Mini 1476: Dewey Decimal Mafia (Game Over)

[Amrun]

It's certainly a possibility, don't you think? With everyone having a power role, I wouldn't be surprised.

I was going to raegbeast about this but I checked the OP first. I see what you're getting it, but it doesn't mean you're right.

Answer me this: if you thought everyone had a role, why did you expect a claim/use of power to save you?

[Jake from State Farm]

so me, you, flay all think kid is scum. all we need is 3 more and we got us a lynch

vote: kid

all aboard

[TheIrishPope]

@Amrun, I'm not saying I'm right. I literally said it's a possibility. Not going to answer your question just yet.
@Jake, if you promise to vote Ingrid tomorrow, sure.
VOTE: Kid

[Amrun]

Probably okay with kid lynch but.

I need to post about flay first, k?


Kid isn't like my go-to lynch, but he's been pretty scummy all game. Disliked his answering for spicer early on and his treatment of moz/jake slot has some legitimate weirdness. On the other hand, liked his post about Flay.

I think this game will crack right open with a flip or two. There have been some great interactions today.

[TheIrishPope]

You go girl. Flay goes down right after Ingrid.

[Amrun]

I think Ingrid is probably town.

[TheIrishPope]

Oh my... what did you smoke?
Why is Ingrid Town?

[TheIrishPope]

And don't tell me you townread her because I scumread her

[Amrun]

Nope. Just gutsies, plus her insistence on mass claim after negative pressure about it. Bad town, sure, but more likely to be town than scum. I'm not taking it to the bank, but not interested in lynching her today.

[TheIrishPope]

...
Weren't you the one pushing a policy lynch on me for being bad town?

[Amrun]

Nope. Not even a tiny little bit. Do you even read? Seriously? :/

Oh, and Mr. Flay -- I can't post what I want about you until after you detail your reads on me and tip in the manner I requested. (Well, I can, but I dont want it to affect what you say.) I know you tried, so I'm sorry I wasn't more clear originally.

[TheIrishPope]

UGH NOT THIS AGAIN
We went over this, Amrun: you were trying to policy lynch me

[Amrun]

Nope.

[TheIrishPope]

Do I have to wall quote again?

[Amrun]

P-edit:

Omg no

Lynch that

He might be a jester at this point but that still needs to be lynched so whatever

And now you lie, Amrun? Tsk tsk.

You have to be pretty high to interpret that as an advocation of policy lynching, in my opinion.

Even if you end up being town,

which I honestly doubt is the case anyway

, you can't be trusted in LyLo, so you have to go.

Need I quote more?

Nope.jpg

If I think you are so scummy that you might be being intentionally scummy because you are a jester, and if I think that you are probably not town, what does that tell you, if you use your brain instead of your AtE device?

Ingrid, buck up and be less useless.

Gorckat, if the only reason you want to PL tip is that he's hard to read, that's bad and you should feel bad.

This and SEVERAL other posts, one of them on like the last page, explicitly detail that I do not think you should be policy lynched, and instead lynched for being scummy.

There is no way my posts can be interpreted as pro-policy lynching you.

[Amrun]

Mr. Flay, I disagree with that one.

Gorckat has openly called it a policy lynch.

I don't think straight up policy lynch is the way to go, here -- yeah, he is probably a liability, but he did link to meta where he was effective. I think he is a better lynch than most others IF there is a reason to suspect he might be scum.

I think there's enough validity to calling him scum that I'm good with lynching him, but not if everyone else on the lynch is there purely for policy.

Try reading a tiny, tiny bit, tip. /sigh

[TheIrishPope]

Think early game. Not right now. You were trying to policy lynch me.

[Amrun]

I. Was. Not.

[TheIrishPope]

How would you describe it, then?

[Amrun]

I already described it, in detail, and then requoted some of it above. I only ever seriously advocated your lynch when I thought you were scum. We have already had this conversation. How did you draw such a wildly wrong conclusion from it?

[TheIrishPope]

We should have this conversation every once in a while, because I know I'm right and you're wrong
So, after Flay posts, you vote Kid?

[Amrun]

Depends on what he posts. Maybe.

[saulres]

Several sources report that Melvil Dewey's character was -- not sterling. They report his as being, among other things, Anti-Semitic and racist.

An example of the former: When he created The Lake Placid Club, a resort in the Adirondacks, he explicitly excluded Jews from membership. "No one shall be received as a member or guest, against whom there is ... race objection." The club said it was "impracticable to make exceptions to Jews or others excluded, even when of unusual personal qualifications." Dewey was challenged over this stance and eventually resigned his positions. --

Antisemitism: a historical encyclopedia of prejudice and persecution.

, edited by Richard S. Levy, found on Google books.

Vote Count 1.11

L-3 Kid A - Mr. Flay, Jake from State Farm

repl. mozamis

, TheIrishPope
L-5 Ingrid - Darox
L-5 spicer1209 -Amrun
L-5 Jake from State Farm

repl. mozamis

- notscience
L-5 TheIrishPope - Ingrid
L-5 Mr. Flay - Kid A
L-5 gorckat - spicer1209
L-5 notscience - gorckat
L-6 Amrun -
L-6 Darox -

Not voting:

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch

Deadline: (expired on 2013-08-05 22:23:44)

[Mr. Flay]

the reason gork pointed out about spicer was pretty good, you think dumb town would do that?

I don't understand the question?

With everyone having a power role, I wouldn't be surprised.

I think I see what you're doing here, but... ugh, as Darox would say.

Hey, flay, I might have misunderstood your view on TiP. See, earlier I thought you thought he was scum right around the time I did. Then, later, you seemed to be going along with gorckat's fence sitting. You openly agreed with him as he was saying it doesn't matter what alignment tip is, we should lynch him. This seemed like an odd reversal for someone who had said TiP was scum. But then when you detailed your read of him, you didn't mention this at all. Can you clarify?

I think the progression is pretty clear, though it might have worked better if I'd blended them together into one ISO. I didn't start worrying about you not actually being Town until a couple of days ago. Rereading only made it worse, though there's plenty of chance you're not scum (which is why I'm not voting you...yet; lots of richer targets for D1).

I can explain further I suppose, but I really feel like you're playing dumb right now.

Darox, does your shot end Day?

[Amrun]

Do you think TiP is scum? Why, if so?