Wow, like, nothing is getting done. Anyway, time to contribute.
In post 154, Kid A wrote:KX all your votes so far are prods, please say your top scumpick and why you think they are scum, even if you dont want to vote yet
Wtf was the point of saying this? And unless I missed it, I think the vote on me are srs votes. Maybe PimHel's isn't, but even so.
@PimHel/Zach, why the big deal over me keeping a prod vote? It's not like there's a wagon against you or something, so unless you can provide some other problem. Either way, since you insist,
UNVOTE: .
So far, reads are as follows:
Town
Hyperion - I've got to be honest, at least from what I've seen, they seem to be the only smart person in this game. Most of their posts actually have meaning and are semi-helpful or hold a good point, so I'd say Town. Only thing I hold against them is voting me, more later.
PimHel - Mixed feelings, something seems off, but I can't say exactly what. Otherwise, they've made quite a few good points/observations, and so I'd say Town.
Thenewearth - As previously stated, I think I'm going to have to say Village Idiot, so barely town.
Kid A - They seem ok, however, they really haven't done much of relevance but defend themselves. They did that ok though, and I already mentioned #154, so I guess I'll go Neutral for now, I need to see more. However, if their contibution to things outside themselves remains horrible, Scum.
Hamlet - The interaction between heads is horrid, and I so no reason why if town they should keep who's posting a secret. In addition, what they've said separately is very minimal and pretty bad, so Leans Scum. Only redeeming thing I can see is the interesting RVS play, which led to something unique to start the game off with.
Zachattack - It seems like they've done very little, and his #87/89 about possible PR implication was strange to say the least, so Leans Scum
Temphdq - One Post. Nuff Said.
CityElectric - The lack of posting doesn't stand out too well, and their two most recent posts are extremely bad. This game really isn't that long so far, and it seems like it would be extremely easy to take a precursory glance at it and say a few words. A second post on them not being able to post is what really tips it. Leans Scum.
scum
Ironically the two people I read as most town are the ones voting me. But hey, that's just how life goes I guess.
Seeing as how I have four scum reads, a neutral-scumish, and a VI read, I think this pretty much sums up the game to me. I'm seeing very little happen or get done, and feelings that I'm not able to get good reads on the majority of this game. I can't tell if it's simply because most of the players are bad, lack of anything to base healthy discussion around, low activity, etc, whatever, but the point remains something needs to change, or I don't see this game going very far.
Anyway, @Hyperion, if I get this correctly, the reason for your vote is that I'm posting but without content? Even if some of my posts don't have content, though this is something I'd like to object to, since some of them do, how does that make me worse then the part of the game who have posts but no content, or worse, those who are without posts entirely? Since otherwise you seem pretty smart, having difficulty getting how that fits together. Only thing I can think of is somehow my posts seem to you as though they're being made to fake content, but if so, clarification on exactly which posts and how. If you hold to what's described in #83, then I've got some serious questions.
