Mini 1476: Dewey Decimal Mafia (Game Over)

[Amrun]

*without showing your work

[notscience]

I'm telling you he's town. I see the same TIP I see when he's town.

[Amrun]

That's not how things actually work.

[notscience]

Then how do they work?

[gorckat]

Newbie 1384: TIP = Goon

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

[gorckat]

URL broke before hitting ISO, but w/e.

[Amrun]

Then how do they work?

You don't go, "I've only played with TiP as town, but my meta read says he's town so we can't lynch him, gais!"

I don't trust your alignment or your judgment, and you should KNOW that.

If you think his play is consistent with TiP town and NOT with TiP scum, then show your work. Even then, those sorts of arguments are very unlikely to sway people.

[Kid A]

(notscience has hydrad with theirishpope i think you can probably trust his read somewhat)

[TheIrishPope]

Kid A, I would like a read list.

[Amrun]

(notscience has hydrad with theirishpope i think you can probably trust his read somewhat)

Kid A:

-notscience is welcome to share observations in a specific sort of way.
-notscience has never seen TiP's scumgame.
-using his meta read for his own read is one thing; trying to shove it on others without showing work is another.

[Kid A]

Kid A, I would like a read list.

reads lists are bad and i hate them so you dont get one

[Amrun]

don't do a reads list, but do top three scum reads, go.

[gorckat]

Kid A, I would like a read list.

reads lists are bad and i hate them so you dont get one

Partial credit.

don't do a reads list, but do top three scum reads, go.

Boom. 100%

[Kid A]

I will do this right after Darox says what he thinks of the wagon on him because he answer will probably change the list anyway

[notscience]

Amrun, I never fucking said I haven't played with him, I just said they weren't completed yet.

[Amrun]

He literally already answered before you ever asked the question.

p-edit: I DON'T CARE. STOP TALKING ABOUT IT. FOR ALL INTENTS AND PURPOSES YOU HAVE NOT PLAYED WITH HIM AS SCUM.

[notscience]

HEY LOOK I CAN TALK IN ALL CAPS TOO RIGHTEOUS TOWNIE FURY GO

[Kid A]

yeah but i want to know if he thinks its town driven or scum driven or town driven with some scum on it or scum driven with some scum on it or whatever

[notscience]

Are you reading the game Kid?

[gorckat]

This is like a Thanksgiving dinner where grandma thought it would be nice to let the kids eat at the big people table and grandpa had like 4 beers before sitting down to carve the turkey with the new electric knife and everyone got shredded turkey instead of slices.

[notscience]

._.

What

[Kid A]

Half the player list needs to start MAKING SOME NOISE though, it's kinda depressing. It's also the reason I don't care for my wagon, because 3/4s of it have said nothing at all.

this is all he has said about the wagon and it is not really an opinion its a nonpinion

[gorckat]

@not: I'm being a fuddy duddy about the whipper snappers.

[gorckat]

@kid- it is also a perfectly reasonable position.

[Amrun]

HEY LOOK I CAN TALK IN ALL CAPS TOO RIGHTEOUS TOWNIE FURY GO

You are basically breaking site rules -- at least in spirit. And it's really distressing, and I'd like you to please stop. In fact, if you continue in this direction, I will report it even though I like you.