Mini 1450: Hillbilly Hunt Mafia (Game Over)

[Thor665]

Mara vote out of nowhere huh, Thor?

So it appears.
React to it?

[ThAdmiral]

You're wrong again Thor. Either off your game or scum. Tbh I'd be ok with you as a backup lynch to cooldog.

[Thor665]

I'm highly intimidated and my case is crushed.

[T S O]

@Dry-fit: I believe scum is one of {Cool, Ree} and I'm trying to see who I would prefer. Mara isn't quite scummy enough for lynch -yet-.

[CooLDoG]

@Dry-fit: I believe scum is one of {Cool, Ree} and I'm trying to see who I would prefer. Mara isn't quite scummy enough for lynch -yet-.

what do you think of the relationship between mara and ree?

[Thor665]

@Dry-fit: I believe scum is one of {Cool, Ree} and I'm trying to see who I would prefer. Mara isn't quite scummy enough for lynch -yet-.

How are you doing this?
Because I know it's not by asking questions or interacting with anyone.
So...you've been re-reading the game over and over during the past few days or something?

[CooLDoG]

I've posted.

Instead of trying to get prods, how about contributing? You're doing your best to look busy without actually doing anything.

this post is pretty ironic.

[T S O]

You see Thor, I actually read the game. Don't try to explain my actions for me.
Mara-Ree is odd but Mara believes he is hard town and isn't faking it IMO. Whether he is...

[CooLDoG]

Mara-Ree is odd but Mara believes he is hard town and isn't faking it IMO. Whether he is...

what exactly?

[Bacde]

Hey I'm still down to lynch Ree why not imo

[PeregrineV]

Vote Count 1-11

(as of Post 309)

Mr_Ree (4)

- MrObvious, Bacde, CooLDoG, nopointinactingup

CooLDoG (3)

- ThAdmiral, Mr_Ree, MaraPim

nopointinactingup (1)

- Jebus

Bacde (1)

- Dry-fit

MaraPim (1)

- Thor665

T S O (1)

- havingfitz

Not Voting (2)

- timewarp, T S O

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

Deadline:

Tuesday, June 4, 2013 at 3pm Central Time

Replacing:

timewarp

Prods:

Jebus
MaraPim
MrObvious
nopointinactingup

V/LAs:

Mr_ReeMay 25-May 28

[PeregrineV]

Aj The Epic replaces timewarp

[Aj The Epic]

Hello, I have a doctors appointment to track to and I'm only on the third page, but I'll be catching up throughout the day.

[nopointinactingup]

I have no idea why the Ree wagon is stalling up

[CooLDoG]

I have no idea why the Ree wagon is stalling up

same. Thor seems to take a really weird position. It seems hard to want to lynch mara and not ree. The two are so connected they are literally the same person it seems like.

[Dry-fit]

Mara vote out of nowhere huh, Thor?

So it appears.
React to it?

I don't like it. Mara was able to answer all my concerns with her, and I haven't seen anyone else provide good reasons to think she's scum.

[Aj The Epic]

So this whole thread has basically been about Cooldog vs Ree/MaraPM hydra. (Also, at some point in time, didn't mara call Ree scum?) And Cooldog lost.

So, shall we start? The first comment that really got me from Cooldog was the little "MaraPim chainsaw much" thing. Let me explain. If mara has a townread on Ree, it's a town read, not scum buddying. And Cooldog already stank of scum. (By the way, Nopoint, no one cares if you CAUGHT dog. Anyone's style can change. He got bussed by majiffy a couple of games ago where he was bussed out for logical fallacy and his play was very town and fit your town description.)

So why is this comment bad? Because he's technically tying both of their hands together. Fating two in one. Quite unfairly, I must add, and with little logic. The chainsawing really didn't exist, Cooldog just was scummy as shit and he took heat for it. But he postured two people together and he still is currently treating them as a package scum deal. They aren't. Really, the Nopoint comment about knowing Cooldog's scum meta felt more like a protection attempt than anything I've seen out of Mara and Ree. So,

VOTE: Cooldog

By the way:

Nopoint, Cooldog, and Dryfit can all be scum.
Havingfitz is leaning scum. Asking for prods and contributing nothing IS scummy and T S O is right to attack him for it.
T S O is null. Not a whole lot to go on. Ree is also null, but simply because I feel that he's all over the place, which is different from Slenderman. Also, meta. I also somehow completely managed to miss any of Thadmiral's points, so he's null.
MalaPrim is leaning town.
Thor is town. Obvious is town, but needs to do something other than state the obvious. This is typical Jebus play, he's town. General lurker day 1, comes under pressure, lots of V/La. Bacade is probably town, although I'm generally biased on him because I like reading his posts.

[ThAdmiral]

^^
I like this guy

[Bacde]

I'm not opposed to Aj being town or CooLDoG being scum

[MrObvious]

I'm not opposed to Aj being town or CooLDoG being scum

CoolDog is town.

[Aj The Epic]

I know you don't do well with opinions, but try explaining that one, MrO

[Jebus]

I'm not opposed to Aj being town or CooLDoG being scum

CoolDog is town.

Uh. How would you know?

[MrObvious]

Well AJ, frankly Cooldog has backed up everything he has said so far with clear quoted evidence. People may not get a warm fuzzy feeling from Cooldog's delivery and they can say he's wrong until they are blue in the face, but it doesn't make the truth of what he is saying false. I'll give you one example, though plenty more exist.

I'll start with Cooldog

ree's last post is really awkward. He seems like he is trying to gain town points by saying that he hasn't checked his role pm and thus can't be operating off of scum motivation. Hmmm... I like my vote now.

I take this to mean you didn't like your vote before. The analysis is faulty as was pointed out. I didn't say I didn't read my role PM and it was a far jump to assume that.

This is a blatent Misrep

which is why I answered it by explaining why it was a misrep.

Of course you can trust me, I'm the town gynecologist....or was it psychologist... day vig maybe? I should really check my role PM again...

It is impossible for me to misrepresent something that you actually said. Here you were trying to gain town credit by say that you had to check your role pm. This is a fact.

Cooldog wasn't in the game that Ree self meta'd with. I don't think Cooldog had knowledge before this game that Ree spews the same bs in every game. Cooldog, paraphrasing and using the stance of "seems like", was reacting to what had actually been said by Ree. Ree then twisted what Cooldog had said and labelled it a misrep. Ree then also commenced to start a nit picky semantics battle with Cooldog. Whether Cooldog's "hasn't checked" means the same as Ree's "didn't read" doesn't matter, it is indisputable that Ree made a post suggesting that Ree was not completely clear about what his own role PM said. There is only one place fault can land for making such a post and that's not on Cooldog.

-----

Because he's technically tying both of their hands together. Fating two in one. Quite unfairly, I must add, and with little logic. The chainsawing really didn't exist, Cooldog just was scummy as shit and he took heat for it. But he postured two people together and he still is currently treating them as a package scum deal.

You couldn't be more wrong. In post 85, I turned the pressure up on Ree by putting him at L-1. 15 real life minutes later, Mira jumps off the Ree wagon in post 86, not for anything that Ree has said or done, but because Pim doesn't like me and she didn't like my post. However, she didn't bother to point out what she didn't like about my post. She just wanted the heat off of Ree. That right there ties them together without any help from Cooldog. If either flips scum, my vote is immediately on the other.

As far the chainsawing not existing, not only did the chainsaw exist, Cooldog quoted it when called on it.

have a chance at loosing a strong town player with Ree gone so...

~Mara

bullshit. You are defended ree for no reason. It is 8 pages into the game and you already have an obv town read who also happens to be a

very

strong player. Something is wrong.

-----

Cooldog has been right on in his responses with every piece of turd that Ree/Marapim has thrown at him.

So this whole thread has basically been about Cooldog vs Ree/MaraPM hydra. (Also, at some point in time, didn't mara call Ree scum?) And Cooldog lost.

I really think you need to read the thread again and reevaluate who you think the winner of this battle has been. On my scorecard, Cooldog has been the victor and the score is not even close.

[havingfitz]

Back from v/LA...catching up today.

[nopointinactingup]

The chainsawing really didn't exist, Cooldog just was scummy as shit and he took heat for it. But he postured two people together and

he still is currently

treating them as a package scum deal

.

+

Nopoint, Cooldog, and Dryfit can all be scum.

Holy **** This is GEM

~~~
So basically this guy came in, called everyone who favors Cooldog scum and everyone who does not town. Does not explain why Cooldog has bad arguments. Does not find a convincing argument so he picks on my inconsequential comments as his main argument and best of all managed to contradict himself in his very first post. A scum entrance can't possibly be more ostentatious