Mini 1454 - GAME OVER

[notscience]

Guys, I'm not sure. That hammer looks accidental, and it seems you all are reaching a bit hard on it.

However, why the sudden taking your vote off of NS, when you said you'd be on him until he was lynched?

[Amrun]

Unfortunately, fuzzy's ISO isn't very conclusive about who he might have protected on night 1. I know some people he didn't protect (bubba, Juan), but that says very little except "these people are not conftown," which is duh...

Some posts from day 2 indicate it may have been me, which makes sense, but tells me jack shit since I know I'm town.

The players most likely to kill fuzzy are notscience and Juan (if scum), but that ALSO says very little. I myself had thought he might be a power role because of the way he played day 1. (actually, I thought he might be a cop and had copped me, leading to his strong town read of me opening day 2.) So if I picked it up without trying, scum could easily have picked it up since they definitely are trying.

Bummer.

p-edit:

You're joking, right?

Scum DID kill. We had a doctor protect night 1, which was obviously successful. Scum kill flavor is obviously "exploded," which leaves the "kill" flavor for the Serial Killer (AJ).

[Kthxbye]

Bubba, why is your amrun read out the window exactly?

[GuyInFreezer]

Scum could've targeted the same target. Or a doc save.

Pushing kthx for "quick hammer" is terrible cos its clearly an accidental hammer.

That said,

VOTE: notscience

P-edit
Ninjas D:

[notscience]

Actually Amrun, I disagree. If he switched his read on you, and he was a doctor when there was just one kill, wouldn't that mean you were town? I'm not 100% sure on that, but that seems like what he's going at.

[notscience]

Shocker, GIF is voting for me again.

GIF, care to vote any actual scum? Or are you just going to sit there on me this whole game without pursuing other people

[Amrun]

Well, I mean, it could also have been something else, like a roleblocker or whatever, but since we have a doctor that we know of, it's easier to work from that.

And my vote for ktb has nothing to do with his hammer, btw. When it happened, I thought it might be faked, BUT -- it's unlikely as either alignment. It was most likely genuine. Accidents happen; doesn't mean he's not scum.

p-edit:

It COULD have been a double target, but hopefully we'd have seen two kill flavors in that case.

Remind me why you're voting for notscience, guy? I know you've done it before, but outline your reasons, please.

p-edit 2: Yes, that would mean I was town, IF he knew he had successfully protected me, which seems unlikely. But I mean, I AM town, so go right ahead thinking that...

[Amrun]

Notscience, why no vote? What are your reads?

[GuyInFreezer]

His terrible d1 play and he hasn't done any better.

I have an another suspect and now that my Internet is stable I wanna have a little chat with him.

[GuyInFreezer]

His terrible d1 play and he hasn't done any better.

I have an another suspect and now that my Internet is stable I wanna have a little chat with him.

[Amrun]

Bubba, why is your amrun read out the window exactly?

This post does not contain an answer to my previous question. Your next one should, as well as answer to these: what's your read on me? Why is bubba scum?

[notscience]

I want to hear KTB's answer to my questions, because that'll decide my vote. I'm thinking there's scum between Bubba, KTB, and GIF. Bubba for just how he's been acting, KTB for that hypocrisy and going back on what he was saying (even though it killed the SK, it was weird) and GIF because he hasn't moved his vote from me since D1.

[Amrun]

His terrible d1 play and he hasn't done any better.

I have an another suspect and now that my Internet is stable I wanna have a little chat with him.

Why does "terrible play" indicate scum?

[Rob14]

I believe I did not adequately make this clear. All flavor in the game is just that - flavor. It contains no hints, whatsoever. It just amuses me to write it (and hopefully amuses you to read it).

[Amrun]

I believe I did not adequately make this clear. All flavor in the game is just that - flavor. It contains no hints, whatsoever. It just amuses me to write it (and hopefully amuses you to read it).

The standard notation on this site is that kill flavors -- like actual announcements about who is dead and who is not -- are official, ie different factions sometimes but not always have different "flavors" (ie exploded, killed). This being a normal game, I assumed it was standard notation. Are you saying that the kill flavors don't indicate which party killed whom?

[notscience]

I'm assuming that's what he's saying.

[Kthxbye]

I will most certainly answer questions....patience please.

[Amrun]

Well, I'd rather not assume.

But since the SK is dead, it doesn't matter that much anyway.

p-edit: nevar. scum stalling!

[GuyInFreezer]

His terrible d1 play and he hasn't done any better.

I have an another suspect and now that my Internet is stable I wanna have a little chat with him.

Why does "terrible play" indicate scum?

Because of the tone. I use that a lot when I read newbs.

[notscience]

What tone? You keep giving vague reasons in an attempt to justify yourself.

[GuyInFreezer]

If I could describe it, I would've done it already. I firmly stand by my read because my reads on newbs using this were almost always right.

[Nobody Special]

Almost only counts in horseshoes and handgrenades.

[notscience]

I notice were and almost in there. Leaving a way to get out when you're wrong?

So essentially, you're voting me for a reason that you cannot describe. Good to know. Grade-A scumhunting.

[GuyInFreezer]

I used "almost" because I got it wrong on my first attempt.
Rest of the games I read them correctly.

[GuyInFreezer]

Also your passive-as-fuck play doesn't help your case either.