In post 2295, Remembrance wrote:Seriously Mollie, your level of patience, and your unwillingness to follow what others say is absolutely (awesome) difficult and complicates the game some. You could have sat on the read and waited until Night 2 group was out like it was suggested, but I get why you didn't do that.
More importantly, what do you think of Nacho? Given that Nacho pointed to Bacde initially? And since you already announced Fate was scum, can you tell me why you investigated him? Given your town read on Bacde?
As much as it pains me to say, I agree with Remembrance. The correct play is to sit on your scum investigation, let the day play out a little, and then release your results. Lots of lost information.
With that said, the things to do today in the correct order would have been:
1) the claimed N1 power roles release their results, or at least what power type they were (Cop, Doctor)
2) based on this distribution, the N2 cop dying, and now the N3 doctor, what is the best plan going forward (if all 3 had claimed doctor, and wisdom being a 4th doctor....would that change how we do things???)
3) then follow said plan
On average, you will have 2 power roles a night. With rach dying, that reduces the average to one for N2. If we have everybody claim, and one person claims a N2 power role, what do you think happens to them???
Based on the flips and Nacho/Mollies roles, my suggestion would have been for no one to claim. And if we did claim, to go with Nacho's original plan where just N2 cops claim. With 2 people already claiming no power role N2, and another person soft claiming towards having one, maybe we should finish, I don't know.
As for this game, I believe Fate is scum and will vote when discussion is done. My early notes say that Bacde and SE Asians were not on the same team, hence why I had a town read on that slot as SE Asians I believed strongly was scum. Needless to say, I no longer have confidence in that read.
Bork's replace out feels weird, and his L-1 vote from D1 still stands out as opportunistic.
HD reads mirrored my own D1 (SE Asians/remembrance), except I was also in his reads. Knowing my alignment and now guessing SE Asians is town, I'll say the last scum read is probably in HD/Remembrance. (basically, if remembrance flips town, then HD was likely tunneling hard on 3 townies while defending fate's slot)
Buldermar, Mollie, Kuror, Nacho all have felt town. SE Asians for the Fate scum investigation is also likely town. Mantis I would need to reread, but I remember thinking she was town.
