Mafia 57: Good Ol' Mafia - Game over!

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Ok, I'm finally beginning to be able to put together a theory.

Let's say for the sake of theorizing that TCS is indeed the sole vig. Why, you ask, did Panzer claim vig first then? I think it's entirely possible that all the mafia buddies put their heads together and came up with a plan for confusing the town. They decide that they will have Panzer claim vig, and then go from there, with some of the mafia supporting Panzer, while others go against him to keep adding on to the confusion.

Hmm, it's kinda shaky sounding, but it's the best I can think of right now. TCS, if we were to lynch Panzer today, who would your second choice for tonight's kill be?

Thoughts people?

Although from the perspective of you guys, it's probably better to lynch a third party and let me and panzer vig it out, if you were to lynch panzerjager tonight I would probably vig JDodge... I am utterly convinced of his scumminess. My next choices would be SL or Twito.

[PJ.]

Ok let's move on.

Vote:RafK

[Twito]

Well, first of all, can i please ask for a

VoteCount

as we havent had one in the last few pages.
Anyway, my brief analysis so far, is that Blue Gatorade is as scummy as hell.
Not only has he only made 1 post since my death, the post he did make only said: "sorry ive been quiet, ill post something useful tonight".
No such post came.
In fact, even the Mod didnt realise he was lurking for a while, and forgot to prod him.
Also, he followed CDB in trying to wagon me on Day 1. Im thinking we got a noob-scum here who wants to go unnoticed.

Vote: Blue Gatorade

I just replaced Blue Gatorade in a game I'm modding he really isn't on the site meaning he isn't lurking. I also earlier pointed out this post missing. That vote is stupid.

MOD:

Can we get Blue Gatorade replaced?

[Twito]

Sorry for trouble mod as he has been replaced.

[Twito]

Vote: Ancalagon

I know that you have just walked right into a scum role. Enjoy your lynch.

Reasons for this vote?

Ok, I'm finally beginning to be able to put together a theory.

Let's say for the sake of theorizing that TCS is indeed the sole vig. Why, you ask, did Panzer claim vig first then? I think it's entirely possible that all the mafia buddies put their heads together and came up with a plan for confusing the town. They decide that they will have Panzer claim vig, and then go from there, with some of the mafia supporting Panzer, while others go against him to keep adding on to the confusion.

Hmm, it's kinda shaky sounding, but it's the best I can think of right now. TCS, if we were to lynch Panzer today, who would your second choice for tonight's kill be?

Thoughts people?

Your scummy.

Say we have 8 total mafia, 1 SK, 1 vig, 1 doc, 1 cop, and 12 townies. That seems pretty reasonable to me.

Pretty much what I said earlier. I could understand more than one cop role tho. And possible RB aswell.

TCS and panzer agree to vig each other or be lynched. This is not difficult. How many people do you need to tell you that targetting each other is the town's best play? Sheesh. We have enough scum suspects around without the real vig refusing to take out the fake vig (whichever one of you is the real and whichever one is the fake).

Once we have both of your agreements on that, we can move the hell on with this day to deciding who to actually lynch.

QFT!

Panzer are you willing to "vig" TCS tonight?
TCS has told to be ready to vig you.
This would make things so much easier for us town.

Ok let's move on.

Vote:RafK

I'm not voting for Panzer because I have agreed to vig him tonight.

Thank god finally.
Now stick to this. Excuse me if I'm not fully trusting either of you atm. If atleast one is a real vig stick to the plan and get the scum lynched. If one of you is the real vig I believe it's Panzer. Now Panzer you must understand that trading vigilante for scum is a good trade.

Note: TCS has switched his stance from "I've decided that I'm not going to vig Panzerjager." to this "I'm not voting for Panzer because I have agreed to vig him tonight." which he needed it as his defence. It's very obvious TCS is scum.

Now we can move on. I'm looking for my next suspect. I'm feeling Canuckle lynch. If and when I guess TCS turns out scum and if I'm not around please LYNCH CANUCKLE for me tomorrow.

[Twito]

That being said I'm gonna

unvote

for now.

[PJ.]

The post that I voted RafK in was a confirmation. I was lazy but it should have read "I'll vig him so how about we move on to a Rafk lynch".

[Twito]

Good, though so. I'm not sure if I agree about RafK lynch yet tho. I'll vote again tomorrow.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

lol Twito I'm going to be so happy to see you wrong... except that I'll be dead.

[Twito]

lol Twito I'm going to be so happy to see you wrong... except that I'll be dead.

Why do you want to see me wrong? Wanting to see Twito wrong is definitely scummy!

[Battle Mage]

in response to Twito's questioning of my vote:

Well, first of all, can i please ask for a

VoteCount

as we havent had one in the last few pages.
Anyway, my brief analysis so far, is that Blue Gatorade is as scummy as hell.
Not only has he only made 1 post since my death, the post he did make only said: "sorry ive been quiet, ill post something useful tonight".
No such post came.
In fact, even the Mod didnt realise he was lurking for a while, and forgot to prod him.
Also, he followed CDB in trying to wagon me on Day 1. Im thinking we got a noob-scum here who wants to go unnoticed.

Vote: Blue Gatorade

I suggest that everyone considers this. Its such an obvious scum-kill, that we would have to be stupid to pass it up. Vote Ancalagon today.

[JDodge]

in response to Twito's questioning of my vote:

Well, first of all, can i please ask for a

VoteCount

as we havent had one in the last few pages.
Anyway, my brief analysis so far, is that Blue Gatorade is as scummy as hell.
Not only has he only made 1 post since my death, the post he did make only said: "sorry ive been quiet, ill post something useful tonight".
No such post came.
In fact, even the Mod didnt realise he was lurking for a while, and forgot to prod him.
Also, he followed CDB in trying to wagon me on Day 1. Im thinking we got a noob-scum here who wants to go unnoticed.

Vote: Blue Gatorade

I suggest that everyone considers this. Its such an obvious scum-kill, that we would have to be stupid to pass it up. Vote Ancalagon today.

Actually, it's an obvious OMGUS from you. You showed that yourself when you said "Also, he followed CDB in trying to wagon me on Day 1. Im thinking we got a noob-scum here who wants to go unnoticed."

[The Central Scrutinizer]

in response to Twito's questioning of my vote:

Well, first of all, can i please ask for a

VoteCount

as we havent had one in the last few pages.
Anyway, my brief analysis so far, is that Blue Gatorade is as scummy as hell.
Not only has he only made 1 post since my death, the post he did make only said: "sorry ive been quiet, ill post something useful tonight".
No such post came.
In fact, even the Mod didnt realise he was lurking for a while, and forgot to prod him.
Also, he followed CDB in trying to wagon me on Day 1. Im thinking we got a noob-scum here who wants to go unnoticed.

Vote: Blue Gatorade

I suggest that everyone considers this. Its such an obvious scum-kill, that we would have to be stupid to pass it up. Vote Ancalagon today.

Actually, it's an obvious OMGUS from you. You showed that yourself when you said "Also, he followed CDB in trying to wagon me on Day 1. Im thinking we got a noob-scum here who wants to go unnoticed."

Bad, bad logic. It's not really an OMGUS because we know that the original incarnation of Battle Mage was innocent. If a third party that wasn't Battle Mage 2 had brought up the same point, it would not be an OMGUS, and the point would be valid. So is the point not valid because the same person is bringing up his own innocent lynch? We should treat them as separate players, because for the purposes of this game, they are.

[JDodge]

Bad, bad logic. It's not really an OMGUS because we know that the original incarnation of Battle Mage was innocent. If a third party that wasn't Battle Mage 2 had brought up the same point, it would not be an OMGUS, and the point would be valid. So is the point not valid because the same person is bringing up his own innocent lynch? We should treat them as separate players, because for the purposes of this game, they are.

Right... Sorry. Forgot he was two different people.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Bad, bad logic. It's not really an OMGUS because we know that the original incarnation of Battle Mage was innocent. If a third party that wasn't Battle Mage 2 had brought up the same point, it would not be an OMGUS, and the point would be valid. So is the point not valid because the same person is bringing up his own innocent lynch? We should treat them as separate players, because for the purposes of this game, they are.

Right... Sorry. Forgot he was two different people.

Well, I suppose at least Shadowlurker would be convinced you're town now... he seems to think forgetting who was lynched/NK'd is a town tell.

[Ancalagon]

Ok, I've caught up...


*pant*

BM, what makes you think I'm an obvious scum lynch?

[Battle Mage]

ive pretty much summed it up in my last post.
Sorry, but you've walked into a situation where little you can say will make me change my mind about you being scum, because in my mind the evidence is quite conclusive.
BM

Ok, I've caught up...


*pant*

BM, what makes you think I'm an obvious scum lynch?

[Ancalagon]

So since BG was completely forgot about the game, I must be scum.

Logical.

[Canucklehead17]

So since BG was completely forgot about the game, I must be scum.

Logical.

Yeah, welcome to the game.

BM, Blue Gatorade was not lurking, he's was inactive. This is evident in his replacement. Therefore, you being so jumpy on the guy who takes his spot makes no sense whatsoever, and you being so eager about it raises you way up on my scumdar.

Since it appears TCS and Panzer are agreeable to vigging each other tonight...

unvote, vote: BM

[Canucklehead17]

Ok, I'm finally beginning to be able to put together a theory.

Let's say for the sake of theorizing that TCS is indeed the sole vig. Why, you ask, did Panzer claim vig first then? I think it's entirely possible that all the mafia buddies put their heads together and came up with a plan for confusing the town. They decide that they will have Panzer claim vig, and then go from there, with some of the mafia supporting Panzer, while others go against him to keep adding on to the confusion.

Hmm, it's kinda shaky sounding, but it's the best I can think of right now. TCS, if we were to lynch Panzer today, who would your second choice for tonight's kill be?

Thoughts people?

Your scummy.

Sigh, you're impossible. I'm not scum, and to be honest, I have no idea why you think I am. But that's not unusual for you to just declare one scum and then vote for them is it?

[TheJiveMachine]

Okay, so TCS and Panzer are 'vigging' each other tonight. That takes care of the two people at the top of the scum-o-meter.

Canucklehead's theory doesn't make much sense. Why would the mafia tell Panzer to claim so early in the day? They must have known that it would be perceived as a scumtell and probably even get him lynched. I'm behind the theory that either Panzer or TCS is an SK.

Also,

Sorry, but you've walked into a situation where little you can say will make me change my mind about you being scum, because in my mind the evidence is quite conclusive.

Vote: Battle Mage.

Do I really need to explain?

[JDodge]

I could go with a BM lynch, provided TCS and Panzer "vig" each other tonight.

unvote, vote: Battle Mage

[Twito]

in response to Twito's questioning of my vote:

Well, first of all, can i please ask for a

VoteCount

as we havent had one in the last few pages.
Anyway, my brief analysis so far, is that Blue Gatorade is as scummy as hell.
Not only has he only made 1 post since my death, the post he did make only said: "sorry ive been quiet, ill post something useful tonight".
No such post came.
In fact, even the Mod didnt realise he was lurking for a while, and forgot to prod him.
Also, he followed CDB in trying to wagon me on Day 1. Im thinking we got a noob-scum here who wants to go unnoticed.

Vote: Blue Gatorade

I suggest that everyone considers this. Its such an obvious scum-kill, that we would have to be stupid to pass it up. Vote Ancalagon today.

You are voting him blaming him of lurking. Which just isn't truth and him being replaced proves this.
Or if you are voting him based on being replaced maybe you should think about the fact that you yourself have been replaced twise already in this game.

FoS: BM

Ok, I've caught up...


*pant*

BM, what makes you think I'm an obvious scum lynch?

That's all you have to say after catching up with the whole game?

FoS: Ancalagon

Sigh, you're impossible. I'm not scum, and to be honest, I have no idea why you think I am. But that's not unusual for you to just declare one scum and then vote for them is it?

No it's actually not unusual for me. Being right about them isn't unusual for me either.

Vote: Canuckle

for being scum.

[Twito]

TheJiveMachine and JDodge, since I know you have both played with BM in the past those votes look scummy.

Btw I really don't like the way BM replaced in to a game where he has already played. This simply shouldn't happen.

[Twito]

That being said I might even be willing to go with BM lynch just so he isn't here to confuse us. I'm totally againts what mod did in this game but what mod says is the law so..