Open 510: DUCK DUCK GOOSE- SCUM WIN!!

[Treble]

notmara is town imo so I'm gonna sheep HARD

[Treble]

SORRY MARA I STOLE YOUR SPOT. D:

[Ms Marangal]

the bump is supposd to be mine to

:/

Pedit: stop dammit!

no duckie pics for anyone

Vote Count 3.02

Voting:

TheIrishPope (3)

: NotMara, Generic, Mutleyddmc

(L-2)

Not voting

: TheIrishPope, ,Treble, Sound of Silence, Siverure DtTrikyp, TaskMaster

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch[/area][/align] [/size]

Deadline is 8/10/2013 11:24 GMT (That's (expired on 2013-08-10 11:24:00))

Rob 1/2 of the NotMara Hydra is V/LA 7/28-8/1[/color]

[Treble]

SOMEONE PUT HIM AT L-1 BECAUSE I HAVEN'T GOTTEN TO HAMMER ANYTHING YET.

[Treble]

<3

[Mutleyddmc]

Worst at getting the mod top post ever. Should have asked me again

[Generic]

Why am I scum too mutley?

Carry over from the last game I assume. I pushed hana into exposing her scumminess. You have done what in this game exactly besides threaten to quit mafia?

[Mutleyddmc]

Cos Sak flipped scum. Very likely that Sak scum cross busses. The whole get generic when I flip town. Is so Sak and scum buddy

[Treble]

what the hell head 1 what kind of jackshit spamposting was that


Mara, I don't know if its because you included me in your case or not which makes me prejudiced

but from an observer's point of view I don't like your case




#2

[Treble]

Not really trying to be a defensive prick here but looking at this logical inconsistency in your "case" makes me go

TiP is also fishy but he's innocent until proven guilty.

What the hell does that mean? Please explain. From my point of view,

this posting comes from scum

with TiP or

potentially town

with a silly reason to post this.

"This posting comes from scum or town"

I don't know how to say this better.... OBVIOUSLY IT HAS TO COME FROM EITHER SCUM OR TOWN? OR ELSE WHAT... SERIAL KILLER??

Question to all: Can TiP + Hana be scum together or are they mutually exclusive? I'd personally think that they can possibly be both scum.

However I find Hana scummier as of this moment.

This posting, on the other hand,

either comes from scum

IF either TiP or Hana is town

OR town.

We know Hana is scum, so this would have to be scum with a town TiP or just town.

"This posting... either comes from scum, OR town."


I don't wish to use this small part here to make a logical fallacy regarding his whole case... nor will I call his "whole case" "shit", but considering this snippet of extreme fail logic in his "case" just diminishes his credibility by /a lot/ in my eyes.


#2

[Treble]

>if it doesnt come from either scum or town, where does it come from?

I'm not going to comment anything much about the case on TiP, but I'd like to advise all members of the town to take NotMara with a pinch of salt.

Seeing as to so many people sheeping him etc

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

Wow. That's a blatant misrep. Look at the stuff in between the bits you bolded and interpret that and it makes a lot more sense.

Anyway, the claim of PGO yesterday was a bit of a gambit and I used PGO last night.

VOTE: the irish pope

[Mutleyddmc]

that wasnt obvious siveure

[NotMara]

Treble, you so silly. As Siv said, read between the bold and you'll get something a lot different. First post you quoted wouldn't have come from scum if TIP is town, because there'd be no reason to try to avoid hopping on the wagon while acknowledging he's scummy like that. Second post you quoted wouldn't have come from scum if both TIP and Hana were also scum, because you would be lining up lynches on your scum partners.

We know Hana is town, so that leaves the possibility (if you're scum) of you being scum with a town TIP or a scum TIP. Based on those two posts, I think neither is likely. Therefore, you are town. Although, to be honest, your last post makes me rethink that. You just majorly misrepped me by literally ignoring some of what you quoted in favor of bolding some stuff out of context and calling it bad logic. You then said my case on TIP should be discarded because the misrep'd version of my case on you isn't good. lolwut? Don't be a TIP - if you want to attack my case, do so on its own merits.

Siv - that gambit was obvious and just a generally bad idea.

Also, Mutley, Generic is town. I promise. Both Hana and TIP tried to push stuff onto him all game. I'll give some examples after a TIP flip, but I seriously doubt Generic is scum at this point.

[Treble]

trebles' last post made me think scum-
ohwait that's us
we really should talk about these things ahead of time ok

[Mutleyddmc]

Treble problem is I know sak and TIP would happily double bus, and cross bus.

[NotMara]

Yes, but not in the way that TIP tried to direct pressure onto Generic at the start of day 2 through NK WIFOM - that was clearly preplanned, and bussing is rarely preplanned to that degree. Seriously doubt TIP and Generic are scum together.

Treble - you said you were waiting for another vote to be placed to hammer TIP, but you didn't vote in your last post while he's at L-1 (or state intent to hammer and ask for a claim). What gives?

Meanwhile, since I'm gone the next few days: If I'm not around when next day starts, pressure Treble quite a bit. Remaining scum after TIP is like 85% likely to be in {Treble, Sound of Silence} and 100% likely to be in {Treble, Sound of Silence, Siv}. BYE GUYS - GOING TO A THEME PARK NOW.

[Treble]

ah, so I guess something bad happened to your idea that "no way tip and treble could be scum together no way"
meh intent to hammer but we're liking notmara a lot less nowww...
and someone explain why it can't be taskmaster.

[TheIrishPope]

It's silly to think I'm scum. If you want me to counter Rob's case, fine. But don't speedlynch me just yet.

[Ms Marangal]

[Ms Marangal]

[Ms Marangal]

[Ms Marangal]

[Ms Marangal]

[Ms Marangal]