#10 - prohawk's list gets a reaction
#11 - BRO's response is interesting, if BRO flips scum I'm going to be interested in those on the list.
#12 - same again with TIP
#13 - calcifer's suspicion seems town motivated
#19 - scummy, speculation on scum numbers seems fake - BRO is scum read
#23 - I'm happy zdenek is probably town if BRO is scum
#29 - liking calcifer more
#32 - too blatant to be chainsaw vote, I don't think nero is scum if BRO is
#35 - not liking TIP though if BRO is scum
#38 - yeah zdenek is town
#42 - BRO is scum
#44 - interesting post from stevie... why is forming a town read on page 2 a scumtell? This stinks to me of distancing from BRO and TIP.
#46 - yeah calcifer is on exactly the same page as me here, this guy is town
#53 - huh? calcifer is now saying BRO, TIP and stevie all town? I'm confused, these three were all named as scum in post #46, a position I agree with at this stage
#57 oh of course, hydra differences... I suppose I won't complain about that, seeing as we'll probably have our disagreements
#70 - ripping Bender jokes... made me laugh though... TIP posting a little more townlike though
#73 - BRO seems like he's deliberately trying to link himself with TIP here... not sure how this reflects on TIP, but I'm pretty sure BRO is scum whatever TIP's role
Up to beginning of page 4...
I'm really tired and need sleep, will resume my catch up later.
So far... BRO is probably scum, weaker scumreads on stevie and TIP... calcifer and zdenek both town.
In post 198, Nero wrote:good work comrades, pile the votes on stevie. if required, i will hardclaim my role to get him lynched.
Just re-posting this quote to remind you all of what a scum Nero is. I think BROseidon is probably the best, most agreed-upon lynch target today. Will ISO him for my next post. I'm not going to move my vote off of him, but I will definitely hammer him.
I'll post much more often from here. djd did say before we agreed to hydra that he was going to be busy, hence me being the primary head, but I'm free now and have no plans to disappear again, so this game will be my priority now. I haven't yet spoke to djd since the start, so for now it's just going to be my reads and ideas. I'm not sure he's fully up to date either, he hasn't left any notes in our QT telling me what he thinks, it's just stuff like "where are you" lol.
Reading up from p4 now. I'll post more notes today. I'll avoid putting a vote down until a) I've read every post, and b) I'm in agreement with djd.
In post 198, Nero wrote:good work comrades, pile the votes on stevie. if required, i will hardclaim my role to get him lynched.
Just re-posting this quote to remind you all of what a scum Nero is. I think BROseidon is probably the best, most agreed-upon lynch target today. Will ISO him for my next post. I'm not going to move my vote off of him, but I will definitely hammer him.
RIGHT. This is starting to get ridiculous. Just so you can't be prodded, you're not asking questions, you're not interacting, you're not scumhunting or participating. You're making useless posts about hydras which have probably already been answered. Start. Doing. Something. With. A. Fucking. Purpose.
Ok so djd has emerged and said he'll be able to read up "tomorrow", though I think he means today (sunday) because he's 7 hours behind me and it was early morning for me when he posted that.
notes -
Spoiler:
#84 - stevie explains why he considers a towntell on page 2 to be scummy... I disagree... while I agree strong reads are very difficult to form by page 2, it's entirely possible to have scum and town reads by now. I think BRO is scum, but not because he has town reads on page 2.
Starting #86, there's an exchange between TIP and kingcrabd. TIP suggests doc is scum, kingcrabd rises to his defence. This could be interesting if doc is scum.
#91 and #93 has me thinking TIP is town. This suspicion feels sincere.
#99 - kingcrabd discreditting TIP
#101 - TMT talking up a TIP lynch.
#108 - further discreditting of TIP, this time by ankamius, emphasising bad town. Finishes with a BRO vote
#130 - I don't like this post... PL sucks, so does complaining about people posting.
#132 - hmmm this doesn't feel like both doc and kingcrab are scum, possibly doc is scum and is trying to link himself with kingcrabd
#135 - this is awful... if ankamius thinks TIP is town, then why does TIP need rope?
#136 - doc is sketch
#139 - kingcrab starting to feel more town
#150 / #152 - playing dumb with hydras? How hard is it to look at OP? MS is someone I have played with and he always seems scummy. But this is lazy fluff posting.
#161 - quiet guy commenting on post #10, which is prohawk's list...
#162 - stubbs thinks doc's post is awesome
#176 - I like this post from prohawk, and I like his RVS list idea, it caused a reaction which could give us clues later.
#177 - mac feels like town here, he raises good points and appears to be scumhunting
#182 - towniest thing I've seen so far from BRO
#191 - is good post
#192 - town thought process
#198 - talk of hardclaim to get a lynch? What the fuck is this? Nero stinks here.
#211 - ok so djd does have some ideas, can't say I hate this vote of ours.
#225 - bravo for townreading us after we made 2 posts in 9 pages... I'm impressed...
#262 - this sums up my feelings on BRO and has me leaning town with ank... doesn't feel like he's bussing BRO.
#264 - lazy chainsaw, rift could be scum with BRO
#274 - weirdest claim I ever saw, will come back to this
#276 - lol @ not self destructing on n2
#280 - ok rift is town
Here's where I'm at, I would like djd to read through and talk through with me where agrees or doesn't, and hopefully we'll be able to refine our reads further into stronger ones...
reads -
Spoiler:
Ankamius - possibly scum, but a BRO scumflip would look better for him, although he could be bussing ofc. Didn't like him piling on the TIP VI wagon.
Baby Spice - not much to go on, but feels town
Brian Hollywood - who? Let me ISO... oh, one post... obviously null as fuck
BROseidon - number one scum read, only once did I get a town feel from BRO, the rest of his posts stink
Calcifer (mastin2 & Nachomamma8) - got an early town feel from this slot and saw no reason to be worried
Doc Holliday - reads scummy, there's a few posts of his I didn't like
dramonic - who? ISO time again... oh yeah I recognise the avatar now... could be scum trying to float by day 1.
KingCrabd (Hydra of Cabd & TheKP) - I didn't like his attack on TIP, but otherwise he looks ok, so mostly null. Will revisit in the event of doc scumflip.
Mac - I get a town feel from him, but nothing strong, though his low activity is a little alarming
Metal Sonic - usual scummy self
Nero - his laid back style seems town, but I didn't like his hardclaim comment, so I'm a little concerned
orcinus_theoriginal - probably town because I saw him as scum recently and he was ridiculously active
ProHawk - leaning town
Rift Adrift (Syryana and fferyllt) - that weird claim... I'll look more at this hydra
Shadi1337 - null
StevieT92 - slight scum lean
StubbsKVM - loosely linked to doc for #162
T S O - null
The Goat - null
TheIrishPope - At first I though scum, but started to get a town feel from this guy, and feel like he might have been identified by scum as a ML target. I don't agree he's VI, if he's town he's doing an excellent job of stirring things up.
TMTOLBTWNTOF - mostly null, there was something he posted I didn't like all that much though
truly14 - replace request seems town but it's a lame reason for town cred, I'll wait for replacement before moving out of the null group
Zdenek - leaning town
scum/null pool - ankamius, brian hollywood, BRO, doc, dramonic, kingcrabd, MS, nero, rift adrift, shadi, stevie, stubbs, TSO, the goat, TMT, truly14
town pool - baby spice, calcifer, mac, orc, prohawk, TIP, zdenek
baby spice and mac townreads are thin to say the least, need more to go on really.
I hate large games on day one. Far too many in the scum pool. Get towning, people.
I'm finding a few potential links though. Doc doesn't look good, and if doc flips scum and TIP town, then I feel there's a good chance of scum between ankamius and stubbs, perhaps even both. Also a doc scumflip is interesting for kincgrabd, though this is thin and one could argue a doc scumflip looks good for king too, based on doc's buddying. Certainly I'll be looking again at king, stubbs and ankamius if we get a scumflip on doc.
A BRO scumflip looks bad for rift based on #264.
At this stage I like a doc or BRO lynch most, but I'm yet to exchange thoughts with djd, so until then...
In post 198, Nero wrote:good work comrades, pile the votes on stevie. if required, i will hardclaim my role to get him lynched.
Nero feels good except for this post. I don't like the hardclaim hint. Maybe just WIFOM for the lulz, I'm guilty as hell of this as town in the past, but still it pinged. But otherwise, yeah nero seems good.
Do you have any scumreads MS? I don't see a vote from you yet, which I find alarming.
