooo impressed Balrog half-broke the game with 20.

Yeah, I asked that after you mentioned the Cult thing. Not impressed.

FoS:PeregrineV

I like the commitment you show here by not actually voting your scumspect.

Now this game is all serious mode and I really didn't like Balrog's posting.

Why not? I'm beautiful.

-

Hey PV, what game was it that you played on MTGS?

-

Don't Restart

I just didn't like how he wanted to control that game right off the bat and it seemed like anybody who disagreed with him was already scum in his book.
I don't see the point in playing the game if it's not going to be any fun. Defeats the point of this being a Mafia game.
It's not vote worthy imo, I was just pointing out that I didn't like his posting. Plus spamming us to page 5 before I could even start reading the game makes me less inclined to like you.
Sorry, not sorry.

diaf (not sure if I'm serious about that yet)

If there is Chad, Tad definitely has to be in this game, right?

dat modgaming

Woops. I'm Tad. I thought Tad was the black one, but I'm the white one and the white one is Tad.
I got the names confused. Sorry.
Visual memory and all that stuff...

UNVOTE: Vifam, VOTE: Vote MrZepher (guess I was serious)

You get an IMAGE of the kid you have in the PM, unless you are blind there is no way you could mistake black skin and white skin

I know that I was the one with white skin. I just thought he was Chad. He's Tad. That's my mistake.

Color me unconvinced.

Why not? I just thought it'd be interesting

I don't watch the show all the time, but isn't some teacher always after the fairies? I can imagine scum gaining something from picking off specific characters.

Teacher =/= Kid

You keep rubbing me the wrong way. Any particular reason why you're choosing to act like this?

Also, I got a sort of "testing the waters, do I dare to jump in?" vibe from this post.

I'm a little torn to be fair. But would scum really attempt to call out an obviously protown plan, and a protown player? Doubtful in my opinion. I think they'd be more like "oh shit oh shit oh shit" Than actually call Bal out.

I disagree, I think Zepher felt some anti-Balrog emotions in the pool and decided to stick his toe in the water.

Klick, why is grine town?

Two reasons.

1.

No restart.

Things are fine the way they are.

I guess the best question to ask is

@NumQ- How much coordination are we allowed to have/use?

I never said you couldn't coordinate. It's the game breaking I don't like.

2.

Why not? I just thought it'd be interesting

I don't watch the show all the time, but isn't some teacher always after the fairies? I can imagine scum gaining something from picking off specific characters.

This quote, knowing that the Anti-Fairies are the scum, makes me feel that Peregrine isn't one of them.

I think this is all null.

I agree with HD, nothing there proves town.

Pedit: Yeah his complain about not breaking the setup seem a little disingenuous. As does his in thread mod question.

Yep. Tryhard for town credit, much, eh? (Not you, him.)

Also I get the gut feeling that Kiwi's vote on Vifam is more than just an RVS.....

Based on? Substantiate. Gut reads can always be explained.

So here are the okay lynches:
kiwieagle
L
Grine
Zeph

Holy shit, you made a post I agree with.

Okay.

Thanks for the content, plan to contribute any time soon?

[Sanjay]

Benmage, what scummy things were you referencing here?

[Sanjay]

I think I'm going to

Unvote

Zepher for now. I'm not really as excited about it.

[Seanald]

Sup, Im the actual Chad, so that clears up nothing? although Im believing that zephyr simply made a mistake, Tad does sound more black.

Benmage you killed me last game we were in but I still want to sheep you does that make me gay?

also going on a hunch Vifam is tots town.

and -L- is not, VOTE: -L-

im voting L off the basis that he is posting no content due to fear of saying the wrong thing but still trying to look active something plausible considering all the strategy talk.

[Balrog]

And all the little townies lay snuggled in their beds
While visions of Balrog danced in their heads.

[MrZepher]

Chase me down on a frivolous argument at best and watch it go nowhere.
I made a mistake. Shit happens. I already know there's scum on my wagon; there's absolutely no way there isn't.

My point in posting, while yes I was being really cautious, was to point out that I was uncomfortable with the first 5 pages of what is basically now garbage.
And my only reason in caution is being uncomfortable with the speed at which 5 pages had been reached. I felt like I was missing something.

Anyway, I've had my opening-game spamfest fun. I have to be up for work in 3 hours, so I'm gonna sleep. I'll check up on you kids later. Before I go:

VOTE: Vifam, as I sense absolutely nothing he posts will be of any value for the remainder of the game if he's town and he's pretty much declared himself scum twice as it is anyway.

This after saying she's/he's already confirmed himself as scum twice (which was a misrepresentation anyways).
Your point here is completely subjective and entirely misleading.
You're first half of your ISO is total garbage at this point so what am I supposed to make of you?

I would suggest that anybody on my wagon that is town and wants this day to go somewhere to get the fuck off my wagon. You're all way to heavy.

[Vifam]

I don't understand the context in your post before that, what are you trying to say when yo voted me?

[adorkable]

aw hell, I'm bad at this

Mod: Please delete that post

Mod note: Post deleted.

Man, I didn't think anything of the whole tad/chad debacle, but ew ew ew ew that last Zepher post...

Zepher, is Vifam the only scum on your wagon? Who do you think are scum off your wagon? Is there anyone on your wagon you'd give a 'misguided town' pass to?

[captaineddie]

1. Holy shit, you guys posted 10 pages while I was asleep/not on the computer?

2. I'll post by the end of the day. Sorry about the delay. =(

[captaineddie]

That was the easiest 10 pages to go through.

1. Why are we breaking the game, we came here to make wishes! =D Maybe those who want to "break" the game are anti-fairies because they'd want to lose asap? No muffins for them = no entertainment value in this game = auto concede. There were so many breaking strategies in this game, I can list at least 2 right now. Lets just play this as is and think of the muffins as more of a "bonus" to our roles.

2. I'm Tootie! LOVE ME TIMMEH! Muah!

3.

Woops. I'm Tad. I thought Tad was the black one, but I'm the white one and the white one is Tad.
I got the names confused. Sorry.
Visual memory and all that stuff...

Lynch go.

Uh, yah.

VOTE: MrZepher

4.

I'm sorry, Benmage. I didn't think I was being obstinate.

I suppose I can't simultaneously criticize Balrog for being coy about his roleclaim and do it myself. I thought it was clear that I was nameclaiming 'Sanjay' but I guess not.

The flavor, unfortunately, is different than the one I hinted at in my last (first?) post.

Forgive me for having a tough time thinking you actually pulled Sanjay, randomly for a character and didn't enter the thread all HUZZZAAAHHH like.

Uh, If I were the mod of this "fun" game, I would so totally let sanjay BE sanjay. Think of all the entertainment value! =D

5. I think everybody right now just wants to go into night and use our muffins. Am I right?

[Balrog]

@Zepher: That's why it's RVS. It's garbage. Can you explain to me what you hoped to gain by criticizing the first half of my posts in the part of the game that's reserved for silly debacles?

@captaineddie: RE: #5: No.

[adorkable]

Just as a note, I think Zepher is at L-2 right now, L-1 if for some reason the mod counts kiwi's unbolded vote (which he shouldn't, I don't think...)

I think it's too soon for day to end. This game is also likely going to be swingy and I'd rather get more info in the day phase than try to rely on the Lucid Dreamer-ish setup to win the game for us.

Balrog: Do you still think Vifam is scum? (Is he bussing his buddy?)

[Benmage]

Uh, If I were the mod of this "fun" game, I would so totally let sanjay BE sanjay. Think of all the entertainment value! =D

Pretty sure mods aren't suppose to "pick" who gets what.

[Sanjay]

I should clarify what I meant by "testing the waters" with regards to that Zepher post. I was floating the idea that MafiaZepher was intrigued by my

genius

breaking strategy but knew well enough not to just go "Sounds good, Sanjay! The mafia are me, X and Y, our QT is here." That he wanted to see what his buddies thought about it.

I don't know how convinced I am by that interpretation, but that's what I meant.

I definitely definitely definitely DO NOT want to end the day right now. I am greatly looking forward to wishing the heck out of some frivolous wishes, but we can do that after we get this tedious "playing to our win condition" out of the way. And I don't think ending the day right now is pro-town.

For what it's worth, numberQ assured me my role was random in my role PM. I

suppose

he might have rigged it, but he didn't and doubt he did.

Benmage, I was wondering about that question I asked you.

[Sanjay]

Edit by way of post. Second last line should read:

"For what it's worth, numberQ assured me my role was random in my role PM. I suppose he might have rigged it, but

I hope

he didn't and doubt he did."

[Benmage]

@Sanjay I haven't gone back to reread the first 4 pages... but since I have a list, whats the difference? I'm sure if I get the free time, I'll review the intro, but doing iso's, that early sentiment might be out dated by now.

[Sanjay]

Vote: Benmage

The difference is that you haven't been playing like someone who saw stuff that was scummy early. Like at all.

What's to review? I'm just asking you what you meant.

[captaineddie]

Whoa, apparently I'm the only one who was super excited to go into night with our magical magical muffins... fair enough, scum-hunting is also fun...

@Ben, what do you mean by list?

[Sanjay]

This is where I'm at:
Town:
Human Destroyer
Balrog
Benmage
Klick
MrZephyr
Sanjay
Vifam

Slight town:
kiwieagle

Neutral:
adorkable

N/A
Seanald
captaineddie

Slight Scum:
-L-

Scum:
PeregrineV

[captaineddie]

Thats what I thought so, isn't that list however somewhat outdated?