In post 1323, Tajun wrote:Hmm, thought that I wrote more than that. Still, his reactions are dick-town and not dick-scum. Basically, he calls out people for bad behaviour and is frustrated when the town is screwing up. Yeah, still gut, but I'm not lynching a gut town read.
You've clearly never seen me as scum
Thanks for tackling it though.
In post 1323, Tajun wrote:I must be a Smurfing moron then, because all I can see here is that in either case you get the exact same info, ie. not likely a wolf if you buy that premise (which I don't really).
Well, yeah, maybe you are a moron, but let's look at this;
You're saying the order doesn't matter and the only question is whether it suggests he is or isn't Werewolf.
But, why does it *ever* possibly call into question that he's a werewolf. The answer is because the lynch was a werewolf and theoretically the other werewolf would have attempted to avoid lynching their bud and pushed for a counter wagon.
But, right there, we see that order matters - because unless the wolf was pushed first there is no need for other wolf to push a counter.
So, if it does matter - than order of when the wagons appear matters.
Make sense?
Go play more newbies...
In post 1323, Tajun wrote:The way you phrased it seems like you are saying "we wouldn't have two primary wagons on wolves at the end of day one, because a wolf wouldn't start a wagon on another wolf, therefore sky is not likely a wolf". This is a brutally bad interpretation of what happened, as a) Aldus did not start that wagon, join that wagon, or have anything to do with that wagon other than give a townread on sky, and b) Sky only jumped to Aldus when it was clear that he was getting lynched with or without his help.
A) This is not relevant to my point.
B) This is also not relevant to my point.
You've also kind of misrepresented my point, but I am saying that, of the available suspects, Sky is less likely a wolf than others.
I also think he looks town for other reasons besides that which makes him less likely mafia and thus a poor lynch.
Also, as you mock this, I would note I'm using more and better logic than your case so...maybe I should just say gut and scream 'nyah!' at you or something? Get over your bad self and at least try to address the points in a sensible way if you're going to attack them - also, are you seriously arguing Sky=werewolf here? You appear to be trying to do so.
Because I'd rather lynch scum than town, and don't really think it's a bad idea to leave a werewolf alive to generate night kills. So I'm lynching top scumspects regardless of my belief of the wolf/maf scale - also, you using 'but I may not be a wolf!' as a immediate defense tends to make me think of you as more scummy than less.
In post 1325, Whiskers wrote:Actually, I'm not sure how accurate this is. ProHawk and Aldus had varying levels of support all Day 1-- where would you put HD, for example? He was almost a lynch, is he primary counter to Prohawk? Or vice-versa??
HD was a counter to Ald, and actually looking at it and Uct's move it suggests he's either likely town or mafia - I should probably read into that shift more, but I think I'm actually taking him off the table for me today.
Also, seriously, you call my concept into question but can't even mangle together an opinion of your own?
You need death now.
Bullet point it pl0x. One sentence or two is fine and even preferred.
In post 1326, 4nxi3ty wrote:with how Sky, Thor, and Whiskers are all comfortable with an HD lynch definitely not feeling it; even with HD's recent decision to not post in this thread.
Wanna vote Whiskers then?
