Micro 148: 50/50 Mafia (OVER)

[thenewearth]

gut feeling

[mothrax]

Page 9. There's much more substance going on than that. What are your opinions on KX?

[PimHel]

@Kid A
The vote on Hamlet doesn't mean that there is no fence-sitting. It's all about your reason: 'I think [this], but I could see [that]'
If you're scum, it gives you an easy escape if the wagon gets scrutinised.
Could you give more information on your meta argument against Hamlet?

@KX
1. CE has posted, whereas Alex never did. It's more likely for CE to see a vote, than Alex.
2. Based on Post 179, for what purpose did you vote Alex?
3. It's rather easy to ask questions when a players hasn't given much reads. Like:

Hamlet

- Who do you think is the scummiest player?
- What's your impression on the player I'm voting (In my case, KX)
(-What's going on between the heads?)

@Mothrax
Yay~
I'm looking into Kid A and Hamlet now to see if my initial reads of them are correct (Town).
But after that, we should discuss some things. Because theNE looks better than KX to me.

[thenewearth]

What are your opinions on KX?

His ISO looked pretty townish to me.
Though I just skimmed it.

Will look into it later.

And guys... Why KX, btw?

[mothrax]

Because I like asking questions.

Who do you think is scum? And most importantly: why?
(We know hamlet for gut, but the only read you have can't be that one...

[zachattack]

So TNE thinks I'm right about Hamlet. But he doesn't like my reasoning. But he doesn't have a reason of his own.

Hmmm.

[mothrax]

Zach, thatS why you should be voting TNE with me. C'mon, let's be friends! :3

[mothrax]

Also, would love that Votecount...

[zachattack]

I'm going to have to do a scum meta on TNE I guess. Lame. He feels like village idiot.

[D3f3nd3r]

VC 1.2 (4/2/2013)

Zachattack (L-5)
Hyperion (L-5)
Thenewearth (L-4) Mothrax
Kid A (L-5)
Hamlet (L-2) Zachattack, Thenewearth, Kid A
Mothrax (L-4) Hyperion
CityElectric (L-5)
PimHel (L-5)
KX (L-3) Hyperion, PimHel
Not Voting (2) Hamlet, CityElectric

With 9 alive it's 5 to lynch.

Deadline is the night of 4/7/2013.

[D3f3nd3r]

Prodding CityElectric.

[mothrax]

5 days until deadline and with the amount of activity in this game it could get ugly. We really really need to step it up guys.

TNE needs to answer my questions...

CE needs to get back in here.

Zach: why was them signing their hydra posts so important to you. If they signed their posts would you still find them scummy.

Hamlet: Who do you think is scum. There are two of you so read read read.

Hyperion: Reads? You aren't voting, why?

[thenewearth]

So TNE thinks I'm right about Hamlet. But he doesn't like my reasoning. But he doesn't have a reason of his own.

Hmmm.

Gut feeling is also a reason >.>

TNE needs to answer my questions...

Will do... Right after real life stuff

[Kid A]

we've got 9 pages of evidence you must have a better scum case on someone other than your gut feeling

[thenewearth]

I'll have limited access for an unknown number of days.

Will try to go on everyday if possible.

And I will answer the questions. Just too busy this time

[CityElectric]

Yeah, don't even have gut reads... Also sorry for being not as active as I should.

[mothrax]

Ok. Deadline is 4 days away and I'm not happy at all with the way things are progressing. I've seen more active games of mafia in {insert random semi derogatory comment here}.
When I'm the most active it's kind of sad, all things considered. Those of you still voting hamlet, you better have a damn good reason.
IMO TNE is today's lynch and I would be more than happy to use the anon vote on lurker CE.

[D3f3nd3r]

Prodding Hyperion.

[Hyperion]

I am voting MOthrax, still voting KX, I want his head on a platter today

Fixed? -D3f

[mothrax]

Oh, duh...

Mod: there seems to be an error in the Votecount.

Hype: Would you be willing to switch votes elsewhere to avoid a no lynch?

Not the one above?

[Hyperion]

Oh crap I didnt realise lynch was that close. I would prefer KE, but would compromise on either Zachattack, maybe an inactive like City. Will figure that out tomorrow since I have a 2 hour gap between classes to reread.

[Hamlet]

Consulting with my other head. We will have our reads up ASAP(as soon as he reads the what I sent him).

[Hamlet]

So, about Kid A.

I don't like 81 where he's attacking thenewearth for tryharding. That's not antitown, it's what we're supposed to be doing.

I'm also not liking 170; Voting someone (the fact that it's me disnae fash me) and then offering to remove the vote given x, y, or z behaviour is what is known as bargaining. As town, I don't want to manipulate people. Follow-the-leader-type behaviour is inimical to town, since that way the scum only has to outsmart the leader. If everyone acts independently, the scum have to outsmart everyone. I will not be ordered about.

VOTE: Kid A

As for KX, we will not be voting KX today. Both heads are in accord on this.

[Kid A]

"if it becomes obvious that the rocky start was just down to them being new to hydra"

im not telling you to play differently, im saying if it becomes obvious to me that you werent being scummy and were just having difficulty with doing a hydra i will unvote

reaching is a scumtell because scum have to make cases against town players and are not being genuine, town shouldnt be reaching when there are plenty of proper reasons to vote people

[Hamlet]

I don't care

what

you're telling me to do, I don't take orders from you.