Mini 1452 - Inevitable Mafia (Game Over)

[RadiantCowbells]

Because "information that I can't give at this point in time" is positively role related.

[gorckat]

And I'm not assuming Cooldog-GF.

Godfather was thrown by someone else way earlier and your 890 happened.

It is totes possible for you to be scum faking JOAT and clearing CD for the cred.

Tangent- You've used 'save' in several places where 'game' makes more sense. Phone posting?

[gorckat]

And CD-GF, RC-scum makes no sense because the Bro-hammer wasn't made, in spite of CD being online in that window.

[RadiantCowbells]

It is totes possible for you to be scum faking JOAT and clearing CD for the cred.

Yeah, it's possible.

Why don't you make a case for it besides "RC wasn't clear about why he thought CD was town11!" instead of waffling harder than the golden griddle up the street?

I mean I know guys have a fear of commitment, but someday you gotta put the ring on it man.

[gorckat]

Why don't you make a case for it besides "RC wasn't clear about why he thought CD was town11!" instead of waffling harder than the golden griddle up the street?

I love your use of waffling. More people need to use the word.

It doesn't apply to me, however (at least the way I use it), because I'm not voting/unvoting or flailing multiple directions, calling you scum, then town, then scum, etc...

I am drilling in one specific direction and that is:

Your claim, subsequent results on CD, further statements under questioning today and overall refusal to clarify what you seem to be able to clarify but refuse to do so 'because it might suggest scum strategy' are suspect.

My ISO should have several posts with the relevant quotes (rather than doing so again) that show the trail of mixed message. Adding you should show a general refusal to address all the salient points, cherry picking what you would answer.

IF the rest of the town thinks there is nothing there, then I'll let it go for now.

IF the rest of the town wants more out of you, by way of what info you won't share, then give it or get hung.

I'll put a rope ring on it when I'm ready to. (Anyone know our deadline?)

[RadiantCowbells]

IF the rest of the town thinks there is nothing there, then I'll let it go for now.

IF the rest of the town wants more out of you, by way of what info you won't share, then give it or get hung.

See, that's the kind of thinking that makes you obvious scum.

-MY ALIGNMENT- does not change whether or not the town thinks that I need to post more information.

If you think I'm scum, then you should start getting other people to think so too. If you don't think I'm scum, then you should start making me believe that you're not scum.

What other people think doesn't come in to play at all, because if I'm town, you need my vote off you to lynch scum, and if I'm scum, you'll need me lynched.

I say you're waffling not because you're strictly waffling, but because you're indecisive as fuck and don't do shit besides follow the crowd. Besides D1, you have not made a single independent though this entire game.
Even this push to test whether or not me and CD are actually scum is just a copy of Roflcopter.

That is why I say you are scum.

You say I "might" be scum because I'm withholding information for a reason that I have clearly stated, because you're gauging to see how receptive the town is to the idea of lynching me.
Just fucking die.

[gorckat]

The horse is dead- you refuse to answer the questions or in any way resolve the variances regarding your secret knowledge and results on CD.

A) The town thinks I'm an idiot for pursuing it and lynching you is not an option, regardless of what I think
B) The town thinks there is something there
-B1) You resolve it to satisfaction and we move assured that you cleared CD legit
-B2) You fail to assure us of your authenticity and we move to lynch

[RadiantCowbells]

If you can't get me lynched and I'm scum you might as well try because otherwise you're going to LOSE.
Town would understand that.

[RadiantCowbells]

regarding your secret knowledge and results on CD.

on D1 a Godfather would NOT have claimed VT under threat of lynch. That is just idiotic; they would have claimed a lesser power role, particularly after there was a known invest and asked to have been checked after the mason died.

CoolDog didnt do anything to bait the investigate and is thus almost certainly not a Godfather.

optimal GF play by far would have been to kill one of the masons N1, let me shoot rob, then ask to be investigated the next night to get a cleared scum.

CoolDog scum doesnt make sense at all; end story.

[BROseidon]

rofl needs to get his ass in here so I can talk to him >:C

[gorckat]

regarding your secret knowledge and results on CD.

on D1 a Godfather would NOT have claimed VT under threat of lynch. That is just idiotic; they would have claimed a lesser power role, particularly after there was a known invest and asked to have been checked after the mason died.

CoolDog didnt do anything to bait the investigate and is thus almost certainly not a Godfather.

optimal GF play by far would have been to kill one of the masons N1, let me shoot rob, then ask to be investigated the next night to get a cleared scum.

CoolDog scum doesnt make sense at all; end story.

Seriously? That is the info withheld for this:

985: Actually there's a reason but if I explain it mafia will do something tonight that will drop our chances to win significantly.

[RadiantCowbells]

Correct.

Mafia kills me, CoolDog is clear tomorrow. They were almost certainly going to given that they already shot at me.

Mafia kills CoolDog, I'm not clear tomorrow.

[RadiantCowbells]

It's worth outing that to make sure you get lynched, though.

[gorckat]

And prior to posting that, you felt that was a giant secret they hadn't already set out upon?

PE: Fucking LOL.

[RadiantCowbells]

You obviously didn't know that.

[RadiantCowbells]

Also, if I'm scum, why the fuck do you care about what I have to say?

[gorckat]

Because I'm still deciding if you're scum (deliberately evasive over the posts I quoted) or a village idiot.

[gorckat]

And I also don't subscribe to the whole 'you're scum I'm not speaking with you' school.

That is a shitty attitude because until flips, you can always be wrong.

It is an anti-town stance to take.

[roflcopter]

talk to me, i'm here. well sort of, my shitty at&t internet keeps dropping every other minute. but i'm intermittently here.

unvote, vote: admiral

admiral > rc > gorc > bro > cooldog

[BROseidon]

At work, so I'll also be sporadic.

I'm glad to see you are thinking along the same lines I am, although I'm also sort of tempted to push for a no-lynch today to see if the night kill clarifies anything.

[BROseidon]

rofl what do you think of a no-lynch?

[roflcopter]

i thought about it, but i'm not for it. cooldog will die and we'll be exactly where we are now.

[roflcopter]

except minus the safeguard against two-person quickhammers that being at mylo and not lylo provides

[BROseidon]

You're still confident that CD isn't scum? Why?

That's the part that I'm tripping up on. I'm a lot less confident now that he's town than I was before.

[RadiantCowbells]

There is no way in hell that I am lynching ThAd today.